2nds 2023 Adelaide Crows SANFL thread

[Mutineer]

Strachan in the best players again

Wowee he got the slight upperhand over a 20 year old Jordan Lukac a veteran of 8 SANFL League games just out of the U 18's comp.

Like I've said if Strachan is the answer as our AFL ruck going forward you're asking the wrong question.

If we don't draft a young developing ruck this draft then I'll be seriously doubting our list management's focus, there are at least 3 or 4 young rucks worthy of serious consideration outside of the 2 likely to go relatively early Mitch Edwards and Ethan Read. Taylor Goad and Joe Pike both quite athletic, certainly not the lumbering types.

 

[maxlilly]

Wowee he got the slight upperhand over a 20 year old Jordan Lukac a veteran of 8 SANFL League games just out of the U 18's comp.

Like I've said if Strachan is the answer as our AFL ruck going forward you're asking the wrong question.

If we don't draft a young developing ruck this draft then I'll be seriously doubting our list management's focus, there are at least 3 or 4 young rucks worthy of serious consideration outside of the 2 likely to go relatively early Mitch Edwards and Ethan Read. Taylor Goad and Joe Pike both quite athletic, certainly not the lumbering types.

I think everyone wants a young developing ruckman on our list and have for a few years now
I just don't understand the why you want to bag Strachan as all I see is a guy that goes out every week and tries his heart out for the club and does a good job.

 

[Mutineer]

I think everyone wants a young developing ruckman on our list and have for a few years now
I just don't understand the why you want to bag Strachan as all I see is a guy that goes out every week and tries his heart out for the club and does a good job.

At SANFL level he's fine but if you see a long term AFL ruck in him then I repectfully disagree...he's SANFL level and will never be anything else especially looking to the future.

 

[1970crow]

Pity Hately not given some time in the middle. He should be part of rotations with Brown

can't have Hately having big inside mid games in the 2s. No spot in the seniors for him, unless injury occurs.

 

[1970crow]

Wowee he got the slight upperhand over a 20 year old Jordan Lukac a veteran of 8 SANFL League games just out of the U 18's comp.

Like I've said if Strachan is the answer as our AFL ruck going forward you're asking the wrong question.

If we don't draft a young developing ruck this draft then I'll be seriously doubting our list management's focus, there are at least 3 or 4 young rucks worthy of serious consideration outside of the 2 likely to go relatively early Mitch Edwards and Ethan Read. Taylor Goad and Joe Pike both quite athletic, certainly not the lumbering types.

so which of our best players were up against AFL worthy opponents?

 

[PeterSalt]

can't have Hately having big inside mid games in the 2s. No spot in the seniors for him, unless injury occurs.

It's almost like his card is stamped

 

[1970crow]

It's almost like his card is stamped

I think it's unfair considering he was quite fine when playing inside mid before being shunted to a wing in the 1s. That said, if they want to stamp his card, fine, but surely not ahead of that slug Brown's card. He's literally putrid.

 

[PeterSalt]

I think it's unfair considering he was quite fine when playing inside mid before being shunted to a wing in the 1s. That said, if they want to stamp his card, fine, but surely not ahead of that slug Brown's card. He's literally putrid.

Agree

 

[1970crow]

Settle down

your interest in the AFL is pretty much limited to how it and the SA clubs influence the SANFL. Troll is probably a harsh description, but people aren't discussing topics with a fellow person interested in what they're interested in.

 

[Eagleboy2011]

 

[chazwazza]

your interest in the AFL is pretty much limited to how it and the SA clubs influence the SANFL. Troll is probably a harsh description, but people aren't discussing topics with a fellow person interested in what they're interested in.

Don’t assume to know where and what my interests regarding footy are. You’re guessing and grasping at straws to validate your own biases.
Jog on.

 

[bigman]

Harry

 

[cleanhands]

LEGS on the board………… unfortunately not over anyone of significance

 

[brucetiki]

Gee what a weekend to forget for South

 

[cleanhands]

We’re coming

 

[crows dude]

Schoenberg/Cook and Gollant should drop back in and Cook/Schoenberg as the travelling emergency. This would give us 19 listed players plus our captain Wright and Marquee player Madgen. Boyle to be the only real top up player

 

[Ciao Giacomo]

View attachment 1719233


Schoenberg/Cook and Gollant should drop back in and Cook/Schoenberg as the travelling emergency. This would give us 19 listed players plus our captain Wright and Marquee player Madgen. Boyle to be the only real top up player

We will take 24 players to Melbourne.

We have 41 active players on our list (plus Doedee, Taylor and McPherson = 44).

So 17 AFL listed players should play against the Panthers????

 

[Bearded Clam]

Looks like a beautiful day at Flinders oval!

 

[crows dude]

Schoenberg and McAdam both on the board in the first two minutes

2.0 to no score

 

[Bearded Clam]

South getting free kick after free kick.. but it isnt helping them

 

[Bearded Clam]

Mcadam is far too good for this level.

 

[crows dude]

McAdam with another

3.1

South yet to have it past centre. Crows have a massive breeze

 

[crows dude]

Cook goals
Crows 4.1
South 0.1

 

[cleanhands]

McAdam with another

3.1

South yet to have it past centre. Crows have a massive breeze

Has it moved the Grandstand anymore

 

[crows dude]

Brown goals
5.2 to 0.1