List Mgmt. 2017 Trade & FA Targets Part 3

[Stan_Darsh72]

"Lol. Gresham is a speck of dust compared to Simpkin"

Don't ever change, lolnorf.

The norf board is quite special

 

[Moral Decay]

Parcel up Roberton for Stringer? No Boyd or Murphy, just what they need?

 

[Joffaboy]

"Lol. Gresham is a speck of dust compared to Simpkin"

Don't ever change, lolnorf.

#lolnorf

 

[Saintos The ITK]

they have too because of retirements and others that just don't cut it

Priddis
Mitchell
Petrie
Butler
Giles
Schofield
LeCra
Masten
Hill
Lamb

and most probably more

Cripps

 

[Darkhour]

The list analysis of St.Kilda on www.theroar.com.au was very interesting , and comes with a few lists , one of them being when each player is out of contract. A good read and very detailed. Not as bad as Bartel's article on realfooty.com.au saying we need to get Trent McKenzie.

thanks for the heads up.. nice read

 

[Hayes4PM]

Parcel up Roberton for Stringer? No Boyd or Murphy, just what they need?

You hanging with Chicken Nixon?! If we were to trade Roberton to them I'd be asking for Hunter or Macrae. 2 blokes who are very good and fit our needs. Stringer is a mid sized forward. We have plenty of forward stocks. Right now Membrey is playing better than Stringer so he wouldn't get a look in.

 

[Dr Spaceman]

"Lol. Gresham is a speck of dust compared to Simpkin"

Don't ever change, lolnorf.

ST KILDA: "We eat* Simpkins for breakfast!"

* eat = delist

 

[Premium]

they have too because of retirements and others that just don't cut it

Priddis
Mitchell
Petrie
Butler
Giles
Schofield
LeCra
Masten
Hill
Lamb

and most probably more

can't see them getting rid of Gaff and Shuey, the only good players they have apart from Kennedy and Yeo

 

[King_Steele]

#lolnorf

 

[Sainterz12]

My Spanish grandmother summed up this trade period perfectly

"está pasando"

 

[Dard Ball Get]

Lmao

 

[Trojan_Saint]

Has anyone considered Matt Crouch? Has had an amazing year - will probably win the Adelaide B&F, could even have a Norm Smith in 4 weeks time and is OOC in 2018. Is also a VIC lad. Would be throwing everything at him before Gaff. Sure, we need outside run and polish but he could be every bit as good as Kelly, only thing holding him back is that he doesn't kick many goals like Kelly does. A genuine A-Grader, and that we definitely need.

Actually taught at the Primary school that he and Brad attended. Will talk to his favourite staff and put a word in. Incidentally, James Frawley and Ricky Henderson went to the same school


Sent from my SM-G935F using Tapatalk

 

[The_Steadier]

He's sorted...will stay at Saints

I dunno about you guys, but I'm stoked josh kelly has decided to stay at the saints.

 

[King_Steele]

I dunno about you guys, but I'm stoked josh kelly has decided to stay at the saints.

Pffft. Kelly is old news.

Stringerrrrr is the messiah.

 

[CursingFijian]

My Spanish grandmother summed up this trade period perfectly

"está pasando despacito"

EFA

 

[Flags_In_The_Bag]

All this talk of Daniher being the next great KPF has me hoping Paddy can greatly close the gap or even chase him down, much like Billings has on Bont.

Really? Closed the gap?

 

[Dard Ball Get]

Really? Closed the gap?

Watch much footy?

 

[Flags_In_The_Bag]

Watch much footy?

Actually yes, he has had a few good games but any serious footy person would still say miles apart.

 

[King_Steele]

Actually yes, he has had a few good games but any serious footy person would still say miles apart.

Bloody oath.

Now scram!

 

[Dard Ball Get]

Actually yes, he has had a few good games but any serious footy person would still say miles apart.

I thought he had a down year, but I think you're being harsh on the Bont. He's not that far behind

 

[Dr Spaceman]

Actually yes, he has had a few good games but any serious footy person would still say miles apart.

Well according to Google Maps they're actually 58kms apart

But in all seriousness...


...they are a fair way apart, but if the Bont can knuckle down and rediscover his early form, he may be able to close up the gap again

 

[Yawkey way]

Actually yes, he has had a few good games but any serious footy person would still say miles apart.

Are we talking about the same player, slow guy big nose played some good footy about a year back.

 

[saintbill]

Why not just do hickey for stringer...

No chance. Hockey is worth a second rounder at best. The problem with a bloke like Stronger is his best is so good that the Dogs would expect a top ten pick, possibly more.

Unfortunately he is only good for 2 good games a year which makes his real worth much closer to around pick 20. However, u can understand why the Dogs would want significantly more as on paper be has got all the attributes to be far better than he actually is.

Would rather go to the draft then pick up Stringer, don't need another bloke who just kicks points. Highly doubt he is up for trade anyway, unless JJ really is shagging his missus.

 

[Yawkey way]

No chance. Hockey is worth a second rounder at best. The problem with a bloke like Stronger is his best is so good that the Dogs would expect a top ten pick, possibly more.

Unfortunately he is only good for 2 good games a year which makes his real worth much closer to around pick 20. However, u can understand why the Dogs would want significantly more as on paper be has got all the attributes to be far better than he actually is.

Would rather go to the draft then pick up Stringer, don't need another bloke who just kicks points. Highly doubt he is up for trade anyway, unless JJ really is shagging his missus.

We've seen plenty of stringer now, so have the Bulldogs which is why he keeps getting dropped.

Your right about what they would want but in reality he is a bit like hickey, how much can you expect for a guy who only plays a few good games a year.

He's a long way past being able to trade on his potential a pick in the twenties is all he's worth imho.

 

[St BKD]

They'd want Acres but I'd give them pick 8 & that's it. Turns 26 next year so has plenty of footy left in him. Averaged 29 touches at 75% efficiency. Mild froffage

If we gave up Acres for Gaff I am quitting following football. I could never follow a new side... that's the most messed up thing anyone could do. But if we made a stupid decision of that magnitude I would give up.

A player with incredible upside that can develop into a star with multiple tricks... for a older one trick pony. It would ruin me

On SM-G950F using BigFooty.com mobile app