2016 trade hypotheticals

[LynchysMob]

This thread is becoming a bit of a joke now. Prestia alone is worth more than 10.

 

[LukeParkerno1]

He signed the extension the year before.

It was first reported on April 2nd, with the Kelly extension in 2014.

Asked for a trade at the end of 2015.

Then don't sign the extension. I blame his manager who is the worst more than him. However both parties can't complain!

 

[isamedthegiants]

Whats Freo R1? P1? That just will not happen. Perhaps if they add someone else like Pickett etc ..but otherwize I cant see a kid that has been out for 12 months being traded for r1. GWS will feel pressure to look like they are doing the right thing ...and I feel that given a choice its better to move that 250-350 of cap that he is using.

Hasn't Pickett sat out 12 months also?

 

[LukeParkerno1]

Whats Freo R1? P1? That just will not happen. Perhaps if they add someone else like Pickett etc ..but otherwize I cant see a kid that has been out for 12 months being traded for r1. GWS will feel pressure to look like they are doing the right thing ...and I feel that given a choice its better to move that 250-350 of cap that he is using.

2017 first rounder not this year. Could be a mid teens selection as Freo will bounce back a fair bit. GWS give back a 2nd or 3rd.

 

[YEMOC NAYR]

This thread is becoming a bit of a joke now. Prestia alone is worth more than 10.

I think he's worth around 10 personally. Has a brief injury history and is uncontracted which plays it's part.

10 would be the bare minmum though. Probably ranges between 5-10, depending on the suiters pick number.

 

[Turbocat]

2017 first rounder not this year. Could be a mid teens selection as Freo will bounce back a fair bit. GWS give back a 2nd or 3rd.

GWS seemed to be loaded with players that they are willing to offload... If they really want that R1 Id say they need to thicken the gravy

 

[isamedthegiants]

GWS seemed to be loaded with players that they are willing to offload... If they really want that R1 Id say they need to thicken the gravy

They can have Dawson Simoson gravy then.

 

[LynchysMob]

I think he's worth around 10 personally. Has a brief injury history and is uncontracted which plays it's part.

10 would be the bare minmum though. Probably ranges between 5-10, depending on the suiters pick number.

Yeah that's fair I wouldn't argue that. Think your pretty on the mark.

 

[Turbocat]

A very very reliable poster on our board thinks most if not all of Marchbank, Tomlinson, Steele and Stewart will be at the blues come 2016. Trading history and SOS big factors in that.

I heard this rumour quoted on SEN today.. someone obviously thinks it has legs.

 

[Taylor]

Then don't sign the extension. I blame his manager who is the worst more than him. However both parties can't complain!

No room for mental illness in the AFL?

 

[Colonial]

No room for mental illness in the AFL?

Plenty. No room for managers and a certain club playing with it to get them that cheap forward they have always wished for.

 

[Taylor]

Plenty. No room for managers and a certain club playing with it to get them that cheap forward they have always wished for.

That is a bold claim.

 

[isamedthegiants]

I heard this rumour quoted on SEN today.. someone obviously thinks it has legs.

Or Big Footy posters ring SEN?

 

[Colonial]

I heard this rumour quoted on SEN today.. someone obviously thinks it has legs.

Considering their calibre would be interested in what Carlton would trade for them.

 

[Colonial]

That is a bold claim.

And yet here we are.

 

[Taylor]

And yet here we are.

I expect the AFL would be all over Freo if they tried it, but here we are. We aren't the favourite child.

Not a whisper.

 

[isamedthegiants]

That is a bold claim.

So was Clive Waterhouse at Pick 1.

 

[Taylor]

So was Clive Waterhouse at Pick 1.

We are talking about 2016.

 

[isamedthegiants]

We are talking about 2016.

Oh. I thought we were talking about bold claims.

 

[Colonial]

I expect the AFL would be all over Freo if they tried it, but here we are. We aren't the favourite child.

Not a whisper.

Whats to prove. You offered what was, at the time, a shit house trade. Hoping that along with the footy show fav manager hitting the homesick button through the media that freo would get him cheap. Oops.

Now i have no doubt the Cam is facing issues absolutely. The club has done everything it could to help him. Except to take it up the rear from freo.

I dont regret supporting the club saying no.

I have no doubt that if you had already traded away this years 1st you would of miraculously already won a game here and there. #freotank.

 

[Colonial]

We are talking about 2016.

Actually 2015

 

[Taylor]

Actually 2015

True, my mistake.

 

[Great8]

Yeah that's fair I wouldn't argue that. Think your pretty on the mark.

Hence why I'd be happy to hand over pick 1 for Prestia and Matera.

 

[Red Bull]

Hence why I'd be happy to hand over pick 1 for Prestia and Matera.

Reckon the Suns would be off to the races with that deal ...

 

[Great8]

Reckon the Suns would be off to the races with that deal ...

I don't think we would part with number 1 unfortunately but from everything you hear there is no stand out gun in this years draft like a Weitering. Id probably rate Prestia in the pick 4-8 range and you know what you are going to get with him rather than the lottery of this years draft, add Matera to the equation and it's 2 players that are best 22 for round 1 2017.