- Sep 4, 2018
- 960
- 1,420
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
- Other Teams
- AFL
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 9 - Indigenous Round - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
List Mgmt. 2024 List Management discussion
- Thread starter M Malice
- Start date
- Tagged users None
TDK would be an insanely good get for us and perfect for the role we like as forward / back-up ruck.
I would have to agree with old mate Blues WalshisGoat or whatever it was, who i thought put out the perfectly reasonable case that we won't have the draft capital and the could match a bid to force a trade. It doesn't happen much but it happens for big fish ie Dangerfield. I think he would be the number one player Carlton would not want to lose, putting Cripps aside (who signed on forever)
We'll see what TDK manages next year but he looms as one of the guns of the game i reckon. The caveat being that while Luke Jackson has loomed as that for 3-4 years it's a hard role to manage consistency in terms of output if you are not a true key forward first and foremost like Joe.
If he has a good season next year he could be on $1.5m which is too much for us.
I would have to agree with old mate Blues WalshisGoat or whatever it was, who i thought put out the perfectly reasonable case that we won't have the draft capital and the could match a bid to force a trade. It doesn't happen much but it happens for big fish ie Dangerfield. I think he would be the number one player Carlton would not want to lose, putting Cripps aside (who signed on forever)
We'll see what TDK manages next year but he looms as one of the guns of the game i reckon. The caveat being that while Luke Jackson has loomed as that for 3-4 years it's a hard role to manage consistency in terms of output if you are not a true key forward first and foremost like Joe.
If he has a good season next year he could be on $1.5m which is too much for us.
- Apr 24, 2020
- 2,779
- 4,391
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
Imagine Joe as a coach. Don't get me wrong, I think he has a great footy brain but I also think he just does things that come natural to him. He wouldn't understand why his key forward doesn't stay down from the ruck contest, get the tap, sprint towards goal and bomb it from 70 for an easy goal when he explained that was the game plan.
A bit like when Ronaldo told one of the players in the team he is now the president of that if he gets into a similar situation again (the guy missed a shot or something) it is just much easier to dribble around the goalie rather than take a shot. To which the player replied 'Yeah, nah mate, you're Ronaldo you can do those things, I can't do those things.' or something along those lines but in Brasilian Portuguese obviously not English.
In all seriousness though, Joe would probably be an excellent development coach because of his cool, calm and gold fish demeanor.
- Sep 9, 2014
- 946
- 1,175
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
Still good for a kid with lot's of development in front of him, who played well over and above what was expected, yet you find a way to bag him...stop expecting perfection from the players.
- Sep 9, 2014
- 946
- 1,175
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
Haters will always hate.
- May 3, 2015
- 15,541
- 18,241
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
Grow up. It was a response from someone who wasn't acknowledging what you said in this post
- Mar 12, 2003
- 5,489
- 9,989
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
- Other Teams
- Brisbane
Thought he did a pretty good job most of the time really. In a relatively low-risk-high-reward role to be fair.
Nunez
Premium Platinum
Someone needs to bump the 'Hipwood The Ruck' thread from many years ago.
I think Hipwood's coachable for rucking duties because he always tries his guts out and he's tall enough.
I just wonder whether we're better off developing his other attributes so he gets up the ground and as a marking target on the wings like Joe was where we'd get a lot more mileage out of him. I don't mind him going up in the ruck 2 or 3 times a game but not so convinced he's the right person to ruck a often as Joe did.
I can't believe there is any criticism of Morris OR any comparison to him and Bradshaw.
Morris is a first year player, promoted for his first gave in rather extraordinary circumstances and performed so well he effectively played out the season for us and winning a grand final. I know we like to discuss players and their faults but give the kid a break - if any kid in his first year should be off limits - leave Morris alone we could not have hoped for more.
Comparisons to Bradshaw - well yes he was a 3rd tall forward but that is all. Bradshaw had arms like legs, he protected the drop zone and marked with strength or he had hands of steel on the lead. But if the ball hit the ground or went over the back, Bradders was the Queen Mary and 30 meters down the ground still trying to turn around. Those a little older may remember he took up a trade as a Carpenter to have something after footy but couldn't bend over with his back. Morris is still a skinny kid, great in traffic, fast with his hands, runs 2 directions and I'd argue his upside is way higher that Bradders who I loved watching with Lynch and Brown taking the big boys out of the way.
Let's move on.
Morris is a first year player, promoted for his first gave in rather extraordinary circumstances and performed so well he effectively played out the season for us and winning a grand final. I know we like to discuss players and their faults but give the kid a break - if any kid in his first year should be off limits - leave Morris alone we could not have hoped for more.
Comparisons to Bradshaw - well yes he was a 3rd tall forward but that is all. Bradshaw had arms like legs, he protected the drop zone and marked with strength or he had hands of steel on the lead. But if the ball hit the ground or went over the back, Bradders was the Queen Mary and 30 meters down the ground still trying to turn around. Those a little older may remember he took up a trade as a Carpenter to have something after footy but couldn't bend over with his back. Morris is still a skinny kid, great in traffic, fast with his hands, runs 2 directions and I'd argue his upside is way higher that Bradders who I loved watching with Lynch and Brown taking the big boys out of the way.
Let's move on.
- Apr 24, 2020
- 2,779
- 4,391
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
Sometimes Joe barely competed in the ruck and played more as a 4th mid as well. Richmond won a couple of flags with a backup ruckman who basically tried to rove his opponents taps. You just need a body there to provide something, whether that is a contest or do a joe and 'suss out the vibe of the ruck contest' to paraphrase Elixuh
- Jun 27, 2017
- 1,734
- 3,985
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
Joe never tried to tap. Just always tried to push his man away, grab it and kick it forward for space or at goal. Never strayed away from that. Hipwood just doesn’t have the strength to replicate that easily unfortunately.
- Oct 13, 2015
- 9,896
- 25,330
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
I literally used a goat emoji to describe McMorris. I think he's awesome.
His set shot goalkicking could be improved to make him a better player though - this isn't me expecting perfection, its pointing out scope for improvement in his second season!
Are we not allowed to make that sort of observation lol?
Morris is someone who relies on his instinctive smart play as a forward which means once he puts his mind to it he'll be a good set shot.
I think he just lost concentration at times with his set shots ,understandably for a kid. Just presumed he'd nail them all.
I agree it's something he can work work on. The major thing for Morris is to really work on his fitness over the next couple of years and if he gets that right he could propel himself into an A Grader well ahead of schedule.
- Oct 13, 2015
- 9,896
- 25,330
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
Nunez
Premium Platinum
Quit observing!!
Morris had an outstanding first year but will need to improve many thing. Other clubs will do their homework on him over the preseason.
