Opinion 2023 Player X vs Y vs Z

[Blues of 77]

Cripps v Walsh

Crippa. Needs a big second half. Walsh not being used exclusively on ball.

 

[Northernsoul74]

Can anyone justify going LDU over Sam Walsh?

Yep but I’d wait a week. Looked a must have earlier in the season.

 

[lids2richo]

Luke Ryan v Sinclair v Houston v Docherty for last def spot?

 

[Kedford]

Need to fill my last defensive spot (again...thanks Yeo). I'm contemplating Houston, Sinclair and Ridley (in that order). Take out Houston's 47 against the Dogs and he's averaging highest and is a big POD. Ridley scoring very well recently but has done it against predominantly weaker teams. Sinclair seems back to 2022 scoring but is a little more expensive. Any guidance welcome...Thanks.

I've had Ridley the whole season, even through all his good scoring, he scares me a bit and I don't know why.

Regardless, he looks very confident and back to his usual self.

Also have Sinclair and would be more confident in his role.

 

[Blues of 77]

Luke Ryan v Sinclair v Houston v Docherty for last def spot?

I'm torn between Houston and Sinclair. Ryan has had weak patches and while I love Doc as a Blues fan, his role could change again if they let Saad loose

 

[shockmaster]

Wardlaw v Johnson for M9?

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Wardlaw v Johnson for M9?

 

[hoddo]

It's great that I can loop Wilmot's 120 onto the ground, but the question is, who does he replace?
I can simply move Mullin onto the field for Mitchell meaning Mitchell misses out.
OR
I can switch Constable with Dawson so that Wilmot takes Constable's spot and Mitchell stays onfield while Dawson moves to mids meaning just one instead of two of Fyfe, Sheldrick, Johnson or Humphrey are onfield.

Or to put it another way, which two of Fyfe, Sheldrick, Johnson, Humphrey and Mitchell are the best to have onfield?

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

It's great that I can loop Wilmot's 120 onto the ground, but the question is, who does he replace?
I can simply move Mullin onto the field for Mitchell meaning Mitchell misses out.
OR
I can switch Constable with Dawson so that Wilmot takes Constable's spot and Mitchell stays onfield while Dawson moves to mids meaning just one instead of two of Fyfe, Sheldrick, Johnson or Humphrey are onfield.

Or to put it another way, which two of Fyfe, Sheldrick, Johnson, Humphrey and Mitchell are the best to have onfield?

Mitchell and Sheldrick or Johnson.

Are you holding Humpa?

 

[hoddo]

Mitchell and Sheldrick or Johnson.

Are you holding Humpa?

Thanks, I'm leaning that way too. Just have to make sure I don't close down vc looping options.

Yes I'm holding Humphrey. I know he could lose cash this week if he stays deep forward, but the Suns are moving Humphrey, Powell and Fiorini around each week without any apparent pattern. It seems random as to which of them gets to play in the high scoring position each week. I wouldn't be surprised to see Humphrey back in the mids this week while Fiorini is sent back to the wing or HFF. If there was an obvious cheap rookie to cash him in for I might be tempted, but I'd rather risk a bit of cash to see if his high scoring days really are finished.

 

[JuddgementDay]

Luke Ryan v Sinclair v Houston v Docherty for last def spot?

Sinclair easily

 

[SC fish]

Need to fill my last defensive spot (again...thanks Yeo). I'm contemplating Houston, Sinclair and Ridley (in that order). Take out Houston's 47 against the Dogs and he's averaging highest and is a big POD. Ridley scoring very well recently but has done it against predominantly weaker teams. Sinclair seems back to 2022 scoring but is a little more expensive. Any guidance welcome...Thanks.

I'd go Sinclair

 

[Northernsoul74]

I'm torn between Houston and Sinclair. Ryan has had weak patches and while I love Doc as a Blues fan, his role could change again if they let Saad loose

Sinclair.

 

[No eye deer]

Serong/Walsh vs Trac/Mills.
Leaning toward the latter…

 

[goondog]

Libba+Mills (Ashcroft M9) vs Walsh+Petracca (Johnson M9)

The rest of my midfield is Bont, Laird, Zerrett, Neale, Brayshaw, Steele

 

[No eye deer]

Libba+Mills (Ashcroft M9) vs Walsh+Petracca (Johnson M9)

The rest of my midfield is Bont, Laird, Zerrett, Neale, Brayshaw, Steele

Walsh Trac. Points on field. MJ is fine as M9

 

[toxic]

Libba+Mills (Ashcroft M9) vs Walsh+Petracca (Johnson M9)

The rest of my midfield is Bont, Laird, Zerrett, Neale, Brayshaw, Steele

Walsh and Trac

Easily

 

[hoddo]

Thanks, I'm leaning that way too. Just have to make sure I don't close down vc looping options.

Yes I'm holding Humphrey. I know he could lose cash this week if he stays deep forward, but the Suns are moving Humphrey, Powell and Fiorini around each week without any apparent pattern. It seems random as to which of them gets to play in the high scoring position each week. I wouldn't be surprised to see Humphrey back in the mids this week while Fiorini is sent back to the wing or HFF. If there was an obvious cheap rookie to cash him in for I might be tempted, but I'd rather risk a bit of cash to see if his high scoring days really are finished.

No longer holding Humphrey. If I hold him and he fails he'll no longer be worth enough to allow me to trade in Mills. Can't risk that happening so he gets downgraded this week with a rookie becoming Mills next week after he drops in price.

Onfield rookie situation a lot clearer after the looped Sheldrick did so well. It's now a choice of Mitchell, Fyfe or Johnson for the other spot and I prefer Mitchell. Johnson's finished each of the last two games with an injury niggle and although I wouldn't be surprised to see Fyfe ton up, I can't trust him yet.

 

[goondog]

Walsh Trac. Points on field. MJ is fine as M9

Walsh and Trac

Easily

The people have spoken. Although Libba started like a house of fire...

 

[Axly]

Fogarty vs Cunningham

 

[Fisheroo]

Sheezel vs Ziebs to sit at D6, possibly for the rest of the year as trades are getting low.
The other will likely become Houston this week.

 

[evo]

Cover guy for the rest of the season Mills or Tarryn Thomas

26

Tarryn Thomas

Age

24

Ht

190cm

Wt

83kg

Pos.

Mid

Career

Season

Last 5

D

11.0

3star

K

5.3

2star

HB

5.7

4star

M

2.1

2star

T

3.3

5star

CL

0.9

3star

D

7.8

2star

K

4.0

1star

HB

3.8

3star

M

1.3

1star

T

3.2

4star

CL

0.2

2star

D

12.8

4star

K

6.2

3star

HB

6.6

4star

M

2.8

3star

T

3.8

5star

CL

0.4

3star

?

 

[A Bit Dusty]

Cover guy for the rest of the season Mills or Tarryn Thomas?

Mills but only because TT could be in jail in a few weeks

 

[Scythe94]

Cover guy for the rest of the season Mills or Tarryn Thomas?

Mills by a mile (provided you have the option of having him cover multiple lines via other DPPs)

 

[SC fish]

Mills but only because TT could be in jail in a few weeks

Is that a real possibility?