List Mgmt. 2015 Trade, Free agency and draft rumours

[bradburygold]

Insurance that can forward, back, ruck and whipping boy all at one rock bottom price.

Great point, not many mentioning that he can pinch in ruck, certainly valuable option possibly moreso than roughead nowadays, versatile just as clarko likes 'em!

 

[Ned Ryerson]

Still not sure how I feel about letting go of Anderson. The kid will be an absolute jet. He has the highest ceiling of any youngster on our list.

But Carlisle in, means out spine is set for 5 years.

Torn.

It makes me rest easier knowing that if our system couldn't get him motivated enough to reach his potential then it will take a hell of a lot from most other clubs.

 

[Hawkas1988]

Boys and girls if we pull this off this is huge.

Hawthorn haven't been in the position for years to draft quality KPP's. They are the hardest to find. With Frawley and Carlisle we are set for a longtime in regards to KPD's.

Midfielders are easier to grab. You need your spine healthy before you can achieve anything and the Hawks are going about this perfectly given the position we are in!

Wrighty and Clarko just get it done!

Hopefully this goes through!

 

[Mr Meeseeks]

Jed has to agree aswell yeah?

 

[hawksrule111]

definitely a good deal if we can make it happen....

still not sure about Carlisle's attitude....leadership group would need to keep him in check......but no doubt he is a talent, and pretty much perfect replacement for Lakey....defence sured up for another crack at it....!

and still worried trading out Anderson could come back to haunt us....but i guess you alwasy think that

I think the question is, if we get in Carlisle next year and win another premiership is that a risk we are willing to take vs watching Jed become a gun in the times we are back to rebuilding?

 

[Zurs]

Still not sure how I feel about letting go of Anderson. The kid will be an absolute jet. He has the highest ceiling of any youngster on our list.

But Carlisle in, means out spine is set for 5 years.

Torn.

Easier to pick up a jet midfielder than a KPP. Just need to pick up O'Meara or a Shiel next year. Reckon that is how they are thinking??

 

[Hawkas1988]

? what was it

"Hawks are the good looking bloke who rocks up at the end of the party and picks up the girl you've been tuning for 3 hours"

 

[Gold Member]

As good as done.

Our hierarchy and even all Hawks on Bigfooty know the Pelican's MO, draft, draft, draft...

 

[The Lemon]

Jed has to agree aswell yeah?

who ****ing cares. yes he has

 

[Gold Member]

Actually, anyone who has a heartbeat can read Pelican like a book.

 

[Lethality]

I think the question is, if we get in Carlisle next year and win another premiership is that a risk we are willing to take vs watching Jed become a gun in the times we are back to rebuilding?

They're basically the same age.

 

[bigblackboz]

mmmmmm I got abused about a month ago when I said you guys were massively into him. Funny how things change in supporters opinions.

 

[hawksrule111]

They're basically the same age.

Indeed, Jed isn't in our best 22 though, Carlisle certainly would be

 

[seysearles]

We are also signing this bloke as a delisted FA to 'replace' Hale. I had never heard of him.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jack_Fitzpatrick

Reminding me of the days we signed Jared Boumann and Wayde Skipper.

Supposedly he is an elite endurance athlete in the Mark Blicavs mould.

 

[tige19]

Jed has to agree aswell yeah?

He's agreed to go to North.. It's formalities now, deal will be complete this arvo.

 

[Hawthorn United]

Supposedly he is an elite endurance athlete in the Mark Blicavs mould.

View attachment 184502

Thankfully lunch time is over.

 

[Lethality]

What happens if Carlisle has to serve a suspension for 2 years?

 

[Davo-27]

Supposedly he is an elite endurance athlete in the Mark Blicavs mould.

View attachment 184502

yea but you gotta remember, he would be our 4th picked, back-up Ruckman, all he has to do is stay healthy for a couple of years whilst Pittonet developes then if he isnt anywhere near the AFL standard we can move him on, no harm, no foul, if we get injuries he can be the meat-shield Ruckman.....

 

[walhawk]

What happens if Carlisle has to serve a suspension for 2 years?

Heatherley plays more games next year.

 

[Mr Meeseeks]

who ******* cares. yes he has

Whats your problem? Obviously he has to agree or the trade cant be done hero.

He's agreed to go to North.. It's formalities now, deal will be complete this arvo.

Cheers

 

[diggydig]

Your board's thoughts on Anderson for 15 from our perspective? I'm of the opinion that it's very slightly overs, but I still think he's likely to be as good, if not better, than any kid we pick at 15 regardless.

When looking at the quality A Graders we are about to lose to age (Mitchel, Hodge, Burgoyne), I thought the only young player on our list with the talent to fill one of those roles was Anderson.

The question on Anderson is whether his body can tolerate the workload and his tough style of play. Was extremely disappointed that he had asked to go (compare to Shoe, who chose to stay with no guarantees), but if he is feeling like that, its best he goes.

Its a roll of the dice for you guys; if his body holds up you guys will be delighted, if he has more injuries it will be a failed experiment. We are gambling for a chance at a fourth in a row and need a tall defender, you are gambling for a chance of a GF and need some brilliance.

 

[seysearles]

If Saints offer up pick.5 will he definitely be off to StKilda? or could Carlisle potentially say that he now prefers the Hawks option and force Essendon to take the 15+18 trade?

 

[beta_condition]

So essentially we got pick 15 for Gilham

 

[Davo-27]

So essentially we got pick 15 for Gilham

Gilham was a Premiership FB

 

[dipper86]

St Kilda will cave now.