2019 Player X v Y v Z

[Asho81]

Williams V Newman

Both


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Red Syrah]

Cripps + Dusty
v
Fyfe + Neale

 

[samFFC]

Viney and Yeo

Or

Kelly and Shuey

Josh? If so, then those two.

 

[SHAKESPEARE]

Cripps + Dusty
v
Fyfe + Neale

Geez.

I would say...cripps and dusty.

I've got cripps and fyfe

 

[Seymour Skinner]

if both are fit for round 1...Greene V Daniher.
Greene probably will score better, Daniher possibly a higher ceiling..?
not sure if either will be top 6 fwd come year end so will probably become F7 at the end...or be stones to the top 6 guys.
with this in mind Daniher is likely better for cash gen, Greene for Points.
not sure which is the better way to go with rooks uncertain atm.

Daniher.
Like you said, better cash gen. Neither will be keepers imo.

 

[ubeaut]

Greene is a

Daniher.
Like you said, better cash gen. Neither will be keepers imo.

Greene is a proven scorer, having averaged 90,103,95,96 before. Can't say that for Joe.
People were picking him last year for 500k+ as a premo. He's what 330k? Possibly a keeper or last upgrade. Daniher is a KPP with a dodgy groin. It's not even close.

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

Viney and Yeo

Or

Kelly and Shuey

Kelly and Shuey but next year at M1 and M2

emirite Daniel McL

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

Cripps + Dusty
v
Fyfe + Neale

Cripps + Dusty

 

[Seymour Skinner]

Greene is a

Greene is a proven scorer, having averaged 90,103,95,96 before. Can't say that for Joe.
People were picking him last year for 500k+ as a premo. He's what 330k? Possibly a keeper or last upgrade. Daniher is a KPP with a dodgy groin. It's not even close.

19, 19, 15, 22, 21, 16, 7.
That's Greene's games played per year.
To be a cash cow you've actually gotta get on the ground.

He also cost 77k more than Daniher who has played 5, 20, 22, 22, 22, 7.

Hope you've got decent cover if you think Greene can be a keeper.

 

[Daniel McL]

Kelly and Shuey but next year at M1 and M2

emirite Daniel McL

M2 & M3, behind Parfitt at M1.

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

M2 & M3, behind Parfitt at M1.

 

[Daniel McL]

Actually just Parfitt M1. Better options for M2 & M3 over Kelly/Shuey

 

[Red Syrah]

Geez.

I would say...cripps and dusty.

I've got cripps and fyfe

cheers. so if upgrading someone to cripps:

upgrade dusty or sloane?

(I'm thinking upgrade Slaone bc Dusty has more upside (but also more downside...))

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

Actually just Parfitt M1. Better options for M2 & M3 over Kelly/Shuey

What Duckwood, turncoat and clangerfield

 

[Daniel McL]

What Duckwood, turncoat and clangerfield

Who’s turncoat?

You aren’t allowed to pick Danger at F1 this year the way you’re talking sh*t about him

But no, you can have Kelly & Shuey, I’ll take Cripps & J. Kelly

 

[Unknown Identity]

Interested in peoples thoughts on:

Angus Brayshaw vs Jaeger O'Meara

imo both primed to go 100+ this season.

 

[BuddysBuddy23]

Interested in peoples thoughts on:

Angus Brayshaw vs Jaeger O'Meara

imo both primed to go 100+ this season.

Brayshaw. JOM to possibly cop more attention with Titch out. Expect both to keep trending up, Brayshaw slightly more so

 

[Daniel McL]

Interested in peoples thoughts on:

Angus Brayshaw vs Jaeger O'Meara

imo both primed to go 100+ this season.

Really rate both, but if I had to pick one it would be Brayshaw as he’s unlikely to be tagged (as teams will tag Oliver first) while O’Meara could be tagged as soon as he dominates a few games in a row considering there’s no Titch.

 

[Unknown Identity]

Brayshaw. JOM to possibly cop more attention with Titch out. Expect both to keep trending up, Brayshaw slightly more so

Brayshaw really came on nicely late in the year.

Went 108 avg from Round 15 to 23.

I am wary of JOM's extra attention.

 

[SHAKESPEARE]

cheers. so if upgrading someone to cripps:

upgrade dusty or sloane?

(I'm thinking upgrade Slaone bc Dusty has more upside (but also more downside...))

Sloane. 100%

 

[Daniel McL]

Neale M4 & Stocker M6.

OR

Brayshaw M4 & Walsh M6?

 

[BuddysBuddy23]

Neale M4 & Stocker M6.

OR

Brayshaw M4 & Walsh M6?

1st option

 

[Squiba]

A) Jelly, A. Brayshaw and Fyfe (~100k in kitty)

vs


B) Fyfe, A. Brayshaw and Miles (~400k in Kitty)

vs

C) Fyfe, Jelly and Miles (~300k in Kitty)

 

[Chism]

Shiel V Wingard??

Both can score big and are about the same price ( 480k) with the Chad having the DPP to swing forward.

I reckon Shiel averages more personally and could be a huge POD.

 

[ubeaut]

Shiel V Wingard??

Both can score big and are about the same price ( 480k) with the Chad having the DPP to swing forward.

I reckon Shiel averages more personally and could be a huge POD.

Sheil may average more but he's a mid only. Chad's fwd eligibility gives him more value. Sheil has never been a premo SC scorer, despite racking up large numbers due to disposal efficiency. Likely to be tagged.