Team Mgmt. 2024 Best 22 (or 23)

Remove this Banner Ad

Bunk Moreland said:
B: McGrath - Laverde - Hind
HB: Ridley - McKay - Redman
C: Shiel - Setterfield - Durham
HF: Stringer - Jones - Martin
F: Gresham - Wright - Langford
R: Draper - Merrett - Parish
I: Caldwell - Hobbs - Perkins - Tsatas
Click to expand...

My update

B: McGrath - McKay - Ridley
HB: Martin - Reid - Redman
C: Durham - Merrett - Duursma
HF: Stringer - Jones - Perkins
F: Gresham - Wright - Langford
R: Draper - Setterfield - Parish
I: Caldwell - Cox - Tsatas - Hobbs - Caddy

October vs February

In: Reid, Duursma, Cox, Caddy
Out: Shiel, Hind, Laverde

(I named 22 before and have added the 23rd)

A bit of "we're really shit, just play the kids" adjustment from me over four months
 
Bunk Moreland said:
My update

B: McGrath - McKay - Ridley
HB: Martin - Reid - Redman
C: Durham - Merrett - Duursma
HF: Stringer - Jones - Perkins
F: Gresham - Wright - Langford
R: Draper - Setterfield - Parish
I: Caldwell - Cox - Tsatas - Hobbs - Caddy

October vs February

In: Reid, Duursma, Cox, Caddy
Out: Shiel, Hind, Laverde

(I named 22 before and have added the 23rd)

A bit of "we're really s**t, just play the kids" adjustment from me over four months
Click to expand...
Jones should be nowhere near our best 22 on current form
 

Log in to remove this ad.

My best 22 assuming 100% health

FB Ridley Mckay Mcgrath
HB Redman Reid Caldwell
C Durham Merrett Martin
HF Perkins Wright Sheil
FF Langford Caddy Gresham
OB Draper Parish Setterfield

IC Hobbs, Tsatas, Dursma, Goldy
Sub: Stringer
 
Hello friends.

After your thoughts and updates on Sam Draper please.

Has been your #1 for a few years now, is that likely to continue in 2024 (when fit...is he fit?) with Goldy coming in as a Phillips replacement and someone who provides a chop out?

And if Draper doesn't play, is Bryan in line for games?

Thanks. And sorry to the mods if this is in the wrong place!
 
Jeremias said:
Hello friends.

After your thoughts and updates on Sam Draper please.

Has been your #1 for a few years now, is that likely to continue in 2024 (when fit...is he fit?) with Goldy coming in as a Phillips replacement and someone who provides a chop out?

And if Draper doesn't play, is Bryan in line for games?

Thanks. And sorry to the mods if this is in the wrong place!
Click to expand...
Draper is gonna be the number 1 when fit. Me (and a few others) are hoping Bryan will be #2 but it looks likely that it'll be Goldy
 
Fayab99 said:
We all know kelly and heppell is starting best 22. LOL :(
Click to expand...
i'd take kelly over heppell every day of the week.

kelly mightn't be flash but he absolutely busts hit gut every second he's on the ground
 
mcgrath_truther said:
i'd take kelly over heppell every day of the week.

kelly mightn't be flash but he absolutely busts hit gut every second he's on the ground
Click to expand...
And he is twice as fast.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

If 100% I would want this team at the end of the year.

McGrath McKay Cox
Ridley Reid Redman
Durham Merrett Martin
Langford Caddy Gresham
Menzie Wright Davey Jr

Draper Parish Hobbs

Perkins Caldwell Setterfield Duursma (Stringer)

Edit: Tsatas hopefully banging down the door in the VFL.
 
Last edited:
So first thoughts after the scratch match for round 1

McGrath McKay Cox
Martin Reid Redman
Durham Merrett Martin
Langford Jones Gresham
Menzie Wright Hind

Goldstein Parish Setterfield

Perkins Caldwell Stringer Duursma (Tsatas)

*Potential to go with Draper over Stringer who becomes sub and Tsatas out.
 
Last edited:
Vindicater said:
So first thoughts after the scratch match for round 1

McGrath McKay Cox
Martin Reid Redman
Durham Merrett Martin
Langford Caddy Gresham
Menzie Wright Hind

Goldstein Parish Setterfield

Perkins Caldwell Stringer Duursma (Tsatas)

*Potential to go with Draper over Stringer who becomes sub and Tsatas out.
Click to expand...

Can’t see them bringing Caddy straight in, think that spot goes to Jones
 
B: RIDLEY MCKAY MCGRATH
HB: REDMAN REID MARTIN
C: DUURSMA PARISH DURHAM
HF: STRINGER JONES GRESHAM
F: LANGFORD WRIGHT MENZIE
R: DRAPER SETTERFIELD MERRETT
INT: CALDWELL HOBBS CADDY PERKINS

EMG: GOLDSTEIN TSATAS HIND
 
Not for rd1, but a thought re: the 2018 draftees onwards...if all our sharper pick players make it, what does the side look like?

Ridley - mckay - mcgrath
Redman - reid - martin
Duursma - tsatas - durham
Perkins - jones - gresham
Caddy - wright - langford
Draper - merrett - parish
Setterfield - hobbs - cox - bryan
 caldwell

Fwd line is too tall but does highlight the need for quality in the small fwds im coming years....either from menzie, tex or daveys...or recruiting one
 
Pretty harsh but time to be a realist with what we have and our future prospects;

Back pocket; Jordan Ridley - star when on the park.
Full back; Ben McKay - serviceable, high quality role player
Back pocket; Andrew McGrath - serviceable who could be one of the better ones in a good system

Half back flank; Mason Redman - High quality role player in a good system. Think Brayden Maynard good
Centre half back; NEED A GOOD ONE
Half back flank; Nic Martin - I want to like this but like him more on a wing. Could use

Wing; Sam Durham - Good, high quality role player who is being used inside as much as the wing
Centre; Zac Merrett - Gun, star, captain
Wing; Xavier Duursma; Good honest role player, last week showed he can contribute.

Half forward flank; Archie Perkins - Unsure, is being used further up the ground which I am liking.
Centre half forward; NEED A GOOD ONE
Half forward flank; NEED A GOOD ONE

Forward pocket; Kyle Langford - Good, high quality role player who is borderline gun.
Full Forward; Peter Wright; Good high quality role player
Forward Pocket; Jake Stringer - Good, high quality role player, borderline gun

Ruck; Sam Draper / Todd Goldstein - Draper is not as good as he once promised, Goldstein is 35. Need tp upgrade
Rover; Jye Caldwell - Good honest role player.
Ruck Rover; Darcy Parish - Good player, borderline elite but not quite.

My two main queries moving forward are the forward group.

The forward group on paper looks a mishmash of match winners and goal kickers with high ceilings. How does it not consistently work?!?!?! A marking small forward is needed, a pressure small forward is also needed. As good as Jake and Kyle are, a small forward with elite speed is desperately needed.

The midfield is a mess. A lot of similarly athletic small midfielders, even the next wave of guys are small. When does it change?! Moving away from the size, we have no real match winner who can go through here apart from contract year Jake Stringer. Hell I would take a (1.76cm) Shai Bolton who can turn a game on it's head in a quarter. We have multiple good honest "match winners" who can perform across a game but none (bar Jake) who can turn a game on a dime in a quarter.

The 8 year plan that Scott was talking about will see over half this 22 not here if/when compete in 2032
 
Yoda_ said:
Pretty harsh but time to be a realist with what we have and our future prospects;

Back pocket; Jordan Ridley - star when on the park.
Full back; Ben McKay - serviceable, high quality role player
Back pocket; Andrew McGrath - serviceable who could be one of the better ones in a good system

Half back flank; Mason Redman - High quality role player in a good system. Think Brayden Maynard good
Centre half back; NEED A GOOD ONE
Half back flank; Nic Martin - I want to like this but like him more on a wing. Could use

Wing; Sam Durham - Good, high quality role player who is being used inside as much as the wing
Centre; Zac Merrett - Gun, star, captain
Wing; Xavier Duursma; Good honest role player, last week showed he can contribute.

Half forward flank; Archie Perkins - Unsure, is being used further up the ground which I am liking.
Centre half forward; NEED A GOOD ONE
Half forward flank; NEED A GOOD ONE

Forward pocket; Kyle Langford - Good, high quality role player who is borderline gun.
Full Forward; Peter Wright; Good high quality role player
Forward Pocket; Jake Stringer - Good, high quality role player, borderline gun

Ruck; Sam Draper / Todd Goldstein - Draper is not as good as he once promised, Goldstein is 35. Need tp upgrade
Rover; Jye Caldwell - Good honest role player.
Ruck Rover; Darcy Parish - Good player, borderline elite but not quite.

My two main queries moving forward are the forward group.

The forward group on paper looks a mishmash of match winners and goal kickers with high ceilings. How does it not consistently work?!?!?! A marking small forward is needed, a pressure small forward is also needed. As good as Jake and Kyle are, a small forward with elite speed is desperately needed.

The midfield is a mess. A lot of similarly athletic small midfielders, even the next wave of guys are small. When does it change?! Moving away from the size, we have no real match winner who can go through here apart from contract year Jake Stringer. Hell I would take a (1.76cm) Shai Bolton who can turn a game on it's head in a quarter. We have multiple good honest "match winners" who can perform across a game but none (bar Jake) who can turn a game on a dime in a quarter.

The 8 year plan that Scott was talking about will see over half this 22 not here if/when compete in 2032
Click to expand...
Stringer is not a borderline gun imo he’s a bit part player who fills his boots against average sides.
 
Funny how when the criticism of Geulfi and Snelling and even Menzie is they do not kick enough goals. So we get Gresham who has kicked 7 goals in 4 games and yet he is no good either. Sure he is not a fast pressure player and we 100% do need one or two but I do not mind Gresham in the mix if he is going at just under 2 goals a game.
 
ant555 said:
Funny how when the criticism of Geulfi and Snelling and even Menzie is they do not kick enough goals. So we get Gresham who has kicked 7 goals in 4 games and yet he is no good either. Sure he is not a fast pressure player and we 100% do need one or two but I do not mind Gresham in the mix if he is going at just under 2 goals a game.
Click to expand...

Unfortunately When Essendon looses everyone is a spud who should be traded for a bag of chips because a 3rd round pick would be better for the future.

That’s how it goes on here I guess
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Team Mgmt. 2024 Best 22 (or 23)

Similar threads

Skipper_
Prediction 2025 Best 23
2 3 4 5
Replies
113
Views
7K
monty1104
monty1104
eth-dog
Competitions 2024 Mock Draft
7 8 9 10 11
Replies
262
Views
8K
I Remember Bluey
I Remember Bluey
Harlequin
AFL Autopsy RND 22: Loss
10 11 12 13 14
Replies
330
Views
19K
Nicholas61
Nicholas61
eth-dog
  • Poll
Brownlow Brownlow Thread 2024
2 3
Replies
70
Views
2K
BrunoV
BrunoV
eDPS
MVP Round 22 - Bombers vs Swans
Replies
14
Views
407
Vindicater
Vindicater
Lore
Fixture AFLW 2024 Fixture
Replies
5
Views
1K
Happyskeret
Happyskeret
ghostdog
Opinion 2024 The good, the bad and the ugly
2
Replies
39
Views
2K
BomberManU
B

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top