List Mgmt. 2024 List Management thread - Trade Targets Part 2

[DragoDelph]

Still don’t buy it. But hard to walk back now without looking like idiots.

Pulled out of multiple club events.
Removed from club sponsor marketing.

 

[DragoDelph]

But this makes kossie more likely.

They’ll lose one, but won’t want to lose both.

 

[s_wd6]

View attachment 2097548

Well that's a lot more convincing. You'd think Kozzie is out of the picture for us then....

 

[s_wd6]

But this makes kossie more likely.

They’ll lose one, but won’t want to lose both.

Really? I took it as less likely. It shows where they're at from a list management perspective. They'll want to back themselves in to compete next year. Won't be letting b22 players walk out with 3 years contracted.

 

[freo1997]

Petracca playing the long game for now it seems.

That probably makes it easier to get Pickett out I reckon. They may be inclined to honour that trade for homesickness so they don’t look like total campaigners. Depends on Kosi I guess.

 

[DragoDelph]

That probably makes it easier to get Pickett out I reckon. They may be inclined to honour that trade for homesickness so they don’t look like total campaigners. Depends on Kosi I guess.

This was my thought too.

“Look, we’re the good guys. Petracca was just grumpy “

 

[danster168]

You’d need to offer the equivalent of 2 Pickett’s to enter a conversation for Brayshaw or Young, and it wouldn’t be enough. With Treacy, you wouldn’t enter the building with 2 Picketts. Literally a dominant key position forward at 21 or maybe 22 years old for a 171cm small forward. Laughable.

no way am I trading Pickett for Young straight swap. Brayshaw and Young are what say the 20-30th best mids in the game? Pickett is a top 3 small forward in the game. It's a scarce position that's hard to fill. Most teams either have 0 good small Forwards or 1.

 

[DragoDelph]

no way am I trading Pickett for Young straight swap. Brayshaw and Young are what say the 20-30th best mids in the game? Pickett is a top 3 small forward in the game. It's a scarce position that's hard to fill. Most teams either have 0 good small Forwards or 1.

How many mids were named in the 44 man AA squad?

 

[freo1997]

Really? I took it as less likely. It shows where they're at from a list management perspective. They'll want to back themselves in to compete next year. Won't be letting b22 players walk out with 3 years contracted.

Disagree. They won’t want to look like they are holding playing against their will, so may honour one contracted player…maybe. Up to Kosi and indecisiveness.

….reckon they’ve promised him Oliver will be kicked to the kerb. Watch for Oliver to go now.

 

[MadMundy]

no way am I trading Pickett for Young straight swap. Brayshaw and Young are what say the 20-30th best mids in the game? Pickett is a top 3 small forward in the game. It's a scarce position that's hard to fill. Most teams either have 0 good small Forwards or 1.

 

[Ge3ks]

Wonder what concessions the club offered Petracca. Are they finally gonna deal with Oliver?

 

[Snuffaluphagus]

Really? I took it as less likely. It shows where they're at from a list management perspective. They'll want to back themselves in to compete next year. Won't be letting b22 players walk out with 3 years contracted.

I don't know if it makes more likely but i don't think it hurts. Now they can say "we aren't arseholes but we won't be dominated by players / agents"

 

[freo1997]

Wonder what concessions the club offered Petracca. Are they finally gonna deal with Oliver?

he is gone and I reckon will go very cheaply.

 

[freo1997]

This is bloody good news now for us tbh. Doesn’t look like an exodus at the Dees with Petracca committing.

They’ll say Oliver is a required player until 2nd or last day then try do their best to get something for him. Probably a 2nd rounder. Any other shit heads at the Dees he doesn’t like might get the flick too.

 

[s_wd6]

Will say I much prefer Trac playing for Dees than for Carlton or Collingwood

 

[Tundrawolf]

Really? I took it as less likely. It shows where they're at from a list management perspective. They'll want to back themselves in to compete next year. Won't be letting b22 players walk out with 3 years contracted.

Pickett wants out for family reasons...Petracca wants to build his brand.....that's the difference.

 

[freo1997]

Pickett wants out for family reasons...Petracca wants to build his brand.....that's the difference.

Depends what side of the bed Pickett wakes up on. At the end of the day if he desperately wants back the request would be in by now. It’s up to Pickett, if he nominates us I reckon it will go through but we’re giving up a bit.

 

[s_wd6]

Pickett wants out for family reasons...Petracca wants to build his brand.....that's the difference.

Build his brand....or not play for a club that almost killed him, among other things

 

[JammoMonty]

This whole saga made absolutely no sense from the beginning. The clubs been floated didn’t have the picks of the money. Trac clearly unsettled at the club following his surgery. He lit a flare in the Pacific Ocean and waited for a passing ship. Lucky that Freo container ship didn’t pass him or he’d be back under the knife. This was a play from Trac to shake up the club and get a new set of kitchen knives. Well played on his behalf.

 

[Snuffaluphagus]

no way am I trading Pickett for Young straight swap. Brayshaw and Young are what say the 20-30th best mids in the game? Pickett is a top 3 small forward in the game. It's a scarce position that's hard to fill. Most teams either have 0 good small Forwards or 1.

You are truly such a goober

 

[freo1997]

This whole saga made absolutely no sense from the beginning. The clubs been floated didn’t have the picks of the money. Trac clearly unsettled at the club following his surgery. He lit a flare in the Pacific Ocean and waited for a passing ship. Lucky that Freo container ship didn’t pass him or he’d be back under the knife. This was a play from Trac to shake up the club and get a new set of kitchen knives. Well played on his behalf.

Any chance Oliver goes and they look to Brodie or Erasmus packaged with a pick for Pickett? One of them takes Oliver’s load in the midfield.

Surely the club offloads Oliver? Petracca hates him at the club.

Your thoughts?

 

[CapitalA]

I'm sorry but no. Pickett is one of the very best small forwards in the league. Brodie has 0 value. Switkowski is a good little player but the guy will be 28 next year. Pickett is 23. I repeat, 23. He's worth 2 genuine firsts (if he was out of contract let alone in contract) and it seems like you're trying to squirm out of giving what he's actually worth. If we're losing Pickett, we're asking for Treacy, Brayshaw, Hayden Young etc. You can't get quality and offer up trash. Accumulating junk doesn't equal treasure. It's equivalent to me offering Sparrow, Jake Bowey and Pick 10 for Hayden Young. Come on now, be reasonable.

Bolton and Pickett are both worth the same value. It's 2x first rounders for each. Not 3 in total.

Alright you twisted our arms, you get Banfield and pick 17.

 

[DragoDelph]

Any chance Oliver goes and they look to Brodie or Erasmus packaged with a pick for Pickett? One of them takes Oliver’s load in the midfield.

Surely the club offloads Oliver? Petracca hates him at the club.

Your thoughts?

Really feels
Like they’ve committed to some change to keep him happy.

Be interesting because the blues itk’s thought it was done

 

[s_wd6]

Really feels
Like they’ve committed to some change to keep him happy.

Be interesting because the blues itk’s thought it was done

Who's the ITK? interested to see what he had to say

 

[DragoDelph]

Who's the ITK? interested to see what he had to say

They’re were a few.