Position 2017 Rookies

[LeverPuller]

Is he worth taking with so many melbourne fwd mids available?

I think the catch is so many of them are unfit. Kent, Garlett, Kennedy all have missed a fair bit of training.

His JS is probably touch and go though, I agree .

 

[TheOz]

Says before teams are announced

We already have confirmation that all of Hampton, Hibberd and Smith will play with Stewart pretty much confirmed as well. Otten is the only real question mark.

 

[big bootaaaaah]

His JS is pretty certain. My worries are injury history, and what he has to avg to make decent money compared to a Smith etc

Not taking him fwiw!

Interesting to note, both Marchbank and Elliot only played two games each last year.

Kinda puts me off!!!

Gotta go at least 80 to make enough cash to justify the spend.

 

[Seymour Skinner]

So what's the go with ZGuthrie? No elevation? Do I have to grab Macreadie now? Maybe I'll swing Hibberd back and get Mountford in the middle.

Anyways I'm off to the footy now, Go Tiges.

 

[Phoenix_9]

Can anyone post the rookies SC scores throughout preseason? How did Butler score in particular?

 

[Souup]

We already have confirmation that all of Hampton, Hibberd and Smith will play with Stewart pretty much confirmed as well. Otten is the only real question mark.

Hibberd won't play too many games, bad JS

 

[The Lemon]

Can anyone post the rookies SC scores throughout preseason? How did Butler score in particular?

 

[Wild Bill]

Yep. Using Myers. At least you won't have to trade out a non player and can trade out a non performer when Myers starts playing.

What is the ETA on Myers returning?

 

[LeverPuller]

What is the ETA on Myers returning?

6-8 weeks

 

[toxic]

What is the ETA on Myers returning?

Rd 6-8 i think i read

 

[WaynesWorld19]

We already have confirmation that all of Hampton, Hibberd and Smith will play with Stewart pretty much confirmed as well. Otten is the only real question mark.

I am comfortable on PS form, Otten will be selected ......you just don't get dropped playing the way Otten has been

 

[Franky_024]

We already have confirmation that all of Hampton, Hibberd and Smith will play with Stewart pretty much confirmed as well. Otten is the only real question mark.

only Hampton out of those has decent JS and who knows he could flop round 1. Smith has ok JS now that Hibberd will miss a few

 

[Wild Bill]

Rd 6-8 i think i read

Thats way too long to carry a player. Will be a great swap when a rookie has made some decent cash. Can't have Myers round 1.

 

[TheOz]

I am comfortable on PS form, Otten will be selected ......you just don't get dropped playing the way Otten has been

I only worry that he isn't defensively as sound as Cheney and I think that's who he's competing with directly. There's no way they will leave Lever out.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

SPS upto 9.68% ownership lads.

it doesn't take long for group think to take effect

 

[WaynesWorld19]

I only worry that he isn't defensively as sound as Cheney and I think that's who he's competing with directly. There's no way they will leave Lever out.

Lever will play, Otten is very good defensively on talls and smalls .....very smart

His career though his scoring will be mid 60's .......if you're in the team and playing well, Cheney doesn't get back in, he's not an automatic best 22

 

[KardiniaPark]

I only worry that he isn't defensively as sound as Cheney and I think that's who he's competing with directly. There's no way they will leave Lever out.

You don't keep a bloke in your list for 8-9 years if he can't play. If he's fit he will play.

 

[Spacedog]

Marchbank - yes or no

 

[big bootaaaaah]

it doesn't take long for group think to take effect

I thought it was shitting thyself effect

 

[WaynesWorld19]

I thought it was shitting thyself effect

Yes all these Rookies expected to play .......absolutely love SPS, but $189K is a huge risk ATS ......i'd look at him b4 his 3rd game to bring in, by them we'll be doing adjustments anyway

 

[Dan87]

Marchbank - yes or no

Yep

 

[big bootaaaaah]

Nope

 

[Test Tickle]

Yep

 

[Dark Sharks]

Marchbank - yes or no

Just follow your heart young warrior.

 

[big bootaaaaah]

Yes all these Rookies expected to play .......absolutely love SPS, but $189K is a huge risk ATS ......i'd look at him b4 his 3rd game to bring in, by them we'll be doing adjustments anyway

He might be Relton 17