Position 2017 Rookies

[Spacedog]

Florent. If he does well, Horse plays him

Doesn't that apply to everyone... i feel like florent has more competition than simpkin or bowes do

 

[Pea Nut]

Thoughts on Josh Smith ....position & JS?

Had to bring him in over EVW due to money in other areas ......is this a wrong move?

Joel Smith or Josh Smith ??

 

[Spacedog]

Houston, parfitt, mountford choose 2

 

[pincrusher]

Thoughts on Josh Smith ....position & JS?

Had to bring him in over EVW due to money in other areas ......is this a wrong move?

Josh (Pies) or Joel (Demons)?

 

[Spacedog]

Joel Smith or Josh Smith ??

pretty sure he means joel from melbourne

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Doesn't that apply to everyone... i feel like florent has more competition than simpkin or bowes do

My gut says in order Simpkin > Bowes > Florent

Much harder to sustain games in top contenders .....North are building, i know positions named are misleading, but Simpkin named on a wing?

My mind keeps reflecting on Paul Roo's gushing over Simpkin ......he rarely does that

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Josh (Pies) or Joel (Demons)?

Sorry, Joel Smith (Melbourne)

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Joel Smith or Josh Smith ??

Sorry Melbournes Joel Smith

 

[pincrusher]

Sorry, Joel Smith (Melbourne)

Most rooks are a lottery at the moment.

I didn't take Butler because I thought his JS was shaky at best but after last night he'll probably be safe for a few weeks.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Most rooks are a lottery at the moment.

I didn't take Butler because I thought his JS was shaky at best but after last night he'll probably be safe for a few weeks.

I still do, but i agree, he'll at least another couple of games on the back of last night ....i also didn't have Butler, still not regretting the decision ......believe me?

 

[swingsnrounds]

Trying to lock in my forward rooks.
Which two to select between:
Florent, Matt Kennedy, Bowes, Turner, Parfitt?

 

[vast]

Expect friendly reminder in 2 weeks when mountford makes way for cunnington and balic is named.

 

[BabyBlues]

Doesn't that apply to everyone... i feel like florent has more competition than simpkin or bowes do

Florent. If he does well, Horse plays him

I am leaning towards Florent based on the success of sydneys rookies last year. He's going to be in a winning team most weeks and if he performs should stay in the team I feel

 

[ldamico]

Who out of Bowes, Florent, Simpkin, Turner, Ainsworth?

 

[The Lemon]

Expect friendly reminder in 2 weeks when mountford makes way for cunnington and balic is named.

Ross. the. Boss.

Will defo not name a kid early

 

[patfootball04]

If I stick Guthrie on my bench, is he a chance to get upgraded anytime soon?

 

[toxic]

My gut says in order Simpkin > Bowes > Florent

Much harder to sustain games in top contenders .....North are building, i know positions named are misleading, but Simpkin named on a wing?

My mind keeps reflecting on Paul Roo's gushing over Simpkin ......he rarely does that

where does Foote fit in the rankings

 

[The Lemon]

vast i am now questioning Mountford. ABORT MISSION!

Tossing up between Parfitt and Hibberd i think now

 

[WaynesWorld19]

where does Foote fit in the rankings

Who's Foote? .........think that a) indicates my knowledge & b) how i rank him

 

[enobrien]

Who's Foote? .........think that a) indicates my knowledge & b) how i rank him

180k rookie playing for Swans aswell

 

[Hairy Lager]

rocker_oz33 you picking Guthrie if he plays ?

 

[DaveyBoy123]

What does everyone think of Barrett's JS & scoring potential? It seems most have him, but am wondering if it's worth me using my $40k in the bank to upgrade him to Florent/Simpkin.

 

[Spacedog]

**** this game is too hard

 

[Spacedog]

Im worried about the JS of mountford, parfitt, houston, and tarantino.

 

[Nathan Wilcox]

Mcarthy, Taranto or bowes for f4????