List Mgmt. 2023 Trade & List Management Thread III

[TruRoos7]

I have it on good authority Ziebell was serving regular coffee out of the coffee cart and was telling everyone it was decaf, this really rustled some feathers internally until it came out that it was actually Nathan Hrovat wearing a Ziebell disguise.

Either way, neither Ziebs OR Hrovat are invited to book club this weekend, make of that what you will.

Mission Impossible style I like it.

So was Ben wearing Harry’s face or the other way around

 

[B4Bear]

Mission Impossible style I like it.

So was Ben wearing Harry’s face or the other way around

I was thinking Hannibal Lecter actually.

 

[HBFlanker]

Who Clarko, yeah that bridge has been burned

Say that again?

 

[Northball]

Mission Impossible style I like it.

So was Ben wearing Harry’s face or the other way around

The chatter I’m hearing is Ben grew his beard out and has been filling in for Harry the second half of this year - that’s why ‘Harry’ has been missing from the goal square

 

[shinboner magic]

Jack's brother is playing for Carlton?

ETA

View attachment 1831754

Yeah brother Jack Martin

 

[Arathrawn]

WC 2, 15, 18, 42 had 1, 23, 37
M 3, 17, had 6, 11, 42
NM 1, 6, 11, 23, 37 had 2,3,15,17,18

I haven't even convinced myself.

Just a thought bubble really.

 

[HBFlanker]

North get: 1, 23
North give: 2, 15

WCE get: 2, 11
WCE give, 1, 22, 2024 2nd round pick

Melb get: 15, 2024 2nd round pick
Melb give: 11

That's as simple as it could be.

West coasts 2nd round pick next year will be inside 23.

North enter with 1,3,17,18,23

 

[GS WARRIORS]

Hearing Clarko has spoken to Gunston.

He won't get to Hawthorn.

Better not get to North either.

 

[disco_cowboy]

Better not get to North either.

 

[HBFlanker]

Better not get to North either.

You for real?? Would cost us fk all and if Comben goes back gives us another marking option. Hes better than CCJ by a mile.

 

[Roosurgence]

Better not get to North either.

He would probably be good for our young forwards from a football perspective, but the stunt he is pulling on Brisbane makes me think he has a bit of the flogs about him, so it’s a NO for me.

Imagine leaving the sinking ship to chase glory and then wanting to piss off because they left him out.

I’m not sure why the Hawks would want him anyway?

 

[HBFlanker]

He would probably be good for our young forwards from a football perspective, but the stunt he is pulling on Brisbane makes me think he has a bit of the flogs about him, so it’s a NO for me.

Imagine leaving the sinking ship to chase glory and then wanting to piss off because they left him out.

I’m not sure why the Hawks would want him anyway?

Brisbane play 2 talls, he's not in front of either of them, there's no stunt.

It's the best forward line in the comp by the length of the straight.

Family stuff as well obviously.

He would play 18+ games for us then finish up end of the year.

 

[DunderHead]

We could use some extra leadership and development on the field. If he wants to get into coaching would be good to give him some extra responsibilities around development - we did just lose Russell.

 

[Roosurgence]

Brisbane play 2 talls, he's not in front of either of them, there's no stunt.

It's the best forward line in the comp by the length of the straight.

Family stuff as well obviously.

He would play 18+ games for us then finish up end of the year.

The same forward line he left to join.

The family stuff was also there when he made the original call to leave.

Bloke comes across as a bit of a sook who didn’t like how it turned out, so now wants to take his bat and ball and go home. Also didn’t want to stick around and guide the Hawks through the rebuild after what they had given him as a club.

Not ticking a lot of boxes when it comes to his character. The fact that Brisbane were shocked by the request, says a fair bit.

 

[pupstar]

Brisbane play 2 talls, he's not in front of either of them, there's no stunt.

It's the best forward line in the comp by the length of the straight.

Family stuff as well obviously.

He would play 18+ games for us then finish up end of the year.

Then why would he leave the Hawks in the 1st place if their forward line is the best by a long way not for success he has had plenty of that.

 

[gustaaf]

You for real?? Would cost us fk all and if Comben goes back gives us another marking option. Hes better than CCJ by a mile.

He doesn't do any defensive work or apply any pressure when the ball is turned over in the F50. I'm happy for him to return to Hawthorn, although I'm not even sure they'd have him back.

 

[HBFlanker]

The same forward line he left to join.

The family stuff was also there when he made the original call to leave.

Bloke comes across as a bit of a sook who didn’t like how it turned out, so now wants to take his bat and ball and go home. Also didn’t want to stick around and guide the Hawks through the rebuild after what they had given him as a club.

Not ticking a lot of boxes when it comes to his character. The fact that Brisbane were shocked by the request, says a fair bit.

The hawks booted him out. The same as Mitchell and O'meara. Then they regretted it.

All I'm saying is he plays round 1 or us. I'd be happy to part with our last pick for him

 

[HBFlanker]

Then why would he leave the Hawks in the 1st place if their forward line is the best by a long way not for success he has had plenty of that.

He was booted. Plain and simple.

There's a stench around Sam Mitchell at the moment. There's a fair bit in the Tom Mitchell podcast stuff.

O'mearas version of last year's trade period would be fascinating.

 

[Marstermind]

WC 2, 15, 18, 42 had 1, 23, 37
M 3, 17, had 6, 11, 42
NM 1, 6, 11, 23, 37 had 2,3,15,17,18

I haven't even convinced myself.

Just a thought bubble really.

Time to pop that bubble. Any scenario where we don't have two of the first three picks anymore is a shocker. If a scenario has that AND giving up 5 of the first 18, for three is utter shyte.

 

[My Left Foote]

He’s not referring to McKay. He can only be referring to Jack Ziebell. Easily the most hated man at North in decades. Not by supporters, mind you. They mostly revere Jack for his hardness and courage. But for team mates and coaches, he is absolutely despised.

Elite User Name / Post contradiction going on here.

 

[Psicosis]

The same forward line he left to join.

The family stuff was also there when he made the original call to leave.

Bloke comes across as a bit of a sook who didn’t like how it turned out, so now wants to take his bat and ball and go home. Also didn’t want to stick around and guide the Hawks through the rebuild after what they had given him as a club.

Not ticking a lot of boxes when it comes to his character. The fact that Brisbane were shocked by the request, says a fair bit.

Clarkson probably knows, so I’ll back his yes or no

 

[Roosurgence]

The hawks booted him out. The same as Mitchell and O'meara. Then they regretted it.

All I'm saying is he plays round 1 or us. I'd be happy to part with our last pick for him

No they didn’t, he pissed off because he didn’t have the nutsack to want to help through a rebuild and went chasing glory.

The only reason he wants to come back is because it didn’t work out his he thought it would and is sooking it up.

Mitchell was on record early last year that Gunston was the player they wanted to keep out of the players that left or were moved on.

Sounds like he isn’t high on the Hawks priorities anyway, which speaks volumes.

 

[ohmygewd]

I don't want Gunston as it stuffs up our average age - cannot stand another year of potato head using "we're the youngest team out there" excuse!!

We go from ave 24yo to 22.8yo

 

[pupstar]

He was booted. Plain and simple.

There's a stench around Sam Mitchell at the moment. There's a fair bit in the Tom Mitchell podcast stuff.

O'mearas version of last year's trade period would be fascinating.

If he was booted out fine but why choose Brisbane then.

 

[Arathrawn]

Time to pop that bubble. Any scenario where we don't have two of the first three picks anymore is a shocker. If a scenario has that AND giving up 5 of the first 18, for three is utter shyte.

It seems I've managed to annoy both North and WC fans. WC fans say not enough, our fans say too much.

I think we could walk away with Reid and Sanders in that deal plus best KPD at 11. Anything after that is a lucky dip.

Just a thought bubble but I find it amusing how angry people can get at a simple musing of a random on BF.