List Mgmt. 2016 Trade & Free Agency Discussion Thread [v. 1.0]

[scooby1279]

McKenzie and a second rounder for Hartlett

 

[shinboner spiggs]

McKenzie and a second rounder for Hartlett

just signed the deal. Can we expect him for this week?

 

[Heaps of fun]

Port have a ruck dilemma.

Hartlett and pick 9

For

Goldstein and Aaron Black

If I could reach through my computer and slap you I would.

 

[Black2Blue]

The Goldy trade I would like to see is the round 7-22 Goldy traded out in exchange for the round 1-6 Goldy. Should be a straight swap without any need for draft picks, but might involve a surgeon's fee thrown in.

 

[Rooboys Rool]

A Swallow and pick 11 to Gold Coast for their picks 8 & 21.

 

[muttley45]

Port have a ruck dilemma.

Hartlett and pick 9

For

Goldstein and Aaron Black

Yep, their biggest dilemma is whether to trade Lobbe, and go with the Paddy Ryder/Trengrove combo, or keep him on the list.

 

[Heaps of fun]

Yep, their biggest dilemma is whether to trade Lobbe, and go with the Paddy Ryder/Trengrove combo, or keep him on the list.

Nah, obviously they need to trade out their first round pick for a ruckman for the second time in three years.

 

[Only Forwards]

Every year, without fail, every god-damn year people want to trade Goldstein.

What the f*** is that about?

We moved on 2 more than adequate ruckman to facilitate his development, now that he's developed people want to sell him off.

Going down this route would simply make us a feeder club. Is that what people want to be? When we get legit A grade talent we f*** it off for ok talent and a magic beans draft pick?

Goldy is contracted, loves the club and in all likelihood wouldn't move from Melbourne for a start.

 

[King Corey]

Port have a ruck dilemma.

Hartlett and pick 9

For

Goldstein and Aaron Black

Hahaha.

Oh.. you were serious?

 

[Black2Blue]

Every year, without fail, every god-damn year people want to trade Goldstein.

What the f*** is that about?

We moved on 2 more than adequate ruckman to facilitate his development, now that he's developed people want to sell him off.

Going down this route would simply make us a feeder club. Is that what people want to be? When we get legit A grade talent we f*** it off for ok talent and a magic beans draft pick?

Goldy is contracted, loves the club and in all likelihood wouldn't move from Melbourne for a start.

Summed it up OF. I under-rated Goldy in 2014, but since moving back and seeing him live last year and this year, have seen how much of a champion he actually is. It is just that his form has dropped off since his knee injury against the Bullies that has made him expendable in some eyes. I have no doubt that he will get fixed up and back to his best for round 1, 2017. And I would say the same about Cunners, who has been mentioned a bit too as trade bait. To trade our top liners when their drop in form has coincided with knee injuries is madness.

Goldy will be back in AA contention in 2017. Bookmark it, as Gaso would say.

 

[Only Forwards]

Goldy will be back in AA contention in 2017.

Best Ruckman in the league is his title and he should forcibly show everyone why.

 

[roos_fanatic08]

A Swallow and pick 11 to Gold Coast for their picks 8 & 21.

I would do that in a heart beat

 

[Star]

So unless a top 20 pick is a super star you should delist. Righto.

Care to show me where I said that?

People have an expectation that Top 20 picks (an average of one per club) will be stars. Hardly an earth shattering statement

 

[Prefectionist]

People do forget that Goldy is our only mid capable of kicking more than two goals a game.

Trade the Datsuns before the Ferrari.

 

[Uber poster]

Cool. Then we'll have a ruck dilemma.

Majak, give preuss a go, or pick up a vfl/sanfl/wafl ruck.

Every year, without fail, every god-damn year people want to trade Goldstein.

What the f*** is that about?

We moved on 2 more than adequate ruckman to facilitate his development, now that he's developed people want to sell him off.

Going down this route would simply make us a feeder club. Is that what people want to be? When we get legit A grade talent we f*** it off for ok talent and a magic beans draft pick?

Goldy is contracted, loves the club and in all likelihood wouldn't move from Melbourne for a start.

Yeah and now those two have retired. Time to cash in and more him on after a lean year.

Hahaha.

Oh.. you were serious?

Most overrated position on the field. Just chuck a big guy on the field and get the midfielders to crumb their ruck. Opposition players do it to goldy all the time.

Time to unleash Maj.

 

[Arden]

Majak, give preuss a go, or pick up a vfl/sanfl/wafl ruck.


Yeah and now those two have retired. Time to cash in and more him on after a lean year.

Most overrated position on the field. Just chuck a big guy on the field and get the midfielders to crumb their ruck. Opposition players do it to goldy all the time.

Time to unleash Maj.

If ruck is over rated, why would Port pay good money for Goldy then?

 

[Uber poster]

If ruck is over rated, why would Port pay good money for Goldy then?

Because some people still believe in them. Also, lobbe has struggled and ryder is a forward/ruck. We've got a ready to go reserve that has dominated in the ruck at vfl level for years.

 

[Only Forwards]

Yeah and now those two have retired. Time to cash in and more him on after a lean year.

Wot?

 

[TruRoos7]

Yep time to turf goldy and recruit dan Currie ( he played VFL for awhile ) would be a good pickup to replace goldy seeing we only need a second string ruckman, so we can get pick 1 from a club for goldy...



Oh wait.....

 

[Arden]

Because some people still believe in them. Also, lobbe has struggled and ryder is a forward/ruck. We've got a ready to go reserve that has dominated in the ruck at vfl level for years.

Dominated VFL for years?

Has been on the list two years and last year played the bulk of the year in the development league

 

[Thewlis Dish]

Because some people still believe in them. Also, lobbe has struggled and ryder is a forward/ruck. We've got a ready to go reserve that has dominated in the ruck at vfl level for years.

Goldy is more of a forward than Ryder.

 

[Only Forwards]

Dominated VFL for years?

Has been on the list two years and last year played the bulk of the year in the development league

I haven't checked but I believe this line was being pushed previously.

Sounds like there is some Curiouslplater type nonsense going on.

 

[Uber poster]

Dominated VFL for years?

Has been on the list two years and last year played the bulk of the year in the development league

Majak. Was considered a ruck until Goldies dominance and a need pushed him to the forward line.

Goldy is more of a forward than Ryder.

Didn't say he was a good one. Overrated and port paid too much.

 

[GS WARRIORS]

Marchbank would be a good get.

Strong mark and gives good rebound. Was good one on one at Junior level and was one of the youngest drafted in his year being born in December. Reminds me a bit of Rance.

Would join EVW, Durdin and Nielson as talls from the 2014 draft and could set our defense up for the next 10+ years.

 

[koshari]

You do know that future picks can be traded, right?

future picks really should only be used when you get a rare opportunity to secure a player of dangerfield or trelour etc.