2023 Trade Time Talk - Henley Beach Café Returns

Most Likely Option of this Trade Period

  • Nothing Happens but a few lame Pick swaps and we are let down

    Votes: 43 35.2%
  • Matt Crouch leaves and we get a 3rd round compo

    Votes: 20 16.4%
  • We recruit a second(3rd) rate defender for needs

    Votes: 25 20.5%
  • We somehow manage to move up in the draft

    Votes: 28 23.0%
  • A big name comes out of nowhere to us and we rejoice

    Votes: 11 9.0%
  • Organic Growth

    Votes: 40 32.8%

  • Total voters
    122
  • Poll closed .

Remove this Banner Ad

Which ones?

UAlTnyaP.jpg

acf6e2b95bb0929867483364ec4b28c3.jpeg
Ooooof - there's some UGLY looks there.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

The suspicious thing about the poll from memory is that I needed to vote an exorbitantly huge number of times to change the outcome, and then wasn't the poll taken down once my bot had done its job?

I think I drew the conclusion the poll was already pre-populated with votes

EDIT: Here's the thread where I did it News - 2017 Adelaide Crows ISC apparel
 
Last edited:
Why specifically....underwhelming and tried in multiple positions at both AFL and VFL but hasn't owned any of them so far.

Not suggesting we pay anything remotely close to what he cost, but the talent was there two years ago, so not sure what has happened.

We only need to look at Keays, Hinge & Murray as three players who didn't look to offer much at their first club and were discarded for nothing and have turned out to be quite handy pickups.

If Hinge can put together a full year that reflects his last couple of months of footy, he should be AA worthy. Murray was also on track to be in the same conversation.

Hollands is worth a punt, but not paying what GC would be after, however if pick 4 is on the table, and it includes us taking on Hollands and his wage, we should be all over it.
 
Out of interest, When was the last time Hollands spent any time in a midfield?

At the Suns I only saw him play HFF. But he was touted as a potential #1 mid who can play forward right?

I wonder if a part of his careers lackluster start is him playing the graveyard flankers role almost exclusively. I mean hes almost 190cm and 87kg, the kids not built like a buzzing HFF.
 
Sure .. as long as they can post that they saw Fantasia having coffee with Adelaide officials in HB the same afternoon Fantasia was interviewed outside a coffee shop in Melbourne :thumbsu:
actually thats one i can answer, we bid on Fantasia but never actually wanted him. Just bumped up Powers price paid.

From horses mouth - a real (well sort of) horse. Not of the red variety
 
Has been at an underwhelming club, where facilities and culture haven't been strong. In a better environment, he may realise his promise.

And if not, no one is suggesting giving up much.
cost? pick 24 or lower? I suppose if salary dump its even lower...

You had mentioned Dylan Stephens perhaps - sounds like Kangas are after him as not re-resigning with Swans
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

and in total objectivity, Faith did say Luko was only ranked 8-10th (IIRC) in his draft year. Pretty spot on and he did get SMASHED with this opinion

Walsh
Rankine
M King
Rozee
Smith
Blakey
Butters
B King

I would take before Luko
 
are we sure Faith and Redhorse are still here? Any hints on usernames?
One is, not sure about the other... though think he was just the alias of another.

Know your alphabet...
 
and in total objectivity, Faith did say Luko was only ranked 8-10th (IIRC) in his draft year. Pretty spot on and he did get SMASHED with this opinion

Walsh
Rankine
M King
Rozee
Smith
Blakey
Butters
B King

I would take before Luko
In Luko's defence, he literally only just started playing the position he was drafted to play this year. And was a 39 goal forward in his first season up front.

So it might still be a bit premature to set that list in stone
 
and in total objectivity, Faith did say Luko was only ranked 8-10th (IIRC) in his draft year. Pretty spot on and he did get SMASHED with this opinion

Walsh
Rankine
M King
Rozee
Smith
Blakey
Butters
B King

I would take before Luko
The bet welcher..he owes me a bottle of Penfolds RWT. Thilthorpe going at pick 9 - lol
 
and in total objectivity, Faith did say Luko was only ranked 8-10th (IIRC) in his draft year. Pretty spot on and he did get SMASHED with this opinion

Walsh
Rankine
M King
Rozee
Smith
Blakey
Butters
B King

I would take before Luko
Interesting

I would have Luko ahead of Smith and B King
 

Remove this Banner Ad

2023 Trade Time Talk - Henley Beach Café Returns

Back
Top