List Mgmt. 2024 List Management thread - Trade Targets Part 2

[freo1997]

Because he is absolutely sh*t house

Well they better drop him and we better not pick him up!

 

[s_wd6]

Narkle gonna be delisted? Why?
He has played the back end of the year right?

I mean did you watch him play on Friday?

 

[Docker82]

It may change and he gets a contract offer, but if he's already in talks with WAFL clubs? Tabs was chatting to clubs about half way through the year as well.

Been on the fringes all year, playing now mainly because of the outs. shrugs

Sounds to me like he wants to get back to WA for non-footy reasons.

I don't think either WA team would be interested. He's not best 25 at Freo (I'd actually say best 30 but that's kind of debatable) and whilst he probably is at West Coast they'll want to get games into younger players that'll go past him in 12-18 months anyway. He'd just be a list clogger for either team.

 

[DragoDelph]

Sounds to me like he wants to get back to WA for non-footy reasons.

I don't think either WA team would be interested. He's not best 25 at Freo and whilst he probably is at West Coast they'd pretend he's not in order to get games into younger players that'll go past him in 12-18 months anyway. He'd just be a list clogger for either team.

I agree, but pretty sure he and SPP are close.

Was the SPP extension at Port around the same time the committed to Narkle for a couple of years?

 

[arsesmart]

I mean, this was clearly just an error, there were 3 peel players all in that vicinity and he picked out the SD player


I'd say it's 99% he was trying to hit one of the 3 peel boys

Error in decision making (I mean horrific bad) when under near zero pressure was what makes it concerning. And sure execution can go awry... but what he pulled out of the hat was a few strokes below sub par.

I mean I like Simpson too, but it's the combination there that makes it a stark moment to carry forward and not just be brushed aside.

Hopefully a real learning opportunity.

 

[CaseySibosadoHOF]

I know it only 1st to 4th year players, but surely this is a good sign. Frederick should have the endurance to apply elite pressure.

I wonder if certain players, can see the play unfolding 2 or 3 second early and no when and how to apply defensive pressure. Maybe he just doesn't have that.

THREE THINGS WE SAW: Frederick and Worner lead time trials

What we noticed on the track as Fremantle’s first-to-four-year players returned for the opening day of pre-season

www.fremantlefc.com.au

FREMANTLE FIRST TO FOUR YEAR 1km TIME TRIAL FINISHES:

Time Trial 1:
1. Karl Worner
2. Michael Frederick
3. Neil Erasmus
4. Conrad Williams
5. Matt Johnson

Time Trial 2:
1. Michael Frederick
2. Karl Worner
3. Neil Erasmus
4. Conrad Williams
5. Matt Johnson

Time Trial 3:
1. Nathan O’Driscoll
2. Michael Frederick
3. Neil Erasmus
4. Karl Worner
5. Matt Johnson

The 1 thing I worry about in terms of natural attributes is whether Freddy is a bit too "straight line pace" and tall to apply high level pressure and be a real presence at ground level. Some of the elite small fwds in those areas are shorter and have more agility. Not to say he can't improve in those areas coz he definitely can: 2022 in particular he was applying good pressure.

Might also have a bit to do with role. With his raw pace, he's a very appealing outlet option, and I imagine that's where he expends the bulk of his running. After Sharp (and there's a big gap after him), I think he's often next highest in sprint data on the Telstra Tracker.

 

[Docker82]

I agree, but pretty sure he and SPP are close.

Was the SPP extension at Port around the same time the committed to Narkle for a couple of years?

Tbh I think Port were just really short on depth and saw the opportunity to bring someone in with AFL experience in the MSD. I don't think most clubs draft anyone without planning to keep said player on their list a second season.

Now we're heading into trade week and free agency and eventually DFA and SSP they'll be no shortage of out of contract experienced fringe players that quite frankly offer a fair bit more than Narkle. There's already been players delisted that are better than him.

 

[s_wd6]

I really thought SPP was 28/29 and Narkle was 23/24. Did not realise they were both 26 only a month apart.

 

[apuchar]

2024 average age per team in home and away season​

Collingwood – 27.5
Geelong – 27.1
Brisbane – 26.3
Western Bulldogs – 26.2
Carlton – 26.1
Sydney – 26
Melbourne – 25.9
Essendon – 25.9
Richmond – 25.8
Port Adelaide – 25.7
St Kilda – 25.6
West Coast – 25.4
Greater Western Sydney – 25.2
Hawthorn – 25
Fremantle – 25
Adelaide – 24.8
Gold Coast – 24.7
North Melbourne – 24.3

2024 average games player per team in home and away season​

Geelong – 128
Collingwood – 128
Brisbane – 123
Sydney – 118
Melbourne – 113
Essendon – 110
Western Bulldogs – 109
St Kilda – 100
Port Adelaide – 100
West Coast – 96
Richmond – 95
Greater Western Sydney – 94
Carlton – 91
Hawthorn – 90
Fremantle – 87
Gold Coast – 85
Adelaide – 80
North Melbourne – 75

https://www.afl.com.au/aflw/fixture?Competition=3&Season=72&Round=1106

 

[mattis117]

Error in decision making (I mean horrific bad) when under near zero pressure was what makes it concerning. And sure execution can go awry... but what he pulled out of the hat was a few strokes below sub par.

I mean I like Simpson too, but it's the combination there that makes it a stark moment to carry forward and not just be brushed aside.

Hopefully a real learning opportunity.

Yes, that was a moment where I sat up and was like wow that's horrific, that's way below the level. I'm hoping it's just first year blues. Coop has really fallen off in the second half of this season.

 

[wakojako]

I was thinking if Noddy does leave, the club probably wants Chapman to replace him on the wing. Pretty risky move but could pay off.

 

[Snuffaluphagus]

Yes, that was a moment where I sat up and was like wow that's horrific, that's way below the level. I'm hoping it's just first year blues. Coop has really fallen off in the second half of this season.

Specifically the last 4 games. He actually was really building at the backend by getting a few more touches and getting on the scoreboard.

 

[s_wd6]

I was thinking if Noddy does leave, the club probably wants Chapman to replace him on the wing. Pretty risky move but could pay off.

The move has always been on the cards. Probably a bit easier now with Draper looking the goods.

 

[Paracleet]

2024 average age per team in home and away season​

Collingwood – 27.5
Geelong – 27.1
Brisbane – 26.3
Western Bulldogs – 26.2
Carlton – 26.1
Sydney – 26
Melbourne – 25.9
Essendon – 25.9
Richmond – 25.8
Port Adelaide – 25.7
St Kilda – 25.6
West Coast – 25.4
Greater Western Sydney – 25.2
Hawthorn – 25
Fremantle – 25
Adelaide – 24.8
Gold Coast – 24.7
North Melbourne – 24.3

2024 average games player per team in home and away season​

Geelong – 128
Collingwood – 128
Brisbane – 123
Sydney – 118
Melbourne – 113
Essendon – 110
Western Bulldogs – 109
St Kilda – 100
Port Adelaide – 100
West Coast – 96
Richmond – 95
Greater Western Sydney – 94
Carlton – 91
Hawthorn – 90
Fremantle – 87
Gold Coast – 85
Adelaide – 80
North Melbourne – 75

https://www.afl.com.au/aflw/fixture?Competition=3&Season=72&Round=1106

Also if you want to specifically compare Freo and Hawthorn who are ostensibly similar buts whose end of season form line went opposite ways: By the end of it we were fielding teams in the 85 games 24.8 years old range*. Whereas the Hawks actually were slightly older than Port on the weekend at 102 and 25.2 (v 98 and 25.1).

*This is only an excuse in that 'It is what it is'. We have put ourselves in this position through the decision to essentially double dip rebuild and not to expend capital shoring up the older end of the list (26+) though trades and DFA's (Instead the capital has been expended on players the same age as the core). We have only signed two players over the age of 26 in 5 years and one of them was a DFA backup. BTW I think there are strong signs its a strategy that is going to pay off, but until it does...

 

[Paracleet]

Yes, that was a moment where I sat up and was like wow that's horrific, that's way below the level. I'm hoping it's just first year blues. Coop has really fallen off in the second half of this season.

There was a bit of a jumper clash yesterday. Allan also handballed direct to Swans player in space at one point. And it wasn't like it was a 5 metre no-look handball to a voice. Guy was 15 / 20 metres away ahead of play.

 

[apuchar]

I agree. It honestly looked like he thought it was a Peel player in the open. Only he could answer that though

 

[poshman]

Also if you want to specifically compare Freo and Hawthorn who are ostensibly similar buts whose end of season form line went opposite ways: By the end of it we were fielding teams in the 85 games 24.8 years old range*. Whereas the Hawks actually were slightly older than Port on the weekend at 102 and 25.2 (v 98 and 25.1).

*This is only an excuse in that 'It is what it is'. We have put ourselves in this position through the decision to essentially double dip rebuild and not to expend capital shoring up the older end of the list (26+) though trades and DFA's (Instead the capital has been expended on players the same age as the core). We have only signed two players over the age of 26 in 5 years and one of them was a DFA backup. BTW I think there a strong signs its a strategy that is going to pay off, but until it does...

Oh it will pay off. And pay off in a big way. There has been some pain getting here and that will make the next decade all the sweeter.

 

[Paracleet]

BTW I had been thinking about this when occasionally reading 'Frederick to the wing' posts, but only just got round to digging up the stats. This is why it'll never happen:

 

[poshman]

Bolton seems like a done deal. Just his addition makes us the best forward line in the league. I never thought I would say that.

We can expect growth from Simpson, Chapman, Draper, Young (where is his ceiling?), Jackson, Amiss and Treacy.

I can't wait to see what this team becomes!

 

[go_the_dockers]

BTW I had been thinking about this when occasionally reading 'Frederick to the wing' posts, but only just got round to digging up the stats. This is why it'll never happen:

View attachment 2112426

What website are you using?

 

[Paracleet]

What website are you using?

AFL Player Statistics

AFL player statistics.

www.wheeloratings.com

 

[Docker82]

The move has always been on the cards. Probably a bit easier now with Draper looking the goods.

Not sure we’ll be able to get away with playing Draper at Peel anyway tbh. If we try that at some stage it’s not going to end well in terms of him staying at the club long term.

But I do think there’s room for Sharp and Chapman on either wing and NOD as an inside wind that rotates wing within the best 22 tbh (It’d probably mean Johnson replaces Fyfe rather than playing multiple roles during games which I’m okay with).

 

[malpaso]

Not sure we’ll be able to get away with playing Draper at Peel anyway tbh. If we try that at some stage it’s not going to end well in terms of him staying at the club long term.

But I do think there’s room for Sharp and Chapman on either wing and NOD as an inside wind that rotates wing within the best 22 tbh (It’d probably mean Johnson replaces Fyfe rather than playing multiple roles during games which I’m okay with).

Draper will play where the club tells him to. He has a lot to learn and also needs to bulk up, he only played this year because of injuries to our KPD.
We aren't moving around best 22 players for fear of Draper leaving..

 

[freo_leo29]

Narkle in talks for South Freo next year.

Port gonna play him in 3 finals and delist?


I reckon those talks are over, should be at port next year

 

[go_the_dockers]

Port gonna play him in 3 finals and delist?


I reckon those talks are over, should be at port next year

Only best 22 as powell pepper is injured.

I don't think he plays a game next year. Fair to delist him. Wish we were half as ruthless as this.