List Mgmt. 2016 List Management thread - 2017 list complete

[deeman87]

NBA baby. Get on the Milwaukee Bucks. A typically downtrodden POS of a team like the Dees and like us with hope due to young guns. We have a 7 foot point guard who is going to tear the competition apart and he's the most fun player to watch in the world.

Mate don't be advocating Dees supporters to start barracking for the Bucks. Sure you have The Freak, Thon and Delly but i don't see you challenging in the East anytime soon. Us Dees fans don't need more pain in our lives...

 

[saj_21]

If Hogan goes and we don't get a superstar like Fyfe out of it the club will be in PR disarray given we've lost our coach, have no first round pick, and ended the year with two very bad losses.

Pretty negative way to look at it. If hogan goes this year freo will have to pay overs to get him as he is contracted. Everyone knew For two years Roos was going to be on his merry way round 23 and trained Goodwin in the process. We hardly lost him. First round pick this year effectively got us weid last year.

But those two bad losses will piss me off all summer no doubt!

 

[Jordie_tackles]

"Hullett is way down in terms of forwards at Melbourne which isn't a good side" - he had actually showed more than weid most of the year. Had a few niggles and missed a few games. First year forward and not a first round pick. He's showed nothing but good signs so far

King is stuck in the development side, hasn't set the world alight and is on the last year of his rookie deal. Unless we pick him in the draft or re rookie him, he's gone

Agree on what you take from my hullet comments but weideman showed good signs imo at AFL level he is and always has been ahead of Hullet. Hullet being a first year player obviously has some time but I still think he is stuck behind others at this point.

King will always have an advantage in being a Ruck we only have 4 on the list so I think if we drop him we are running with Gawn, Spencer and the other King which is bare bones.

 

[DemonTim]

Agree on what you take from my hullet comments but weideman showed good signs imo at AFL level he is and always has been ahead of Hullet. Hullet being a first year player obviously has some time but I still think he is stuck behind others at this point.

King will always have an advantage in being a Ruck we only have 4 on the list so I think if we drop him we are running with Gawn, Spencer and the other King which is bare bones.

Hullett hasn't had a chance at afl level, and weideman didn't show a heap at afl level (2 goals in his first game, but IIRC they were his only 2 kicks and one was a free). Hullett was ahead of weid at VFL level in terms of strength, leading and reading the play

You're just basing it on vague stereotypes around that. The rumbles are max King is gone, he's had 3 preseasons and can't even break into the casey seniors. Oscar at casey is in the draft combine and I wouldn't be surprised if we drafted him. It's not a one or the other mate, we can get rid of max King AND pick another ruck up, it's not like if we delist him we aren't allowed to find another ruckman.

Sorry if I'm coming across rude. Just a pet peeve when people talk about players without watching them

 

[Jordie_tackles]

Hullett hasn't had a chance at afl level, and weideman didn't show a heap at afl level (2 goals in his first game, but IIRC they were his only 2 kicks and one was a free). Hullett was ahead of weid at VFL level in terms of strength, leading and reading the play

You're just basing it on vague stereotypes around that. The rumbles are max King is gone, he's had 3 preseasons and can't even break into the casey seniors. Oscar at casey is in the draft combine and I wouldn't be surprised if we drafted him. It's not a one or the other mate, we can get rid of max King AND pick another ruck up, it's not like if we delist him we aren't allowed to find another ruckman.

Sorry if I'm coming across rude. Just a pet peeve when people talk about players without watching them

Don't worry at all, and I was saying that I think he would be in a group moving forward in the fringe.

Sure we can pick up a new ruck I just think it gives the rucks we have some leverage, as really anyone we draft is generally less developed, granted King is only playing development league.

Hullet is obviously in his first year has time just think he is in the bottom part of our list. When do you think he will break into our team? Is he AFL ready?

 

[SuburbanMe]

I left all the mfc facebook groups, not great places (and I was a dick when I discussed with people on there)
But yeah, it's not an online rumour. I'm fairly certain he's been made an offer to go elsewhere, not sure if he will take it up

I hope not.

 

[DemonTim]

I hope not.

Rumoured that clubs have enquired about Dawes and that Pedo is leaving. Leaves us with very little tall forward depth

 

[Gysberts2Bate]

I've heard Pedo will be gone next year...

Would be the Dogs best forward.

 

[Blackas87]

Would be the Dogs best forward.

Yep he would be, closely followed by Cloke and Boyd a distant third.

 

[Marc_Remillard]

Delist:
- Terlich
- Michie
- King
- Lumumba (mutual)
- Dunn (sad but the signs are there)

Trade out:
- Dawes (aim for pick 30+)
- Grimes (aim for pick 40+)
- Garland (aim for pick 30+)
- JKH (if good offer)

Upgrade:
- Wagner

Re-rookie:
- White
- Smith

Target tall defenders, outside mids and ruck/forwards through the trade and draft period.

Hold onto our first rounder for next season, maybe try trade some of the older players mentioned for future 2nd round picks.

I like that list but i hope give JKH one more year,

 

[DemonTim]

Yep he would be, closely followed by Cloke and Boyd a distant third.

Boyd will be a good player

 

[DemonTim]

I like that list but i hope give JKH one more year,

isnt he contracted until end of next year?

 

[Marc_Remillard]

isnt he contracted until end of next year?

Not sure, i'll check footywire later

 

[Marc_Remillard]

Hullett hasn't had a chance at afl level, and weideman didn't show a heap at afl level (2 goals in his first game, but IIRC they were his only 2 kicks and one was a free). Hullett was ahead of weid at VFL level in terms of strength, leading and reading the play

You're just basing it on vague stereotypes around that. The rumbles are max King is gone, he's had 3 preseasons and can't even break into the casey seniors. Oscar at casey is in the draft combine and I wouldn't be surprised if we drafted him. It's not a one or the other mate, we can get rid of max King AND pick another ruck up, it's not like if we delist him we aren't allowed to find another ruckman.

Sorry if I'm coming across rude. Just a pet peeve when people talk about players without watching them

Max King is really disappointing, he looked really promising in his first year

 

[DemonTim]

Max King is really disappointing, he looked really promising in his first year

Apparently he's a really good bloke (has the cutest dog in the world, managed to get to play with it at box hill), he performs really well some games, then disappears in others. I was really hoping he would make it

 

[Gysberts2Bate]

I'm shocked that our 20yo skinny ruckman is taking time to come on. I wish we'd cut Max Gawn at the same age.

 

[DemonTim]

I'm shocked that our 20yo skinny ruckman is taking time to come on. I wish we'd cut Max Gawn at the same age.

You're oversimplifying it mate, it's not a shock that he's not an afl ruckman, it's a shock that he's struggling in development league
I rate Oscar over him currently, and he's up for the draft

 

[CWaffles]

Yeah I had a huge barney with 1 bloke and I am pretty certain he's on here.

Dr Whooooo?

 

[00Stinger]

Delist:
- Terlich
- Michie
- King
- Lumumba (mutual)
- Dunn (sad but the signs are there)

Trade out:
- Dawes (aim for pick 30+)
- Grimes (aim for pick 40+)
- Garland (aim for pick 30+)
- JKH (if good offer)

Upgrade:
- Wagner

Re-rookie:
- White
- Smith

Target tall defenders, outside mids and ruck/forwards through the trade and draft period.

Hold onto our first rounder for next season, maybe try trade some of the older players mentioned for future 2nd round picks.

No way they delist dunn with a year left on his contract

Sent from my SM-G925I using Tapatalk

 

[Blackas87]

If Dawes and Pedo aren't returning then I hope Dunn moves to the forward line. When he started his career I thought he'd be our future Full Forward.

 

[Marc_Remillard]

If Dawes and Pedo aren't returning then I hope Dunn moves to the forward line. When he started his career I thought he'd be our future Full Forward.

Just on Dunn, I've heard that at the start of the year he did something to piss off the coaches, has anyone else heard this?

 

[Theseventhhamster]

Mate don't be advocating Dees supporters to start barracking for the Bucks. Sure you have The Freak, Thon and Delly but i don't see you challenging in the East anytime soon. Us Dees fans don't need more pain in our lives...

Eh Lebron can't dominate forever and we'll cover the rest. Will be fun as hell with Giannis, Parker, Middleton and a couple of Aussies.

 

[schmuttt]

Just on Dunn, I've heard that at the start of the year he did something to piss off the coaches, has anyone else heard this?

I heard there was some personal stuff, someone alluded to it on here but it didn't sound like he had pissed people at the club off, sounded more like he had some stuff going on outside footy.

 

[Bluelegs]

Will be shattered if pedo is axed. Give him a coaching position at least

 

[DemonTim]

Will be shattered if pedo is axed. Give him a coaching position at least

Not axed...he's been made an offer its up to him I think