2013 Player/s X versus Y

[toxic]

This is for next week, Minson vs Goldstein.

Okay they are polar opposites,

Goldtein has 3 or 4 others who can take his spot or share his time in the ruck, North expected to make the 8 - clearly this isnt going to happen, as a result they will test players in regards to the list next year as well as send players early for off season surgery
Doggies however have only 2 options for the ruck - Minson and Tom Liberatore. Doggies never had any hope or dillusion of making the 8 - so there desire to rest is less.

For me - Minson is miles ahead of Goldy

 

[Zach Package]

Jack v JPK v Jelwood v Mundy v Fyfe

 

[Super Hans]

Jack v JPK v Jelwood v Mundy v Fyfe

JPK. Gun.

 

[Zach Package]

JPK. Gun.

was leaning that way, all i'm doing now is psyching myself out.

He's also dirt freakin cheap as well

 

[Ed_Gein]

Okay they are polar opposites,

Goldtein has 3 or 4 others who can take his spot or share his time in the ruck, North expected to make the 8 - clearly this isnt going to happen, as a result they will test players in regards to the list next year as well as send players early for off season surgery
Doggies however have only 2 options for the ruck - Minson and Tom Liberatore. Doggies never had any hope or dillusion of making the 8 - so there desire to rest is less.

For me - Minson is miles ahead of Goldy

Am i missing something here? Minson miles ahead of Goldstein? There is only like 3 points in difference when you look at their averages and by far the best 2 'pure' ruckman when you remove the F/R combo of NN/Cox. It's a flip of the coin job, you couldn't go wrong either way.

 

[toxic]

Am i missing something here? Minson miles ahead of Goldstein? There is only like 3 points in difference when you look at their averages and by far the best 2 'pure' ruckman when you remove the F/R combo of NN/Cox. It's a flip of the coin job, you couldn't go wrong either way.

Not about history, its about going fwd and team direction for mind, and there averages from NOW onwards, hence my comment

 

[Super Hans]

Not about history, its about going fwd and team direction for mind, and there averages from NOW onwards, hence my comment

Minson having Melbourne x2 and GWS to come has him infront for me atm.

 

[Ed_Gein]

Not about history, its about going fwd and team direction for mind, and there averages from NOW onwards, hence my comment

Point taken, i still don't think the difference is going to be that great. At the moment Petrie, Daw and the likes so far haven't really had an impact on Goldstein's scoring, they'll give him a chop out for 5 minutes a qtr at most. To be honest, i'd be more worried about Minson being burnt out as the year goes on.

 

[Obese Arachnid]

Jack v JPK v Jelwood v Mundy v Fyfe

All the way with JPK!

 

[Super Hans]

Harvey vs Martin.

 

[tracygrimshaw]

Harvey vs Martin.

Martin is still getting better.. Harvey can only get worse.

Cotchin v Selwood?

 

[toxic]

Martin is still getting better.. Harvey can only get worse.

Cotchin v Selwood?

Which selwood? Joel or Scott?

 

[christoff91]

JSelwood, Jack, Deledio or Barlow? Please help!

 

[Zach Package]

JSelwood, Jack, Deledio or Barlow? Please help!

I'd go Jack. Super consistent

 

[Zach Package]

here's my dilemma. Mids are currently: Gaz, Pendles, Griffen, Danger, Smitchell, Cotchin, Hannebery, TMitchell, KMartin, Blicavs. 1 upgrade left, 200k in the bank. Should I...

Go Blitz to Jelwood now? Or any premo under 520ish for that matter
Wait a week for blitz to rise one more time then turf him for JPK after r13?
Downgrade Ben Kennedy to Daniher or Menzel and then Upgrade Blicavs to Swan before his price makes him ungettable for me?

Thoughts pls

 

[Super Hans]

JSelwood, Jack, Deledio or Barlow? Please help!

Barlow or Jack, I'd go Barlow.

 

[Super Hans]

here's my dilemma. Mids are currently: Gaz, Pendles, Griffen, Danger, Smitchell, Cotchin, Hannebery, TMitchell, KMartin, Blicavs. 1 upgrade left, 200k in the bank. Should I...

Go Blitz to Jelwood now? Or any premo under 520ish for that matter
Wait a week for blitz to rise one more time then turf him for JPK after r13?
Downgrade Ben Kennedy to Daniher or Menzel and then Upgrade Blicavs to Swan before his price makes him ungettable for me?

Thoughts pls

I think you have to go the option that gets you Swan, he should average 125+ for the rest of the season.

 

[toxic]

Kieran Jack or Joel Selwood??

Jelwood will give me almost the same average for the rest of the year and is 70K cheaper...

Jack is an untapped superstar but i do worry a tad that with the emergence of Tmit his pints may be slightly diluted

last spot will complete my mids for now:
Pendles, Cotchin, Watson, JPK, Hannaberry, Barlow, GAJ, Kmart & Tmit ++++ one other..

 

[frozensage]

franklin or goldstein?

current fwd: sj, bartel, cox, rock, martin, rowe, neade, staker

would franklin complete the f6 or i should just go someone like a nicnat?

 

[BuddysBuddy23]

Kieran Jack or Joel Selwood??

Jelwood will give me almost the same average for the rest of the year and is 70K cheaper...

Jack is an untapped superstar but i do worry a tad that with the emergence of Tmit his pints may be slightly diluted

last spot will complete my mids for now:
Pendles, Cotchin, Watson, JPK, Hannaberry, Barlow, GAJ, Kmart & Tmit ++++ one other..

Im liking Jack. However you cant pass up on Selwood at his current price. I'd go Selwood due to price. I'll be getting Selwood this week.

My dilemma this week is i need to trade out Murph. Who to bring in though? I only have 512k to spend unless i use my third trade for a downgrade(I'd rather not however). So who is below that price worth picking up? My SC page isnt working for whatever reason so i cannot check prices myself. Is there any fallen premos worth picking up for under 512k? Keeping in mind i'll already be getting Selwood? Or use the third trade and bring in anyone i want?

Thoughts?

 

[toxic]

Im liking Jack. However you cant pass up on Selwood at his current price. I'd go Selwood due to price. I'll be getting Selwood this week.

My dilemma this week is i need to trade out Murph. Who to bring in though? I only have 512k to spend unless i use my third trade for a downgrade(I'd rather not however). So who is below that price worth picking up? My SC page isnt working for whatever reason so i cannot check prices myself. Is there any fallen premos worth picking up for under 512k? Keeping in mind i'll already be getting Selwood? Or use the third trade and bring in anyone i want?

Thoughts?

Kane Cornes is an interesting option at that price range - average of 115+ but he is from Port

 

[BuddysBuddy23]

Kane Cornes is an interesting option at that price range - average of 115+ but he is from Port

Considering Cornes heavily. Just not entirely sold due to the jumper he wears and the run he has had!

 

[Knighta21]

Also looking at K Cornes, would be decent POD

 

[freoman87]

jack v deledio

bartel v walker

????

 

[Super Hans]

jack v deledio

bartel v walker

????

Jack and Bartel.