List Mgmt. 2022 List Management and trading thread

[Scorpus]

I saw this format on the West Coast board and thought it might help understand our current list position

 

[CrowsB4hoes]

Thought it was Pick 8 of that year??

Oops, forgot the link

Source says Adelaide Crows were prepared trade star forward Kurt Tippett to Brisbane Lions last year

Lions not tempted on Kurt Tippett

www.foxsports.com.au

Pick 12 & 30 is better in hindsight but still unders for what Tippett was providing for us at the time.

 

[ams4crows]

Oops, forgot the link

Source says Adelaide Crows were prepared trade star forward Kurt Tippett to Brisbane Lions last year

Lions not tempted on Kurt Tippett

www.foxsports.com.au

Pick 12 & 30 is better in hindsight but still unders for what Tippett was providing for us at the time.

I reckon Melbourne offered us Pick 2? for Dangerfield the year before he became a free agent and we said no. Which was Petracca....

 

[ams4crows]

Look at the difference in the ball. That's so obviously a shank from Keays, in comparison that Ball drop from Thilthorpe looks like perfection.

 

[MarcusP2]

I reckon Melbourne offered us Pick 2? for Dangerfield the year before he became a free agent and we said no. Which was Petracca....

How do you convince danger to go to the demons in this scenario?

On Pixel 5 using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[morris086]

I reckon Melbourne offered us Pick 2? for Dangerfield the year before he became a free agent and we said no. Which was Petracca....

Pick 2 and 3 (Brayshaw) was the rumour.

 

[LeftyLuke]

How do you convince danger to go to the demons in this scenario?

On Pixel 5 using BigFooty.com mobile app

Organise his parents well paying jobs. Aka the Geelong playbook.

 

[CrowsB4hoes]

I reckon Melbourne offered us Pick 2? for Dangerfield the year before he became a free agent and we said no. Which was Petracca....

Dangerfield was never going to agree to going to Melbourne

 

[Play On Advantage]

View attachment 1451677
View attachment 1451678

Look at the difference in the ball. That's so obviously a shank from Keays, in comparison that Ball drop from Thilthorpe looks like perfection.

This post is just embarrassing. Yes Keays isn't the best kick in the team but at least compare oranges with oranges to make a point, not two photos at different stages of impact.

 

[Rory Walkerfield]

This post is just embarrassing. Yes Keays isn't the best kick in the team but at least compare oranges with oranges to make a point, not two photos at different stages of impact.

Who says the Keays one isn’t prior to impact with the foot. Bad drop!!

 

[dylan123]

Keays got some serious tape on those fingers.

 

[MRB37]

For the slow people like me, what’s the answer to this ?

Yeah, what gives. I’m as thick as two planks.

Hamill is a small, running defender who wants to be aggressive by foot, seems obvious to me he's going to want to pick the brains of guys like Seedsman and Smith for offensive advice and Brown for defence over a taller, intercepting defender in Doedee.

 

[Mutineer]

Who says the Keays one isn’t prior to impact with the foot. Bad drop!!

I do.

 

[1970crow]

For the slow people like me, what’s the answer to this ?

Doedee an intercepting tall type player, Smith and Seed are runners and Brown a small lockdown. He’s a combo of those 3 and will never be what Dood is. That’s my guess after going down the concussion track that’s not relevant to Brown.

 

[1970crow]

I thought Doedee was Mr Club first. Has he been taking lessons from Sloane?

If you remain in a culture it gets you in the end.

 

[1970crow]

Oops, forgot the link

Source says Adelaide Crows were prepared trade star forward Kurt Tippett to Brisbane Lions last year

Lions not tempted on Kurt Tippett

www.foxsports.com.au

Pick 12 & 30 is better in hindsight but still unders for what Tippett was providing for us at the time.

But the people who knew should have factored in future risk. Anything close to value a year out we should have jumped at. We got less for prime Danger.

 

[George Kramer]

This post is just embarrassing. Yes Keays isn't the best kick in the team but at least compare oranges with oranges to make a point, not two photos at different stages of impact.

Why is the stitching on Keays ball on its side? There’s definitely something off with the kick, no way that ball is going where it’s should with any accuracy and proper ball spin

 

[Mutineer]

Hamill is a small, running defender who wants to be aggressive by foot, seems obvious to me he's going to want to pick the brains of guys like Seedsman and Smith for offensive advice and Brown for defence over a taller, intercepting defender in Doedee.

Strangely enough multiple sources including footywire have both Doedee and Hamill at 187cm in height the difference is in their weight.

 

[spenze]

Why is the stitching on Keays ball on its side? There’s definitely something off with the kick, no way that ball is going where it’s should with any accuracy and proper ball spin

It hit his shin

 

[Rory Walkerfield]

It hit his shin

So one of his better kicks then…

 

[George Kramer]

It hit his shin

Maybe we practise the hack kick

 

[George Kramer]

I can’t understand how we are so tight for list spots with such an average list. Something doesn’t add up

 

[arrowman]

Why is the stitching on Keays ball on its side? There’s definitely something off with the kick, no way that ball is going where it’s should with any accuracy and proper ball spin

It's a look away kick to a target on his right.

Tex-like.

 

[betterthanu]

I can’t understand how we are so tight for list spots with such an average list. Something doesn’t add up

We have a glut of kids which means we have to wait to see if they make it. Normally a list is more spread out in age and the delistings take care of themselves.

 

[WeedsMullet84]

Strangely enough multiple sources including footywire have both Doedee and Hamill at 187cm in height the difference is in their weight.

What is your honest assessment of where Doedee is at?

Did we ask him to play the KPD role on a few occasions and we've just 'coached' the natural interceptor skills out of him?

When we're playing two KPD's already we're lacking a serious interceptor/rebounding defender/creative player, and he's just turned into this dour spoiling 3rd tall.

I've mentioned on another thread this guys peers are your Siciliy, Vlastuin and Stewart type players. We have nothing resembling that type of quality in Doedee. I'm mystified how he hasn't been dropped, other than the fact i think selectors are worried the literal arse of our age profile/experience will drop out from underneath us if we send him back to the SANFL.

Frampton/Worrell are by far better players in that 3rd tall role

 

[George Kramer]

What is your honest assessment of where Doedee is at?

Did we ask him to play the KPD role on a few occasions and we've just 'coached' the natural interceptor skills out of him?

When we're playing two KPD's already we're lacking a serious interceptor/rebounding defender/creative player, and he's just turned into this dour spoiling 3rd tall.

I've mentioned on another thread this guys peers are your Siciliy, Vlastuin and Stewart type players. We have nothing resembling that type of quality in Doedee. I'm mystified how he hasn't been dropped, other than the fact i think selectors are worried the literal arse of our age profile/experience will drop out from underneath us if we send him back to the SANFL.

Frampton/Worrell are by far better players in that 3rd tall role

Smith said that Doedee had niggles from the weekend, didn’t train and had had issues throughout the year. I think he’s been playing pretty banged up and we should have given him a rest and tried Worrell.

Also think the role we have him playing isn’t allowing him to play to his strengths. He should be better than he’s showing given how he started his career