2022 Hawthorn List Management Discussion (including Trade, FA period)

[Since 2001]

Poulter, narkle and stack are the ones id go after

 

[CaptainWorpedo]

Poulter, narkle and stack are the ones id go after

For me Poulter and or Stock

 

[Denver Day Lewis]

I'm fully prepared to be chuck that jumper on and sit in the stands.

I'd be happy to suit up and try and nab a couple of sausage rolls from the forward pocket.

Only issue would be raising money to pay the fine for ground invasion. Is that what OnlyFans is for?

 

[Steven Tyler]

Would rather Stocker from Carlton if we go down the path of picking up a delisted player

 

[The Chad and I]

I really liked Poulter in his draft highlights.
Reminded me a lot of Birchall.
Stunned that he has been delisted already.

WTF happened?

 

[HODGEYROAD]

I really liked Poulter in his draft highlights.
Reminded me a lot of Birchall.
Stunned that he has been delisted already.

WTF happened?

I dunno, but none of my Collingwood mates seem to give a rats arse.

 

[TylerDurden]

I really liked Poulter in his draft highlights.
Reminded me a lot of Birchall.
Stunned that he has been delisted already.

WTF happened?

Apparently very soft.

 

[SunshineHawkCal]

Would rather Stocker from Carlton if we go down the path of picking up a delisted player

I'm with ya on this one, he'd be the one I'd use one of our 5 senior spots with.

Any thoughts on Stein?

 

[Scrads]

I've seen a few people suggesting we trade up with Brisbane for their Pick 34. If that does go ahead, it would surely be their Pick 36 given the other 2 picks get swallowed by bids so they get more points at no cost to us.

Here is an example. I've stuck with the numbers they are now for simplicity but they will change after their (and Essendon's) bids obviously.

33 - Port
34 - Hawks
35 - Bris (gone after matching)
36 - Bris (gone after matching)
37 - Melb (becomes 35)

As opposed to

33 - Port
34 - Bris (gone after matching)
35 - Bris (gone after matching)
36 - Hawks (becomes 34)
37 - Melb (becomes 35)

As you can see, it makes no difference to who we would select but it does give Brisbane 40 more points than if it were 34 they gave us.

 

[PenAndPaper]

I dunno, but none of my Collingwood mates seem to give a rats arse.

He's not a great kick and panics under pressure, definitely not the type of player we need.

I find it strange we even apparently had a look at him.

 

[Nugett]

s**t drink, but cheap and gets you buzzed

The R2D’s before there was R2D’s.

 

[Buckemenico]

Narkle is an option. Had 35 possessions in an AFL game - that must mean some ability for a guy who can be picked up for free.

 

[hawkmang]

Narkle is an option. Had 35 possessions in an AFL game - that must mean some ability for a guy who can be picked up for free.

He is also mates with Brocky. Would be good to have him at the club, you never know it might be the difference between Brocky sticking around long term if he has an old mate to lean on

 

[DEECEE]

Narkle is an option. Had 35 possessions in an AFL game - that must mean some ability for a guy who can be picked up for free.

At a minimum, we invite him to do a preseason with us? Gauge his interest. Absolutely nothing to lose.

Sent from my SM-S901E using Tapatalk

 

[Ned Ryerson]

Narkle is an option. Had 35 possessions in an AFL game - that must mean some ability for a guy who can be picked up for free.

Ben Ronke once kicked 7 goals on us as well - it doesn't mean he was a good player.

 

[theiaofseed]

Narkle is an option. Had 35 possessions in an AFL game - that must mean some ability for a guy who can be picked up for free.

Hartung had 26 touches and a goal on debut.

 

[TDS7]

Hartung had 26 touches and a goal on debut.

Wrong sport, but Michael Carter-Williams famously beat the LeBron Heatles with a near quadruple-double 22 points, 12 assists, 7 rebounds, 9 steals on the worst team I've ever laid eyes upon. One afternoon does not a career make.

 

[JZedd]

Would rather Stocker from Carlton if we go down the path of picking up a delisted player

Just seems immoral drafting scraps from Carlton.

 

[hawkmang]

Just seems immoral drafting scraps from Carlton.

I think his situation is a bit different to the usual garbage they put out for council hard rubbish collection

 

[arupist]

Hartung had 26 touches and a goal on debut.

Beau Muston had 31 and a goal on debut

 

[Noel Gallagher]

Poulter, narkle and stack are the ones id go after

Wouldn’t waste my time on any of them including Stocker. They were all delisted for very good reasons. Hit the draft and the wait for the MSD which has been absolute gold for us lately

 

[Brant]

Wouldn’t waste my time on any of them including Stocker. They were all delisted for very good reasons. Hit the draft and the wait for t together MSD which has been absolute gold for us lately

We'll be screwed if AFL phase out the MSD for a mid-sesson trade period

 

[Nugett]

I really liked Poulter in his draft highlights.
Reminded me a lot of Birchall.
Stunned that he has been delisted already.

WTF happened?

he still has a full set of teeth?

 

[KermitJagger]

He is also mates with Brocky. Would be good to have him at the club, you never know it might be the difference between Brocky sticking around long term if he has an old mate to lean on

Carrying a player who can't cut it at AFL level in order to keep a player who hasn't proved himself able to cut it at AFL level isn't the most sound list management strategy. The bloke has worse career averages than Cousins did.

 

[TDS7]

Carrying a player who can't cut it at AFL level in order to keep a player who hasn't proved himself able to cut it at AFL level isn't the most sound list management strategy. The bloke has worse career averages than Cousins did.

He averages more than one crack binge a season?