List Mgmt. 2019 Draft and Trade Hypotheticals Thread

[The King!]

I agree swans are into him. I think Longmire would be happy to have Nic Nat he’d be frothing, Franklin, Nic Nat and Alir in the same team Sinclair probably get traded back to Melbourne. I wonder what money to get nic Nat in the red and white .

Imagine the weasels losing their ****...

nic nat signed a contract

 

[DST]

Not negative about him at all.
Have said multiple times how good a player the kids is.
Also said his left foot is amazing!
But as a replacement for an AFL player, 2020 or 2021 would not see him big enough.
I think Campbell is a better choice due to size, toughness and willingness to contest, something that would replace a small forward if they decided to head back to Melbourne.

Relax, we will be taking both Gulden and Campbell unless a club loses their mind and puts a bid in at 1.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[The King!]

there's a few outside players on the free agent list look ok

 

[DobmusEdge]

We are desparate for inside mids and a ruckman.

Cameron is not the answer. Cut or trade.

Ollie tries hard but is not big enough. Heeney is too injury prone and with Florent is a bigger threat on the outside. I'd ask Dawson to play at the coalface. I would recruit the best available inside mid and trade for a ruckman.

Heeney has played 94 games in his first 4.5 seasons and every game this year. Most games he missed was from glandular fever in 2017.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[DobmusEdge]

Pull me up ! , it's a dissagrement on the matter. She has her ideas and I have mine . Like a reporter I have my sources and I can't divulge who they are . Players at all levels don't like their coach , people in the Aussie cricket team wouldn't like each other . Thank you for highlighting a lot. TOHCFN.

Every current swans player likes the current coach


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Mick Oxlong]

Heeney has played 94 games in his first 4.5 seasons and every game this year. Most games he missed was from glandular fever in 2017.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[bedford]

Every current swans player likes the current coach


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

hahaha wdtocf

 

[Angry Red Bull]

I left this thread last night because the imperative to be right at all cost by some impacts your mental health. Wake up refreshed this morning and instead start the day going to the media thread only to be confronted with the same imperative to be right over whether a drop on pitch at the scg would need a crane or something equally futile. Come back here to escape the BS only to be confronted with a dispute with a replacement poster this time (presumably the first one gave up through mental health reasons too) about them having superior sources to know that which no one can know- the minds/ opinions of a collective forty odd people- the list. When the imperative to be right becomes obsessive to the point of failing to conceive even the remotest possibility that someone else may be right on occasion then time for personal reflection aimed at change. Sad indictment on emotional intelligence if you cant. As for me well I'm off for respite again knowing full well I may be subject of acronym abuse/ ridicule masquerading as humour. Don't think I'm alone in saying that a posters capacity to enjoy the site is completely lost with this nonsense.

 

[Blood red]

I left this thread last night because the imperative to be right at all cost by some impacts your mental health. Wake up refreshed this morning and instead start the day going to the media thread only to be confronted with the same imperative to be right over whether a drop on pitch at the scg would need a crane or something equally futile. Come back here to escape the BS only to be confronted with a dispute with a replacement poster this time (presumably the first one gave up through mental health reasons too) about them having superior sources to know that which no one can know- the minds/ opinions of a collective forty odd people- the list. When the imperative to be right becomes obsessive to the point of failing to conceive even the remotest possibility that someone else may be right on occasion then time for personal reflection aimed at change. Sad indictment on emotional intelligence if you cant. As for me well I'm off for respite again knowing full well I may be subject of acronym abuse/ ridicule masquerading as humour. Don't think I'm alone in saying that a posters capacity to enjoy the site is completely lost with this nonsense.

Nicely written Puke.
Some days it seems that a simple opinion and chat board can only be directed by a 'supreme' few.
How bout you take a look at the 19s and 18s coming through the academy (NEAFL and Allies) and give us your thoughts on their draftability?
Kick the real draft discussion off again.
Enjoy the break.

 

[Grand Uncle Horace]

Nicely written Puke.
Some days it seems that a simple opinion and chat board can only be directed by a 'supreme' few.
How bout you take a look at the 19s and 18s coming through the academy (NEAFL and Allies) and give us your thoughts on their draftability?
Kick the real draft discussion off again.
Enjoy the break.

Actually there is not that many 'supreme' types. The ex cheer squad leader is about the only one who fails to contribute to debate.

Today the Allies play SA and Vic Country play WA. Plenty of talent on display in these matches.

I am starting to wonder if Kilpatrick is worth drafting. Despite not looking in ripping fitness, he invariably jags a goal or more in the Ressies. What do others think?

 

[Blood red]

Actually there is not that many 'supreme' types. The ex cheer squad leader is about the only one who fails to contribute to debate.

Today the Allies play SA and Vic Country play WA. Plenty of talent on display in these matches.

I am starting to wonder if Kilpatrick is worth drafting. Despite not looking in ripping fitness, he invariably jags a goal or more in the Ressies. What do others think?

Not just on this thread. But comment on others and look out. It's hilarious!
Kilpatrick does Jag a goal and offer speed.
I just don't think he offers enough.
Wicks is a similar type, but goes a lot harder at the ball, can play inside or outside and go forward.
I can't see Kilpatrick ever making a best 22. So is it worth it?

 

[bedford]

Talk about off topic !

 

[Membling]

Kemp has finally been moved mid for VC and looked exceptional. Unfortunately draft stocks rising so probably need to trade up for him.

Flanders is great inside mid but butchers it without space.

Schorenberg looms a very likely inside/outside mid type. First rounder but bit of a reach at our probable pick.

Serong looks good to go as a mid. Has decent skills and a killer instinct.

Likely top 10 or so:

1. Anderson
2. Rowell
3. Young
4. Gould
5. Serong
6. Kemp
7. Green
8. Williams
9. Ash
10. Taheny
11. Sharp
12. Byrnes
13. Stephens
14. McAsey
15. Pickett

SA v VC today at 1410.

 

[DavyRed]

Kemp has finally been moved mid for VC and looked exceptional. Unfortunately draft stocks rising so probably need to trade up for him.

Flanders is great inside mid but butchers it without space.

Schorenberg looms a very likely inside/outside mid type. First rounder but bit of a reach at our probable pick.

Serong looks good to go as a mid. Has decent skills and a killer instinct.

Likely top 10 or so:

1. Anderson
2. Rowell
3. Young
4. Gould
5. Serong
6. Kemp
7. Green
8. Williams
9. Ash
10. Taheny
11. Sharp
12. Byrnes
13. Stephens
14. McAsey
15. Pickett

SA v VC today at 1410.

Thanks but small correction - it’s VC v WA today at 1410 and SA v Allies at 1640.

 

[Membling]

Thanks but small correction - it’s VC v WA today at 1410 and SA v Allies at 1630.

My bad, got mixed up with the vic teams and opponents

 

[caesar88]

Reilly O’Brien may look elsewhere if the Crows get Grundy. We would be mad not to look into him.

 

[BloodySwan]

Reilly O’Brien may look elsewhere if the Crows get Grundy. We would be mad not to look into him.

His contract runs out this year. We should be going after him already if we're not

 

[The King!]

errol gulden looks alright- small sample of course i saw

 

[The King!]

I left this thread last night because the imperative to be right at all cost by some impacts your mental health. Wake up refreshed this morning and instead start the day going to the media thread only to be confronted with the same imperative to be right over whether a drop on pitch at the scg would need a crane or something equally futile. Come back here to escape the BS only to be confronted with a dispute with a replacement poster this time (presumably the first one gave up through mental health reasons too) about them having superior sources to know that which no one can know- the minds/ opinions of a collective forty odd people- the list. When the imperative to be right becomes obsessive to the point of failing to conceive even the remotest possibility that someone else may be right on occasion then time for personal reflection aimed at change. Sad indictment on emotional intelligence if you cant. As for me well I'm off for respite again knowing full well I may be subject of acronym abuse/ ridicule masquerading as humour. Don't think I'm alone in saying that a posters capacity to enjoy the site is completely lost with this nonsense.

its modern society and im sure im guilty of it plenty,its a bit off topic, but see kahwi in the nba, everyone wants to be the first to announce and first to have the source and the scoop

keep posting mate dont let others ruin it, if its ever me call me a toss and we can move on, ignore others, i enjoy reading your stuff

 

[caesar88]

errol gulden looks alright- small sample of course i saw

Would’ve had at least half a dozen more touches if he wasn’t blatantly snubbed/kicks to him didn’t miss by ten yards

 

[Mick Oxlong]

Would’ve had at least half a dozen more touches if he wasn’t blatantly snubbed/kicks to him didn’t miss by ten yards

Shoulda, coulda, woulda...didn’t!

 

[The King!]

Shoulda, coulda, woulda...didn’t!

i shoulda played afl

 

[bedford]

i shoulda played afl

Aussie rules it is , AFL is 1 comp.

 

[kickthething]

The level of footy in the SA v Allies match was pretty disappointing from what I saw. This is going to be a skinny draft. Some of the play was no better, and possibly worse, than what you see in the NAB league every day. There are some good players running around in the NAB league who are much more likely draft types than the groups I saw in the second match today.

 

[Mick Oxlong]

The level of footy in the SA v Allies match was pretty disappointing from what I saw. This is going to be a skinny draft. Some of the play was no better, and possibly worse, than what you see in the NAB league every day. There are some good players running around in the NAB league who are much more likely draft types than the groups I saw in the second match today.

Dalrymple himself said that the pool was disappointing in his podcast as guest last week (May have been week before). Said something like there was no consistency in the ‘star’ players outside of Rowell & Anderson (and May have alluded that they weren’t setting the world on fire in the champs).