Position 2017 Rookies

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
Rightio Northlings, which 2 of Hibberd/Turner/Vickers-Willis ? . Currently have VW and Turner but can do some easy shuffling
 
Rightio Northlings, which 2 of Hibberd/Turner/Vickers-Willis ? . Currently have VW and Turner but can do some easy shuffling
North have already named 4 debutants
Hibberd is playing 100%, while EVW is going to be emergency

I highly doubt Turner will miss, he had a good JLT 3, but he's a chance to be cut today
 

Log in to remove this ad.

God my last rookie decision is a nightmare.

243k.

WHE v Taranto v Ainsworth v Turner v Bowes v Floz v Simpkin

Who the fk do you go with?!

Anyone got a 7 sided coin?

Bowes - based on JS and scoring potential
Florent - kid can play

god it really is a raffle but the two above are the only 2 of those 7 i have
 
would you rather start declan mountford (with js low once cunnington returns) or ottens (competition with cheeney & lever)?
mitch hibberd is the swingman here
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Bowes - based on JS and scoring potential
Florent - kid can play

god it really is a raffle but the two above are the only 2 of those 7 i have
Florent looked good eh" I didn't see any JLT, he is an unkown quantity apart from what little I have read about him on here.
Good poise? Didn't get overawed?

I got rid of him for Simpkin. Maybe I should put it back, Swans will give him lots of scoring opportunities, but Simpkin will play most games IMO. Ahahhaahah
 
I'm going Hannan. Im 99% sure Houston will be out within 3 or 4 games due to Broadbent and Pittard coming back in.

Correct me if I'm wrong but Melbourne only have Kent and Hibberd to come back in within the next month. If Hannan plays well surely he keeps his spot over Kent? To play Hannan after no JLT over someone like Harmes who is fully fit surely says something about how they rate him and the chance they want to give him?

Might fail and I'll have to do a rookie correction but if that's the case so be it
I think you're underestimating Kent there. He's best 22 every week when fit. He'll probably play next week as well as Tyson. I'm not convinced on Hannan JS but agree Houston is risky to. I'm still unsure who I'll go.
 
think Mountford and Florent are the best of the mid price rooks.
Mine
marchbank, hampton - subs Otten, Smith
Florent, SPP - subs SPS, Mountford, Parfitt
Cameron
Taranto - subs Pickett, Hannan

Mountford to me has that much job opposition its not funny - he must be doing something right to get selected but for me he's a big red flag

however - BACK YOUR GUT
 
Careful mate, most Norfies have him out when Cunners gets back, his JS is shakier than steady eddy during a fap.
Looks to pretty versatile to me, and gives it all, so once cunning-less is back they will just move him to another possie and maybe even rotate with cunning-stunt
 
Careful mate, most Norfies have him out when Cunners gets back, his JS is shakier than steady eddy during a fap.
I disagree

Ben Jacobs is the primary tagger at North and he's out for up to 8 weeks
Mountford is playing that role and Scott obviously likes to run with a tagger every week
He impressed in the JLT and had a great season in the VFL last year

Backing Mountford in to be a great rookie
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top