List Mgmt. 2016 Trade & Free Agency Discussion Thread [v. 1.0]

[shinboner magic]

Can atley be tried as a fwd

 

[Malifice]

I think it will be our 2nd round pick and a bit extra on the fringes (say our third pick next year for their fourth next year, as an example).

No offence mate, but we wouldnt do it for a second rounder. He's happy to stay, and we're happy to keep him. Best case scenario (for us) thats pick 29 (likely a pick closer to 40 after academy selections and F/S). Touhy is worth more than that, and we wouldnt release him for such a late pick (thats at best a 10 percent chance to come out as good or better).

Melksham got Pick 25. Yarran pick 19. Redden Pick 17.

Something like [your 1st and 2nd] for [Touhy, our second and one of our (two) thirds].

It pushes your first live pick back from 11 (at present) to 23. Its a pretty even top 30 odd this year so its not too steep a price to pay.

Values him at around pick 16-20.

We might get sneaky and offer you Touhy and [something] for your future 1st. Big call though.

 

[Shermanator]

Can atley be tried as a fwd

I said that a few months back but got the stock-standard 'we've got Anderson, Garner, Boomer, Turner, Lindsay, Wagner to do that, so no.."

Fast fwd and only LT has played in the 1's for an extended period this year, the others are usually injured or not producing and Boom is history.. so yes.

 

[BoomerRoo]

maybe getting Tuohy allow's us to trade Atley. Get a better player and a high draft pick or another player.

Would we trade Ats whilst looking at getting his brother Joe? Doubtful......

I'd rather lose McKenzie, Hansen, Mullet and Tippett.

 

[Arathrawn]

What would we get pick wise this year if we offer our first round pick next year.

Most clubs would believe we are falling hard and expect us to finish bottom 4-6. If we could get a couple of picks around 10 in this year's draft would it be worth it?

I.e. next year's first for GC pick 9 & 21

 

[Pykie]

The club likes retaining its first pick.

The is absolutely no way they are giving that up for Zach Touhy

 

[DunderHead]

Atley is a decent player. Some people on here are very quick to pull the trigger on blokes for not being super stars. Remember he has been shouldering a lot of responsibility with Mullett and McKenzie playing for half the year.

 

[SnowRoo]

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2016-09-06/fremantle-cuts-ties-with-injuryravaged-morabito

 

[Harris 10]

The club likes retaining its first pick.

The is absolutely no way they are giving that up for Zach Touhy

Even if we wanted to trade it this year there is no way it's going to be given for a 27 year old back pocket.

 

[Palmezzz]

Atley is a decent player. Some people on here are very quick to pull the trigger on blokes for not being super stars. Remember he has been shouldering a lot of responsibility with Mullett and McKenzie playing for half the year.

He has had 130 games to prove himself as a superstar though.

 

[Nutjob]

Even if we wanted to trade it this year there is no way it's going to be given for a 27 year old back pocket.

He is 26 and plays HBF/Wing
Good player but agree with most that he isn't worth a 1st rounder.
Worth probably 20-25. Maybe next years 2nd could be about right, as Carlton will expect us to bottom out.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Harris 10]

He is 26 and plays HBF/Wing
Good player but agree with most that he isn't worth a 1st rounder.
Worth probably 20-25. Maybe next years 2nd could be about right as, Carlton will expect us to bottom out.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

I don't mind him but if we give up even our 2nd round for him I'll be dirty.

Just as a reference:
Docherty went at 33
Yeo went at 28

He'll add to our team but the position we are in means our first two picks must be used wisely, not on soon to be 27 year old back pocket players.

 

[Only Forwards]

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2016-09-06/fremantle-cuts-ties-with-injuryravaged-morabito

Poor kid.

 

[The Filth Wizard]

I've got more than a sneaky feeling Tuohy is (rightfully) pushing for an extra year on a deal for a little bit more coin with Carlton. If I was there I'd want to keep it up for the rest of my career, better chance of a sustained finals run.

 

[SnowRoo]

Poor kid.

Well worth a rookie spot or even late pick in my opinion.

 

[ZACK WILD]

No offence mate, but we wouldnt do it for a second rounder. He's happy to stay, and we're happy to keep him. Best case scenario (for us) thats pick 29 (likely a pick closer to 40 after academy selections and F/S). Touhy is worth more than that, and we wouldnt release him for such a late pick (thats at best a 10 percent chance to come out as good or better).

Melksham got Pick 25. Yarran pick 19. Redden Pick 17.

Something like [your 1st and 2nd] for [Touhy, our second and one of our (two) thirds].

It pushes your first live pick back from 11 (at present) to 23. Its a pretty even top 30 odd this year so its not too steep a price to pay.

Values him at around pick 16-20.

We might get sneaky and offer you Touhy and [something] for your future 1st. Big call though.

Take your dream elsewhere mate

 

[roos_fanatic08]

Half back flanker who ultimately is just another b-grader.

Major pass.

 

[Heaps of fun]

Well worth a rookie spot or even late pick in my opinion.

Would be a waste. He's cooked.

 

[koshari]

We might get sneaky and offer you Touhy and [something] for your future 1st. Big call though.

Pure Fantasy,

How about a strait swap Hanson for Weitering? Hanson was picked at #3 and Jacob @ #1, would only be a downgrade of 2 picks plus Hanson comes with a ton more experience.

 

[Le Grille]

No offence mate, but we wouldnt do it for a second rounder. He's happy to stay, and we're happy to keep him. Best case scenario (for us) thats pick 29 (likely a pick closer to 40 after academy selections and F/S). Touhy is worth more than that, and we wouldnt release him for such a late pick (thats at best a 10 percent chance to come out as good or better).

Melksham got Pick 25. Yarran pick 19. Redden Pick 17.

Something like [your 1st and 2nd] for [Touhy, our second and one of our (two) thirds].

It pushes your first live pick back from 11 (at present) to 23. Its a pretty even top 30 odd this year so its not too steep a price to pay.

Values him at around pick 16-20.

We might get sneaky and offer you Touhy and [something] for your future 1st. Big call though.

Tuhoy and McKay

 

[Harris 10]

Well worth a rookie spot or even late pick in my opinion.

i hope nobody involved with our list management agrees with your opinion.

Completely cooked.

 

[Sheezel2Wardlaw]

Bit cheeky of AFL360 to mention directly to Spitta and Brad that they might be off to different clubs next season. Anyone else catch it?

 

[DesertRoo]

Bit cheeky of AFL360 to mention directly to Spitta and Brad that they might be off to different clubs next season. Anyone else catch it?

Both of them??

 

[king rising]

bookmark it. we are heavily interested in Caleb Marchbank. nothing surer. delusional how some media reports haven't included us in the running when its between us and Essendon from my understanding.

 

[Hojuman]

bookmark it. we are heavily interested in Caleb Marchbank. nothing surer. delusional how some media reports haven't included us in the running when its between us and Essendon from my understanding.

Sauces ?