-
AFLW 2024 - Round 4 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
2023 young talent time
- Thread starter Dockeroo
- Start date
- Tagged users None
It's a fairly good start though!
- Apr 26, 2011
- 10,898
- 13,321
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
- Other Teams
- Wimbledon AFC
Wasn't refering to Barry cable
Watched the WA vs Allies game today. Other than the obvious ones, I thought Hall, Torrent and Hardeman (apart from his kicking) were pretty good. Sanchez too, to a lesser extent.
Hardeman's kicking is normally pretty good. The WA players I think would be a good fit for our side would be Hardeman (wing), Sanchez (wing/forward), O'Driscoll (wing / forward) and I would also look at Sam Van Rooyen (forward but potentially utility tall).
I have a sneaking suspicion that Tholstrup will be available at our first but that we won't take him, even though I think he has of all the WA players the most going for him for an AFL level. Collard is also a mercurial forward type (plays as a goalsneak but is a decent size) that some supporters have been calling out for but again I can see the selectors being worried about the level of tackles and pressure and the like.
Snuffaluphagus
Brownlow Medallist
- Sep 10, 2015
- 24,603
- 84,948
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
Tholstrup's biggest concern is the speed no? Seems a tad slow for any role other than inside mid. Collard was the kid playing for Peel wasnt he? I thought one of this better attributes off the games I saw was he aggression and contest work or am I misremembering?
Nah Subi. Really quick and goal sneak. Noticed a very good chase in the Allies game but not much else. Wasn't a great forward line to be in, to be fair.
Snuffaluphagus
Brownlow Medallist
- Sep 10, 2015
- 24,603
- 84,948
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
Ahh, that's right, it was Clay Hall I'm thinking of I think...
Do you seriously think Subi would be hiding Tholsrtup so that Vic teams can’t draft him ahead of Wc and Freo lol.
If anything Subiaco have been promoting him.
I think there may be a few concerned with his dedication to preseason (again noting the difficulty of getting back and forth from Esperance to get to training); which some may then link to his current form.
I think he has shown he can have good burst speed when stationed as a deep forward but playing the roles he is at the moment (high half forward, mid) he doesn't have the endurance to use it, hence why the reference to the preseason.
Exactly re Subi promoting him they wouldn’t be helping Freo or WC in anyway.
What about Coen Livingstone?
Kicked 6 goals in the colts, 200cm and can ruck.
There seems to be at least 3 talls in WA that appear to be on the road.
WC will take one, but which one?
They'll get Livingstone as NGA the way it's going.
We should pick Collard if we get the chance.
Tholstrup's attributes on rookieme are the following ... Explosiveness, athleticism, kicking penetration, scoreboard impact, x-factor, overhead marking. They don't list any negatives and can sort of make every player sound like the second coming, but if he is available and we pass, I will blow a gasket. It's the type of player I want most in our side as a powerful medium forward/mid. Somewhere on the scale of Lipinksi to De Goey.
If he slides because of his endurance, then great. Might take a few years, but easy to fix. Those attributes listed above, if you don't have them as a junior, then you never will.
Really hoping North don't win another game and then WC manage to fluke one more win (on top of the North game) to go above them on the ladder. Means we move ahead of WC if Tholstrup is going to be up for grabs.
lol what
You do realise that these good players you draft still take time to come on (50-70 games) and become consistent and in the mean time there top end will be retired
Hate to be part of the pile-on, but they are miles off. They'd have to bring in 5+ quality FAs over those two years for that to be realistic.
They have like 5 players under 28 that are AFL standard. The young ones that might be one day will take at least 2 seasons to get there on average and probably more.
Even if they draft amazingly and have the vast majority of the list needed to contend in 1-2 years those players will need 5-6 years to reach their peak.
Outside of Allen, Barrass and maybe Ryan no one of their list is A Grade and still young enough that you'd say they'll likely still be so in 2-3 years. Outside of Ginbey I'm not sure I've seen top much from their younger players either - there's a few other role players there but not superstars imo.
Yeah he’s EXACTLY the type of player we need with added bonus of being local.
Clearly has some exciting traits so will be stoked if he slides(and conversely pissed if we pass)
- Thread starter
- #174
He wants to play for the eagles
All the more reason we should draft him
