Preview 2023 Mid Season Draft Discussion Thread

Remove this Banner Ad

My position on the MSD is we should try to get Ryan Maric from Gipps a 193cm kpf in development or Ethan Stanley a 188cm? Winger from Box Hill, both have impressed me in multiple games, there's another guy I have liked named Rye Penny from Calder as an overeager, he played hbf last year, but had an injury interrupted year, but has impressed again in a different role going through midfield, he would be my 3rd option, other than that I don't know the state leagues so I won't comment on those guys and whether we should look at them or not.

Those Jack Buller highlights look good though, I wonder if he's a target as well?

I liked his mobility including lateral movement. Definitely has something, hate saying it but might be our third best tall forward straght away if we draft him.
 
Yep - reckon he’s worth a shot.

Mature body, 200cm, good agility and has kicked bags at VFL level this year.

Could do a lot worse.
I've gone down to Preston City Oval a few times this season and stats do not do Ryan justice.

He changes the way the Bullants and their opposition play when he's on the ground, if he's forward, rucking, or floating a kick behind the ball. Insane marking ability and field kicking safely above AFL standard.

If I wasn't so emotinally invested in the Box Hill program I'd want no one else.
 

Yep - reckon he’s worth a shot.

Mature body, 200cm, good agility and has kicked bags at VFL level this year.

Could do a lot worse.

Here is a little bit of vision


While watching the Hawks v Bullants game I searched for details on this guy thinking that he looked promising but also that he looked 20yrs old or less. In fact he is 25. Granted he is (sort of) new to AFL and so could have rapid growth in his game but at the time I remember thinking that while he moves well, is a beautiful kick on his left foot and clearly has the size, he lacks ability in the contest. For mine, he would be a project player and well behind Ramsden.

Some more info:
 
Last edited:

Log in to remove this ad.

Very hard to see many positives in that vision considering the opposition, got caught a lot to.
Yes But… he is an 18year old playing against last years grand finalists in the VFL... cut him some slack.

From such young players I am looking for the quality plays as an indication of his potential … and will forgive the mistakes.

We can agree to disagree but I would lIke to see Maric on our list. He is no Jai Newcombe or Max Ramsden in terms of his ceiling, but he could become an AFL quality 3rd tall / high half fwd. That said, if we miss out on him to the Woeful Eagles or Nuffie Norf, … I’ll recover from the disappointment pretty quickly.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Still unsure why the AFL hasn't just made it a mandatory 18 month contract for mid season draftees. 6 months is ridiculous particularly for someone having to move interstate. If clubs don't want to offer that length then they don't get to take a free 6 month hit.
It would probably be a draft full of passes. List size would need to grow before that could happen.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Preview 2023 Mid Season Draft Discussion Thread

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top