List Mgmt. 2015 TRADE discussion

[d33my]

Seb Ross, Daniel Mcstay, Spencer White, Patrick Karnezis, Aaron Black, Jack Redden, Tom Collier, Nathan Djerkurra, Wayde Mills, Adam Hartlett

Last 10 number 25 picks excluding last year
Relax people

Who was last year? It was Nathan Fyfe, wasn't it.

 

[Topkent]

Who was last year? It was Nathan Fyfe, wasn't it.

Hamish Hartlett I believe

 

[Sock045]

Hamish Hartlett I believe

Nope a kid called Daniel Neilson

 

[A11dAtP0w3R]

Nope a kid called Daniel Neilson

Thnx Mr. Srs

 

[Sylvia Saint]

Anderson has been overhyped on here. If he was that good then he would have played more than 10 games in three seasons, Hawthorn or no Hawthorn. Fringe player at elite club does not necessarily = regular at another club. I think a first round pick going the other way is a win for the Hawks at this stage.

 

[Topkent]

Nope a kid called Daniel Neilson

 

[TheCount]

Seb Ross, Daniel Mcstay, Spencer White, Patrick Karnezis, Aaron Black, Jack Redden, Tom Collier, Nathan Djerkurra, Wayde Mills, Adam Hartlett

Last 10 number 25 picks excluding last year
Relax people

Between 2008 and 2012 (too soon on '13 and '14) i count 15 from 50 players drafted in the 20's who are Best 22, with another 4-5 who are close. Not a sure thing ... if nothing else, Melksham keeps M.Jones and Terlich at Casey.

 

[PerfectFooty]

Anderson has been overhyped on here. If he was that good then he would have played more than 10 games in three seasons, Hawthorn or no Hawthorn. Fringe player at elite club does not necessarily = regular at another club. I think a first round pick going the other way is a win for the Hawks at this stage.

Really i'd rate Kennedy from what i've seen slightly higher than Anderson. But because Hawthorn are premiers, and collingwood with our trade history with them everyone seems to think Kennedy = Spud and Anderson = Gem

 

[Topkent]

Between 2008 and 2012 (too soon on '13 and '14) i count 15 from 50 players drafted in the 20's who are Best 22, with another 4-5 who are close. Not a sure thing ... if nothing else, Melksham keeps M.Jones and Terlich at Casey.

Im not saying you should trade the pick everytime either, we have done quite well with all our picks lately, but 25 for a bloke who will probably play another 100 games for us against someone who might not play 20 isnt worth burning your membership over

 

[Sir Hugh Percy]

But then Richmond just went and got Jacob Townsend for pick 70...

 

[TheCount]

Im not saying you should trade the pick everytime either, we have done quite well with all our picks lately, but 25 for a bloke who will probably play another 100 games for us against someone who might not play 20 isnt worth burning your membership over

For sure, if the talent is there, but as I said in an earlier post: With the noted lack of depth in this draft, should we end up with #29 for Toump, it's likely the player we'd take will be the same or be just as speculative as #25.

 

[A11dAtP0w3R]

But then Richmond just went and got Jacob Townsend for pick 70...

Words can't describe how mad this makes me. Seriously what in the world is going on?

Pick 70 for Townsend while we give 25 for Melksham.

This is seriously, seriously a ****ed up world we live in, being a Melbourne supporter, never ever again.

 

[TheCount]

But then Richmond just went and got Jacob Townsend for pick 70...

They did have to throw in #120 tho! ...

 

[A11dAtP0w3R]

Its like ever other club is giving each other hand jobs but we are forced to sit in the corner and wank ourselves.

 

[Sock045]

FU

 

[Topkent]

Thats a little annoying because you know GWS will end up passing on pick 70 anyway

So Choko williams is really helping the tigers steal some talent from there, we should have been asking Dom and Frosty about any gems there

 

[TheCount]

Words can't describe how mad this makes me. Seriously what in the world is going on?

Pick 70 for Townsend while we give 25 for Melksham.

This is seriously, seriously a stuffed up world we live in, being a Melbourne supporter, never ever again.

Townsend has played 28 unremarkable games in 4 seasons, with just the 1 this year. I've also seen him in the NEAFL a fair bit ... and he's just as unremarkable there, disposals in the teens with a goal ... and that's in a side winning most games by 10-20 goals every week. If he plays more than a game or two for Richmond I'll be shocked

 

[A11dAtP0w3R]

In other news, Cam McCarthy showing everyone what a little bitch he is, i read that mile out.

Hope he goes to Freo and they pay him a fortune anyway, only doing us a favour.

 

[wheaters31]

I really don't want to lose out on Gold Coast's pick 3 because of Howe's nomination of the pies so......

By trying to keep things realistic to benefit all clubs, would this work?:
Melbourne give: Howe-->Collingwood
Pick 64-->Collingwood
Pick 6-->Gold Coast
Gold Coast give: Pick 3-->Melbourne
Collingwood give: Pick 26-->Gold Coast
Ben Kennedy-->Melbourne

Melbourne receive: Pick 3, Kennedy
Gold Coast receive: Pick 6, Pick 26
Collingwood Receive: Howe, Pick 64

 

[Topkent]

In other news, Cam McCarthy showing everyone what a little bitch he is, i read that mile out.

Hope he goes to Freo and they pay him a fortune anyway, only doing us a favour.

I would trade pick 25 to GWS to let Cam McCarthy go

 

[A11dAtP0w3R]

Townsend has played 28 unremarkable games in 4 seasons, with just the 1 this year. I've also seen him in the NEAFL a fair bit ... and he's just as unremarkable there, disposals in the teens with a goal ... and that's in a side winning most games by 10-20 goals every week. If he plays more than a game or two for Richmond I'll be shocked

He's been injured for a fair chunk of it to be fair. Plays hard, thats what i like about him, could have played a forward defensive role with us IMO, health permitting.

For pick 70, give me him over 25 for Melksham every single time.

 

[Topkent]

I really don't want to lose out on Gold Coast's pick 3 because of Howe's nomination of the pies so......

By trying to keep things realistic to benefit all clubs, would this work?:
Melbourne give: Howe-->Collingwood
Pick 64-->Collingwood
Pick 6-->Gold Coast
Gold Coast give: Pick 3-->Melbourne
Collingwood give: Pick 26-->Gold Coast
Ben Kennedy-->Melbourne

Melbourne receive: Pick 3, Kennedy
Gold Coast receive: Pick 6, Pick 26
Collingwood Receive: Howe, Pick 64

I like it but no way GC does that, they dont need 2 more kids at the club they want senior talent

 

[PerfectFooty]

Dirt is worth more than pick 70 in this draft which is why i'm surprised GWS didn't demand more. but then again maybe GWS really don't care for him leaving at all

 

[Theo X]

So, what position does Ben Kennedy play if we do indeed pick him up? he is pretty small, hobbit like.

He's like a younger midget version of Ro Bail, so wherever he played.

 

[Topkent]

Dirt is worth more than pick 70 in this draft which is why i'm surprised GWS didn't demand more. but then again maybe GWS really don't care for him leaving at all

GWS are culling their list, think I heard somewhere they still need to cut 8 players from the list this year or something so its pretty much delisting him early