Ultimate Glory 2023 Trade speculation and Shinbeggars discussion

[Mitchell Madness]

In isolation the Brisbane trade looks bad. But looking at it I'm conduction with the gc one, it's not bad. Player of similar age (chol to Ryan, not gunston!) Chol far more fit than Ryan and a better ruck.

I did like that Ryan would make a lead though, it really cleared the forward line ou

 

[TylerDurden]

 

[Billyc]

That Brisbane F2 has gone to GC for Chol and pick 62. Good trade that one.

 

[eldorado]

The pick 62 coming back makes sense, as it's all about the points this year, rather than specific picks

 

[Kuuz]

That Brisbane F2 has gone to GC for Chol and pick 62. Good trade that one.

Loaded up nicely on picks for points matching. Well setup for the draft.

 

[Mr Meeseeks]

We've got plenty of points, don't forget the picks will all come in after the Suns match their academy players.

The Suns have 6 picks before our picks in the 40s so will come in 3 each.

The Dogs have 5 picks in the 50s that will all be gone also after they match Croft.

So the two picks in the 40s will come in 3 each & the two picks in the 60s will come in 7 each.

So ultimately the picks we end up with will be 41,44,54,55 & 56 which will give us 1393 points.

Which gives us enough points to match a bid of upto pick 7.

Some much needed balance in this melt down thread. Happy to share a bag with you any day.

Sent from my SM-G990E using Tapatalk

 

[TylerDurden]

Sleepy walks in to Essendon's room.

 

[Kuuz]

View attachment 1834585

Sleepy walks in to Essendon's room.

He's gotta wait - Dodoro still stuck with Port over Duursma-BZT

He can nap and just have a sign on him saying "Pick 101 or don't wake me"

 

[KermitJagger]

This is the worst trade of our trade period I feel. We gave up a decent asset for a player who didn't want to be at a club, with a coach that didn't want him there.

It's not unconscionable but it's annoying.

 

[hawkman]

The pick 62 coming back makes sense, as it's all about the points this year, rather than specific picks

Depends on how many list spots we are going to have

 

[Jaeger007]

Feel we’ve over paid

Carlton bent GC over

In turn GC bent Sleepy Mark over this one. A player coach doesn’t rate & club needs salary off the books

 

[Flukey!]

Just for clarity, the future second for Chol is not ours right, it's Brisbane's?

 

[Mrzohs]

Chol deal is 4 years with a 5th trigger (17 games) G.C get the Lions F2.

We currently have Pies F2.

 

[KermitJagger]

Just for clarity, the future second for Chol is not ours right, it's Brisbane's?

We don't have ours, we have Brisbane and Collingwoods.

 

[Mitchell Madness]

This is the worst trade of our trade period I feel. We gave up a decent asset for a player who didn't want to be at a club, with a coach that didn't want him there.

It's not unconscionable but it's annoying.

No friends I'm the media to put pressure on gc

 

[VandoHawk]

This is the worst trade of our trade period I feel. We gave up a decent asset for a player who didn't want to be at a club, with a coach that didn't want him there.

It's not unconscionable but it's annoying.

Even if it was slight overs in isolation we picked up a player who will at a minimum be important for us structurally and added 100 more points to match bids this year.

If we can get Chol motivated I also think he's good for 30+ goals a year.

 

[Kuuz]

Just for clarity, the future second for Chol is not ours right, it's Brisbane's?

Correct - so very other end of the round.

I think our F2 went to Pies, in exchange for theirs - during Ginni trade?

 

[Hawkspot]

Feel we’ve over paid

Carlton bent GC over

In turn GC bent Sleepy Mark over this one. A player coach doesn’t rate & club needs salary off the books

It’s about a 20 pick downgrade for Chol. Not gonna lose sleep over it.

 

[BobHawk]

Is there actually a pic of a Hawthorn player out there that Ginnivan isn't in?

 

[eldorado]

We don't have ours, we have Brisbane and Collingwoods.

What happened to our original one again?

 

[Dewyyyyy]

So trade period basically over.

Will worry about picks later on but

In: Ginnivan, Chol, Gunston & Massimo
Out: Kosi, Ryan.

Have our first round pick this year, next year & have a future 2nd (Col), and a second this year.

Team could look like this, although early.


Hardwick - Blanck - Scrimshaw

Seamus - Weddle - Sicily

Anon - Day - Ward

Moore - Chol - Gunston

Breust - Lewis - Ginnivan

Reeves - Newcombe - Worpel

MacDonald - Nash - MacKenzie - Impey

I’d say we would draft one of Watson, Duursma, McKercher or maybe Curtin and all chances to play early. Would all provide skill and pace (Curtin straight line).

Forgot Brockman as an out and edited it!

 

[theiaofseed]

Feel we’ve over paid

Carlton bent GC over

In turn GC bent Sleepy Mark over this one. A player coach doesn’t rate & club needs salary off the books

This is just speculation though, Suns were clearly prepared to keep him on the books.

 

[VandoHawk]

What happened to our original one again?

Swapped it with Collingwood for Ginnivan.

 

[The Golden Glenferrie]

We drank the Kool aid.

What a disaster.

 

[Suntory Boss Coffee]

This is the worst trade of our trade period I feel. We gave up a decent asset for a player who didn't want to be at a club, with a coach that didn't want him there.

It's not unconscionable but it's annoying.

We wanted to give up a future third. We have up a future second linked to a premiership favourite. Much of muchness, AND we got pick 62 for points this year.