2019 Player X v Y v Z

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
Shiel V Wingard??

Both can score big and are about the same price ( 480k) with the Chad having the DPP to swing forward.

I reckon Shiel averages more personally and could be a huge POD.
Shiel definitely scores more but how much more is the question. You'd want him to average 105 as a MID only and be a keeper otherwise his price will stay pretty stagnant.

Wingard likely to be a much better premo FWD than Shiel a MID. But priced at 89avg there isn't much of an updside (I do have him though but he's no way essential).
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Interested in peoples thoughts on:

Angus Brayshaw vs Jaeger O'Meara

imo both primed to go 100+ this season.
I've got both currently, so avoid at all costs. lol
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Oliver/Kelly, Whitfield, Rookie

Vs

Zerrett, Witherden, Libba

The old premo vs midpricers disucssion. Option 2 probably looks sexier on paper but is does having 2 guys who should finish in the top 10 in their position + a rookie work out long term versus 3 blokes who could all very easily finish outside that.

Ultimately if there’s enough good looking Rooks I’ll probably look at option 1, not entirely convinced about any of the guys in option 2.
 
Fyfe and walsh

Vs

Macrea and mchenry?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top