2012 Player/s X v Player/s Y

[BLUES9898]

defender rookie (not marty clarke or brandon ellis) + Kreuzer + Barlow + Hawkins/Darling
or
Jake Carlisle + Leuenberger + Morabito + N.Riewoldt

The first list. Kruzer+rookie defender+Barlow+Hawkins

My question

J.brown and $65.300 + A.christensen and $106.400

 

[BLUES9898]

Wingard or T. Mitchell?

Secondly, an extension of that question, which option out of the following?

1. Enright, Wingard, Saad
2. Broughton, T. Mitchell, Porplyzia

Thanks

I'd pick enright wingard and saad as porplyzia is a bit of a risk Mitchell may not get game time and broughton may play back pocket alot

 

[MrZregory]

The first list. Kruzer+rookie defender+Barlow+Hawkins

My question

J.brown and $65.300 + A.christensen and $106.400

Christensen and save the extra cash, so you can upgrade him to a premium later on

 

[MrZregory]

Swallow (NM) and Didak (Coll) OR Swan (Coll) and Walsh (syd)/Porplyzia (ade)

 

[John Flake]

Definitely Swan, but no idea on the others. I've gone Didak, but all three are a risk. Maybe Swan and someone else.

J. Brown or H. Ballantyne?

Cheers,

 

[back2cat]

Definitely Swan, but no idea on the others. I've gone Didak, but all three are a risk. Maybe Swan and someone else.

J. Brown or H. Ballantyne?

Cheers,

id go brown over ballantyne

cant decide between swan and swallow so i took them both

would stay clear of didak and the porpoise

 

[Jordie_tackles]

Wingard or T. Mitchell?

Secondly, an extension of that question, which option out of the following?

1. Enright, Wingard, Saad
2. Broughton, T. Mitchell, Porplyzia

Thanks

Simply because i dont know if Saad will play or how he will score.

I also think i like Mitchell, BUT dont think Sydney play many first year players from round 1 historically.....although he seems to be a better class than what they normally get with their first round selection.

I like Mitchell because he is 50K cheaper not really any better per se

 

[Jordie_tackles]

The first list. Kruzer+rookie defender+Barlow+Hawkins

My question

J.brown and $65.300 + A.christensen and $106.400

would take Brown if he performs in the NAB

 

[V_23]

1. Ellis or Morris? (Both Richmond Rookies. Is one more of a shutdown defender and one is a good ball user?)

2. A Port Adelaide player or try for the overall prize?

 

[Jordie_tackles]

1. Ellis or Morris? (Both Richmond Rookies. Is one more of a shutdown defender and one is a good ball user?)

2. A Port Adelaide player or try for the overall prize?

People are talking about Morris being the shutdown tagger type, Ellis as more of a HBF type = goodness

I would also try and go for the main prize and avoid all Port players

 

[John Flake]

1. Ellis or Morris? (Both Richmond Rookies. Is one more of a shutdown defender and one is a good ball user?)

2. A Port Adelaide player or try for the overall prize?

I've got $710,00 left. Should I pick Pendlebury, Ablett, Swan or the entire Port Adelaide list?

 

[back2cat]

I've got $710,00 left. Should I pick Pendlebury, Ablett, Swan or the entire Port Adelaide list?

HaHaHa

Ablett of course

 

[back2cat]

People are talking about Morris being the shutdown tagger type, Ellis as more of a HBF type = goodness

I would also try and go for the main prize and avoid all Port players

port adelaide are rubbish but robbie gray is excellent value

 

[SSSSSS]

Priddis + Barlow VS Swan + Wingard and Grimes Upgraded to Shaw

 

[Jordie_tackles]

Priddis + Barlow VS Swan + Wingard and Grimes Upgraded to Shaw

So Priddis + Barlow + Grimes

vs

Swan + Wingard + Shaw

Just the second option, pretty eve on points but Wingard will make you some cash imo

 

[back2cat]

So Priddis + Barlow + Grimes

vs

Swan + Wingard + Shaw

Just the second option, pretty eve on points but Wingard will make you some cash imo

Id agree

is anyone else concerned with grimes being able to stay injury free?

 

[Jordie_tackles]

Id agree

is anyone else concerned with grimes being able to stay injury free?

I am going to back him in, his last injury was very much unfortunate, nothing tissue or his back. It was a freak break in his foot, and his is tipped to play NAB. Then again the ame injury ended Mathews Egans career no?

 

[back2cat]

I am going to back him in, his last injury was very much unfortunate, nothing tissue or his back. It was a freak break in his foot, and his is tipped to play NAB. Then again the ame injury ended Mathews Egans career no?

yeah, still makes me sad to think of mark egan, should be a multiple premiership player

hope grimes plays a long and fruitful career

 

[pbesson1992]

Option 1 - rookie as 7th defender + lenny hayes as 4th mid + winderlich as 6th fwd

Option 2 - rookie as 7th defender + priddis as 4th mid + rookie as 6th fwd

Option 3 - Bock as 5th defender + coniglio as 4th mid + rookie as 6th fwd

what does everyone think?

 

[Jordie_tackles]

Option 1 - rookie as 7th defender + lenny hayes as 4th mid + winderlich as 6th fwd

Option 2 - rookie as 7th defender + priddis as 4th mid + rookie as 6th fwd

Option 3 - Bock as 5th defender + coniglio as 4th mid + rookie as 6th fwd

what does everyone think?

Could you stretch him to Barlow? if so a big yes, still think option 1 is the best regardless though

 

[pbesson1992]

Could you stretch him to Barlow? if so a big yes, still think option 1 is the best regardless though

I could downgrade bock to grimes as 4th defender and then get barlow for hayes? opinions?

 

[Hawkthorn33]

Having a dilemma here guys, would appreciate your thoughts..

Sylvia/ Cloke and Masten

OR

J. Brown and Dangerfield / Scully

 

[Jordie_tackles]

Having a dilemma here guys, would appreciate your thoughts..

Sylvia/ Cloke and Masten

OR

J. Brown and Dangerfield / Scully

Sylvia has aclub imposed ban round 1 and maybe 2, but i think only round 1

This probably changes things for you

I also wouldnt pick any of the highlighted in the midfield, wont be top 8 at the end of the season

 

[timbo3195]

My big dilemma is do I want 4 Premiums in the Mids (Ablett, Swan, Murphy, Selwood) and 1 premium in the ruck (Mumford, Giles).

OR do I go with 3 Premiums(Ablett, Swan, Selwood) and 3 Rookies in the Mids and have 2 Premiums in the Ruck (Mumford, Leuenberger)

Turns out to be something like this:

Scotland, Zorko, Leuenberger VS Broughton, M.Murphy, Giles (Starting)

 

[Ex President]

Option 1 - rookie as 7th defender + lenny hayes as 4th mid + winderlich as 6th fwd

Option 2 - rookie as 7th defender + priddis as 4th mid + rookie as 6th fwd

Option 3 - Bock as 5th defender + coniglio as 4th mid + rookie as 6th fwd

what does everyone think?

Option 2. Hayes/Winderlich/Coniglio you are paying too much for.