List Mgmt. 2015 Trade, Free agency and draft rumours

[GoldenHodge]

or maybe not
View attachment 185033

I think everyone (and I do mean everyone) just wants a decision to be made.

 

[Hawkk]

Sam Landsberger ‏@SamLandsberger 6s7 seconds ago
Essendon has REJECTED St Kilda's offer for Jake Carlisle. Advantage Hawthorn.

Dang

The Aints are such a shit club

 

[Gralin]

I read that language as saying "we haven't offered pick 5 but EFC should take what we have anyway" - I could be wrong. I think St Kilda always come across as thought they have lost, they can't help it - it's their culture.

I read it as them trying to paint * as the bad guy when the deal that isn't pick 5 is rejected and Jake ends up a Hawk

 

[Gralin]

Am I right in thinking that we have on traded our compensation pick for Suckling. If so, is that pick not effected if we bring in a free agent ( as some are saying Brisbane didn't want to do so to no cheapen their Leunberger pick)

We can't bring in a free agent now.
We can pick up a DFA in the draft or a FA who goes that route instead of signing an offer though

 

[MrFujiMoto]

Saints have tabled an offer to the bombre's for Carlisle.
No specifics about what that offer contains but you would assume pick 5 is on the table.

yeah, that was just a club PR operation. No new information other than they have shit themselves and scrambled to talk to Carlisle to make sure he is still interested. They haven't stated that they tabled a new offer at all, just that the Bombers have an offer in front of them. if they have tabled a new offer it is still not what the Bombers are after so they are still fluffing around the edges and dancing with danger. Amateur hour at Seaford, even if they end up getting him with a downgraded rd1 pick and a future pick, they still look like a joke because they have been forced into reactive panic stations.

 

[striker]

Lol didnt take long to reject it. He does seem hell bent on getting to them, maybe we should forget it and move on.

 

[HODGEYROAD]

Apparently The dons have rejected this latest offer, its just going to drag out to they eventually agree with St. Kilda.

 

[Hodginator]

LMAO. The Saints just continue to provide the Lolz

 

[Ranj Sri Lanka]

If he doesn't want to play for the greatest club when asked proves that he is a tool of the highest order. And then would prefer to play for a perennial joke St kilda. This bloke must be as dumb as he looks. I don't think he would be able to handle the demands our leadership group would demand from him anyway.

This - Gold and spot on.

 

[MrPremiership]

This will drag on until next Thursday...saints will cough up 5

 

[GoldenHodge]

I actually don't get how Carlisle looks bad in all this? If he ends up going to Hawthorn he can just say "My preference was St Kilda, but when that deal fell apart, I made sure that my former club was still adequately compensated".

 

[seysearles]

 

[whiteTiga2k]

HAHAHAHAHA rejected! Saints wasted all that time and effort to write a bulls**t statement just to get it smashed back into their faces... That is bloody hilarious HAHAHAHAHAHAA

 

[Suntory Boss Coffee]

Rumours going around that we might trade 15 and 18 for pick 5

 

[The Lemon]

Rumours going around that we might trade 15 and 18 for pick 5

They won't trade pick 5. Only to Essendon

 

[whiteTiga2k]

From how I see it, after Carlisle stated publically that he was going to be a St Kilda player - he had no choice but to say that he'd only come to Hawthorn if a deal with St Kilda couldn't be done.

Clearly it would hurt his credibility completely if he quickly changed his mind. In my opinion, he had no choice to do that.

 

[daniel23]

He won't be coming to us , will enter the psd if a deal does not get done with saints , starting to think saints are holding the cards now and essendon have gone to far in demanding 5 now could lose him for doughnuts

 

[Rioli magic]

"We're not going to provide a running commentary but here is an unnecessary public statement providing a running commentary." - St Kilda FC.

 

[MrPremiership]

Rumours going around that we might trade 15 and 18 for pick 5

good for us....but what would the saints do? then send 15 and 23 to essendon for Carlisle?

 

[Hawkas1988]

Rumours going around that we might trade 15 and 18 for pick 5

Makes no sense. St. Kilda are desperate to keep pick 5.

I've heard rumours of trading for pick 8.

 

[blackheart]

Rumours going around that we might trade 15 and 18 for pick 5

Wouldn't they just be shooting themselves in the foot then? Either way, all those pics will end up at the Bombers one way or another if they want Carlisle.

 

[Gaston]

When St Kilda first started talking to Carlisle and his management surely one of the peanuts at the club could foresee that the Bombers would demand pick 5. Why go there if you not prepared to pay up.
Essendon has form, I get that but in this instance St Kilda is the total fools, cough up and move on, no player of his quality will choose your useless club again.

As for Carlisle's choice, has me stuffed, in 2 years Richardson has not improved that list a great deal, its not like they are making leaps and bounds. If they can't do this trade other high profile players will avoid going there.

 

[Strapping Young Lad]

When St Kilda first started talking to Carlisle and his management surely one of the peanuts at the club could foresee that the Bombers would demand pick 5. Why go there if you not prepared to pay up.
Essendon has form, I get that but in this instance St Kilda is the total fools, cough up and move on, no player of his quality will choose your useless club again.

As for Carlisle's choice, has me stuffed, in 2 years Richardson has not improved that list a great deal, its not like they are making leaps and bounds. If they can't do this trade other high profile players will avoid going there.

Saints were electric at different stages this year.

 

[The Lemon]

Saints were electric at different stages this year.

Their mids will be awesome.

Bruce up forward, Goddard down back...great side in the making

 

[HawksILove]

Pick 15 and 18 = Pick 4 (what Wallace said)