List Mgmt. 2022 Draft and Trade Hypotheticals: Kinnear & Dalrymple - we march to no drum but our own!

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
Reader mode

Log in to remove this ad.

Paddy mac is playing a similar role to Aliir and it's the role Rampe would've played if the McCartin/Melican set up went well. I miss the rebounding/intercept marking rampe who played as the 3rd main defender. IMO that was the best version of Rampe. How long is Paddy signed for? assume he would need a big upgrade on the basis of his performance.
 
BloodySwan said:
Eagles and Essendon I expect will be keen to offload some dead weight at the end of the year. They have some real talent but club culture feels like a bigger issue than anything else
Click to expand...

Eagles should just come out and say we're prioritising youth etc this year and are in a rebuild. Essendon are in a bigger hole imo, they've been inept for a while now and it doesn't look like changing in the near future.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

caesar88 said:
I mean, not really his fault Port are average this year. Everyone knows that if he's played in the right role and allowed . to play in it, he's a gun. Weird that he gets knocked for being limited to that role when it's simply the role he's suited to, like literally every other player who isn't a dual-role player and/or utility. Buddy went into the ruck a few times in a game earlier this year and he looked ******* awful. Is he a lesser player now? Of course not. He's just an athletic forward, not a ruck.
Click to expand...
I reckon Port would say he is reflective of the problems at Port. He has been ordinary this year after taking it all in front of him last year. I don’t think that is controversial, just is what it is. The point is Hewett is going well after the change, the overall trade value will be assessed over the seasons…not 10 games. That Buddy comparison by the way was Gold.
 
Nuggetz said:
Paddy mac is playing a similar role to Aliir and it's the role Rampe would've played if the McCartin/Melican set up went well. I miss the rebounding/intercept marking rampe who played as the 3rd main defender. IMO that was the best version of Rampe. How long is Paddy signed for? assume he would need a big upgrade on the basis of his performance.
Click to expand...
Assuming he stays healthy I think we should assume 2+1 with upgraded $. Take him to 28yo with a similar contract as his last. Amazing pickup.
 
www.afl.com.au

Mid-Season Draft: Eagles close on No.1 pick, latest whispers

Tall midfielder likely to head to West Coast with the first pick in Wednesday night's NAB AFL Mid-Season Rookie Draft
www.afl.com.au www.afl.com.au

Article on tips for who goes where in the MSD..
No mention of Swans. Kinnear and Dalrymple have obviously (again) told Cal Twomey Sweet FA.. haha good job Kinnear.

Ill back El Nour to be a Swan (pure guess)
 
SGBeach said:
www.afl.com.au

Mid-Season Draft: Eagles close on No.1 pick, latest whispers

Tall midfielder likely to head to West Coast with the first pick in Wednesday night's NAB AFL Mid-Season Rookie Draft
www.afl.com.au www.afl.com.au

Article on tips for who goes where in the MSD..
No mention of Swans. Kinnear and Dalrymple have obviously (again) told Cal Twomey Sweet FA.. haha good job Kinnear.

Ill back El Nour to be a Swan (pure guess)
Click to expand...
I'd be happy with El Nour. Truth be told at pick 11 in the MSD our pick will likely be made for us
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

MSD tonight, these seem to be our leading contenders

Massimo D'Ambrossio
The sharp-kicking defender has increased his stocks this season after not getting a shot in his draft year in 2021. The 18-year-old comes from the Western Jets program but has also played for Richmond's VFL side, including last weekend when he had 25 disposals and four inside-50s on the MCG. The 178cm prospect is an elite kick and starred for the Young Guns, with games of 24 and 32 disposals in successive weeks. Can play on the wing or half-back.


Mutaz El Nour​

El Nour has shown plenty of promising development as a key-position defender for the Northern Bullants this season. Seen by AFL clubs as a third tall defender, El Nour is a strong intercept player and has averaged 17.9 disposals and 6.3 marks per game at VFL level so far this year. Listed at 192cm, El Nour is believed to have grown considerably this season, potentially helping his ability to play on bigger bodies in the senior system.

Jacob Bauer
Bauer was overlooked by Sydney during last year's draft process, having graduated from the club’s Academy system. He has since moved to North Adelaide, and into the forward line, where he's had an immediate impact with his athleticism and high-leaping marking ability. The 191cm forward kicked 13 goals from his first three SANFL games, with clubs noting some strong AFL attributes particularly in the air. Still just 19, and still adjusting to his new position in attack, clubs believe there is plenty of growth remaining in his game

Hugo Hall-Kahan
An exciting medium forward who has impressed with his tricks inside 50 in the first half of the season with the Sandringham Dragons. The 188cm goalkicker booted five majors in round two this season and another four in round four and last week had 20 disposals in the NAB League. He was also a standout for the Young Guns, including kicking two goals against Vic Country's under-18 side. Turning 19 later this year, Hall-Kahan capable of marking in the air and also doing some snapping or creating a chance from nothing at ground level. He won an exemption to nominate for the draft after not nominating last year.

In saying that we seem to always spring a surprise. Will likely pick someone we've never been linked to before
 
Final Mid-Season Draft Order
  • Index
    • FINAL MID-SEASON DRAFT ORDER


    1. West Coast (via Oscar Allen injury)
    2. North Melbourne (via Miller Bergman injury)
    3. Essendon (via Anthony McDonald-Tipungwuti retirement)
    4. Adelaide (via Rory Sloane injury)
    5. GWS Giants (via Josh Fahey injury)
    6. Hawthorn (via open list spot)
    7. Gold Coast (via Ben King injury)
    8. Port Adelaide (via Jake Pasini injury)
    9. Collingwood (via Nathan Kreuger injury)
    10. Richmond (via Josh Caddy retirement)
    11. Sydney (via open list spot)
    12. Geelong (via open list spot)
    13. Carlton (via open list spot)
    14. St Kilda (via Nick Coffield injury)
    15. Fremantle (via open list spot)

    ROUND TWO

    16. West Coast (via Luke Edwards injury)
    17. North Melbourne (via Tom Lynch retirement)
    18. Essendon (via Nik Cox injury)
    19. Adelaide (via Paul Seedsman injury)
    20. Hawthorn (via Tyler Brockman injury)
    21. Collingwood (via Jordan Roughead retirement)
    22. Carlton (via Oscar McDonald injury)
    23. Fremantle (via Jye Amiss injury)
     
  • Index
    • BloodySwan said:
    MSD tonight, these seem to be our leading contenders

    Massimo D'Ambrossio
    The sharp-kicking defender has increased his stocks this season after not getting a shot in his draft year in 2021. The 18-year-old comes from the Western Jets program but has also played for Richmond's VFL side, including last weekend when he had 25 disposals and four inside-50s on the MCG. The 178cm prospect is an elite kick and starred for the Young Guns, with games of 24 and 32 disposals in successive weeks. Can play on the wing or half-back.


    Mutaz El Nour​

    El Nour has shown plenty of promising development as a key-position defender for the Northern Bullants this season. Seen by AFL clubs as a third tall defender, El Nour is a strong intercept player and has averaged 17.9 disposals and 6.3 marks per game at VFL level so far this year. Listed at 192cm, El Nour is believed to have grown considerably this season, potentially helping his ability to play on bigger bodies in the senior system.

    Jacob Bauer
    Bauer was overlooked by Sydney during last year's draft process, having graduated from the club’s Academy system. He has since moved to North Adelaide, and into the forward line, where he's had an immediate impact with his athleticism and high-leaping marking ability. The 191cm forward kicked 13 goals from his first three SANFL games, with clubs noting some strong AFL attributes particularly in the air. Still just 19, and still adjusting to his new position in attack, clubs believe there is plenty of growth remaining in his game

    Hugo Hall-Kahan
    An exciting medium forward who has impressed with his tricks inside 50 in the first half of the season with the Sandringham Dragons. The 188cm goalkicker booted five majors in round two this season and another four in round four and last week had 20 disposals in the NAB League. He was also a standout for the Young Guns, including kicking two goals against Vic Country's under-18 side. Turning 19 later this year, Hall-Kahan capable of marking in the air and also doing some snapping or creating a chance from nothing at ground level. He won an exemption to nominate for the draft after not nominating last year.

    In saying that we seem to always spring a surprise. Will likely pick someone we've never been linked to before
    Click to expand...

    Depends on how he kicked his goals of course but 13 goals in 3 games in the SNAFL is nothing to sneeze at. Could really use a tall defender though.
     
    RUNVS said:
    Depends on how he kicked his goals of course but 13 goals in 3 games in the SNAFL is nothing to sneeze at. Could really use a tall defender though.
    Click to expand...
    The Swans look at players that are tall forwards and say "Ha, we'll see about that." I'm surprised Logan hasn't been given a run in defence yet tbh. Bauer has been mentioned as a swingman somewhere, so that's just giving us an invitation. Our current 3 best 22 tall defenders all started forward. My only request if we bring in someone called Jacob Bauer, that he takes Rampe's number 24 when Dane retires and we just nickname him Jack instead of Jake.
     
    Bloods86 said:
    The Swans look at players that are tall forwards and say "Ha, we'll see about that." I'm surprised Logan hasn't been given a run in defence yet tbh. Bauer has been mentioned as a swingman somewhere, so that's just giving us an invitation. Our current 3 best 22 tall defenders all started forward. My only request if we bring in someone called Jacob Bauer, that he takes Rampe's number 24 when Dane retires and we just nickname him Jack instead of Jake.
    Click to expand...
    To be fair, we tend to try them as forwards for a while and shift them to defence when things don't work out so well.
     
    Reader mode
    Status
    Not open for further replies.

    Remove this Banner Ad

    Similar threads

    hairy biker
    • Poll
    List Mgmt. 2024 Draft & Trade Hypotheticals
    383 384 385 386 387
    Replies
    10K
    Views
    280K
    Nuggetz
    Nuggetz
    Ticky009
    Review The Week in Between - now we wait. Selection talk and other guff.
    19 20 21 22 23
    Replies
    562
    Views
    14K
    bedford
    B
    Callipygian
    List Mgmt. 2024 AFLW trade and draft
    2
    Replies
    33
    Views
    1K
    Ticky009
    Ticky009
    Heeney2Franklin
    Autopsy And we are into another Granny! comprehensive 36 point win over Port.
    23 24 25 26 27
    Replies
    666
    Views
    15K
    giantsully
    G
    Ticky009
    Analysis The Stats and nothing but the Stats
    10 11 12 13 14
    Replies
    333
    Views
    16K
    caesar88
    caesar88
    Ticky009
    • Locked
    List Mgmt. 2023 Draft & Trade Hypotheticals
    813 814 815 816 817
    Replies
    20K
    Views
    602K
    Ticky009
    Ticky009
    Ticky009
    • Locked
    Unofficial Preview Collingwood vs Swans Friday March 15th 7:40PM
    2 3 4 5 6
    Replies
    125
    Views
    4K
    RUNVS
    RUNVS

    Remove this Banner Ad

    Back
    Top