The only thing that worries me - if you believe the media;
Seedsman, Lycett and Hanmers all 27+. Does bring in leadership, but we’d want to make sure the next wave are seriously developed right.
List Mgmt. 2018 St Kilda Trade Thread Part 2
- Thread starter plugger66
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
Seedsman, Lycett and Hanmers all 27+. Does bring in leadership, but we’d want to make sure the next wave are seriously developed right.
I thought Lycett was 25... ?
He is. Almost 26 though
gringo2011
Premium Platinum
A pick in the 40s
Seedsman any good?
gringo2011
Premium Platinum
Seedsman is not skillfull, he’s going to fit in well ...hits the occasional target when he feels like it.
Can’t we have a board spill before we commit to any more hacks and waste our pick. We need to get the broom out now. Ricoh is doing a Mick Malthouse and trashing the place before they sack him.
Ok if we get hanneberry for nothing I'm not opposed we will be letting a few senior players go in the next year or two plus we already iirc have plenty of space in the cap. Let's be realistic though we are going to lose a first round or a second round pick, both could be better used on midfielders
Steven's probably has some time left in the midfield but even if you right he could be an effective forward for a few more years
You think they'd do that?
Sounds like too good a deal for us. Even though i dont want to give up the pick.
Sorry was talking next year - and yes you’re right. He’s turning 27 year, but late.. so effectively 26 for the season.
Bloody hell I hope we don’t trade pick 4 in any deal with Sydney unless it involves Heeney.
I’m all for Hannebery, but for a 2nd, at most.
I’m all for Hannebery, but for a 2nd, at most.
- Apr 12, 2017
- 2,949
- 9,847
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
Well at least he suits what we need. Quick and an elite kick.
Is that sarcasm Longmembrey? I know nothing of the bloke other than he played for Collingwood at some stage didn’t he?
- Apr 12, 2017
- 2,949
- 9,847
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
I must be watching a different Seedsman Gringo? He takes some difficult options but to me looks like an amazing user by foot.
- Apr 12, 2017
- 2,949
- 9,847
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
No, he is quick and a fantastic kick. Happy to be corrected? Probably similar to Polec. Bit injury prone too.
Thanks mate, hmmm ok then. Probable avenue of trade is downgrade pick 4 then? I suspect he’s not a FA?
Our pick should only be used in the draft.
Depends what you give up.
I honestly don't see how the young "leaders" will do any different to this year. They either got it or the ain't got it.
Lycett could be a 5 to 8 year player. Hanners, depends on his body. Seedsman is good for at least another 5?
Throws the age demographic back into balance.
Rather Seedsman over Hall for example.
Worst we could do is nothing and have another year like this one.
Seedsman’s kicking has improved out of sight over the past 2 seasons... before that he was an inconsistent kick.
Great speed, run & carry. Not a bad option depending on the price.
Swap for Dunstan sounds about right
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
With so many free agents coming in 2019 they would have to move on the guys that will be moving - they have too
we have to get in there and find what we need
GWS Players Out of Contract in 2019 GWS Player Contracts
Name Years Service Status
Adam Tomlinson 8 Restricted Free Agent
Brent Daniels 2 Non-Free Agent
Brett Deledio 3 Non-Free Agent
Daniel Lloyd 4 Non-Free Agent
Dylan Shiel 8 Restricted Free Agent
Harrison Himmelberg 4 Non-Free Agent
Jacob Hopper 4 Non-Free Agent
Joshua Kelly 6 Non-Free Agent
Matthew Buntine 8 Restricted Free Agent
Matthew De Boer 3 Non-Free Agent
Matthew Flynn 4 Non-Free Agent
Nick Haynes 8 Restricted Free Agent
Rory Lobb 6 Non-Free Agent
Sam Taylor 2 Non-Free Agent
Stephen Coniglio 8 Restricted Free Agent
we have to get in there and find what we need
GWS Players Out of Contract in 2019 GWS Player Contracts
Name Years Service Status
Adam Tomlinson 8 Restricted Free Agent
Brent Daniels 2 Non-Free Agent
Brett Deledio 3 Non-Free Agent
Daniel Lloyd 4 Non-Free Agent
Dylan Shiel 8 Restricted Free Agent
Harrison Himmelberg 4 Non-Free Agent
Jacob Hopper 4 Non-Free Agent
Joshua Kelly 6 Non-Free Agent
Matthew Buntine 8 Restricted Free Agent
Matthew De Boer 3 Non-Free Agent
Matthew Flynn 4 Non-Free Agent
Nick Haynes 8 Restricted Free Agent
Rory Lobb 6 Non-Free Agent
Sam Taylor 2 Non-Free Agent
Stephen Coniglio 8 Restricted Free Agent
- Apr 12, 2017
- 2,949
- 9,847
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
He is out of contract. No idea what he would cost. Probably worth about a mid-20's?
Do Crows need a ruck with Jacobs cooked? Maybe pick 3 + Hickey for 7, 13 and Seedsman?
Hickey and Dunstan for Seedsman...
StCicatriz
Brownlow Medallist
- Aug 3, 2016
- 29,125
- 63,691
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
expect WCE to go hard at Lobb and jump in front of Freo who are also chasing him hard
StCicatriz
Brownlow Medallist
- Aug 3, 2016
- 29,125
- 63,691
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
Adelaide received Seedsman and gave up pick No.32; Collingwood drafted him with pick 76
thats what adelaide paid for seedsman when he was 23 and approaching his prime mature window
so any idea that it would cost us a first rounder is utter madness especially for a bloke out of contract and hardly sought after. he has similar value to koby when we took him i reckon. its a cheap money ball pick up. so another money ball player sent to them, or a third round selection which would be early given our ladder position
lets be honest adelaide would take that
thats what adelaide paid for seedsman when he was 23 and approaching his prime mature window
so any idea that it would cost us a first rounder is utter madness especially for a bloke out of contract and hardly sought after. he has similar value to koby when we took him i reckon. its a cheap money ball pick up. so another money ball player sent to them, or a third round selection which would be early given our ladder position
lets be honest adelaide would take that
StCicatriz
Brownlow Medallist
- Aug 3, 2016
- 29,125
- 63,691
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
something is up with this sydney hanneberry thing. sydney must be into someone up to their eye balls and want to restructure their cap to support that.
even weirder is how much john longmuire has been blind sided by this whole thing, even though, lethers called tom harley to get approval to speak to hanners.
even weirder is how much john longmuire has been blind sided by this whole thing, even though, lethers called tom harley to get approval to speak to hanners.
- Status
