List Mgmt. 2024 List Management thread - Trade Targets

[s_wd6]

If Brodie had it in him, we would've seen it by now. He's been out of the team for over 1.5 seasons at this point, and probably even pre-dating that he should've known these are the aspects of his game to work on.

Gotta cut him loose and let some other team take his salary. There's a good 8-10 names I'm taking off the list before I attempt to strongarm Fyfe or Walters into retirement (especially if they embrace not playing every game when available), and Brodie is on that list.

If not Brodie than NOD. Fyfe isn’t going to get any better and him getting worse is a liability, as seen today. He’s not going to get his flag. Neither will Sonny. Both are past it. Better to retire now than after another year either in the twos or being gifted games when they don’t deserve it

 

[CaseySibosadoHOF]

If not Brodie than NOD. Fyfe isn’t going to get any better and him getting worse is a liability, as seen today. He’s not going to get his flag. Neither will Sonny. Both are past it. Better to retire now than after another year either in the twos or being gifted games when they don’t deserve it

With Fyfe and Walters (especially Fyfe), I look at it as "is their best that they've shown this season at least somewhere in the top 30 of this list", and my answer is "hell yes". Playing them every game when they're fit doesn't work. But there are finals teams that have managed vets exceptionally. If I said to you this time last year "Jack Gunston can play an important role for a finals team next year", I think my account would've been banned for spreading misinformation.

It's the old "I ain't as good as I once was, But I'm as good once as I ever was".

 

[FreoRicci]

Would love to add some currency or trade value for players.
Switkowski for one. If Bolton comes, surely he’s out.

 

[rgauci]

Come on. Rioli barely touched it.
The fat drug cheat got a free, and two goals that dropped in his overweight lap.

Walker belted him running off him and provided good drive off half back

Walker had 205m gained and 0 score involvement.

Wagner, Clark, Ryan and Sharp all have >400m gained.

Ryan and Clark 1 score involvement, 4 for Wagner and 5 for Sharp.

Walker was average. Apparently we are looking at Cummings. He’d be an instant upgrade on Walker and Wagner.

 

[apuchar]

Anyone suggesting Baker isn’t worth it needs a kick in the pee hole.

Baker is everything we weren’t today.

Bolton and Baker yes please. Get it done.

So he must be tall, fast and dynamic with a brilliant long kick

 

[bone2468]

You’re ****ing nuts.

I’m not going to sit here and watch, Banfield, Emmet, Freddy and Switta stink it up all year.

**** that in the poo hole

I’m not going to watch them either, are you telling me your fine spending all 3 of our first rounders on 1 player?

 

[apuchar]

I’m not going to watch them either, are you telling me your fine spending all 3 of our first rounders on 1 player?

Not 3. I hope we don't go stupid.

 

[FreoRicci]

Walker had 205m gained and 0 score involvement.

Wagner, Clark, Ryan and Sharp all have >400m gained.

Ryan and Clark 1 score involvement, 4 for Wagner and 5 for Sharp.

Walker was average. Apparently we are looking at Cummings. He’d be an instant upgrade on Walker and Wagner.

Walker isn’t getting metres gained ffs.
No lockdown specialist is getting that.
The whole purpose of a lockdown defender is so the other 3 defenders can.

 

[bone2468]

Not 3. I hope we don't go stupid.

After the season we’ve enjured I think we’re that stupid, we’ll get a 3rd rounder back lol

 

[FreoRicci]

Anyone suggesting Baker isn’t worth it needs a kick in the pee hole.

Baker is everything we weren’t today.

Bolton and Baker yes please. Get it done.

So another angry small midget that apparently is classy?
Great

 

[FreoRicci]

NOD must re sign.
He was so different today.
Him and Sharp for 2025. Hope the club knows this and look at JOM, Switkowski, Fyfe and do some hard truths.

 

[Cobbler]

So he must be tall, fast and dynamic with a brilliant long kick

He’s clean…

 

[FreoMatt]

Giving up all our first rounders for a small forward id rather go to the draft and take our chances as much as I love Bolton

Where did I say give up all our first rounders??


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[freo_leo29]

NOD must re sign.
He was so different today.
Him and Sharp for 2025. Hope the club knows this and look at JOM, Switkowski, Fyfe and do some hard truths.

Sounds like its as good as done from the way Noddy spoke post game, can't wait to get into preseason, loved the club since he was 6 etc

 

[freo_leo29]

Club already knows players want to be traded

Probably confirms atleast one of the Switta or Sturt calls :\

 

[FreoRicci]

Club already knows players want to be traded

Probably confirms atleast one of the Switta or Sturt calls :\

Hopefully it’s 100% Switta.

 

[Midnite65]

Hopefully it’s 100% Switta.

Why, at least he was having a crack unlike Freddie and a few others.

 

[ilikepotatoes]

Club already knows players want to be traded

Probably confirms atleast one of the Switta or Sturt calls :\

That's incredibly poor for the club to release right?

 

[mightymouse75]

That's incredibly poor for the club to release right?

Sturt to Port Adelaide as we haven't helped them out yet.
Sam Switta to Sydney ??
We need to help out all the top teams.
What a fn joke.

 

[Midnite65]

That's incredibly poor for the club to release right?

Not really, its nice to hear non cliched answers. We failed to make finals so changes need to be made.

 

[ilikepotatoes]

Sturt to Port Adelaide as we haven't helped them out yet.
Sam Switta to Sydney ??
We need to help out all the top teams.
What a fn joke.

Hopefully it's someone like Brodie who we are under-utilising.

We can't keep losing best 22 players.

 

[Midnite65]

We can't keep losing best 22 players.

We can because clearly our best 22 was not good enough to make finals, i.e Freddie, Johnson, JOM, etc all best 22 and we failed for another year.

 

[bone2468]

Where did I say give up all our first rounders??


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

Where did I say you said it? Talks all year have been they want all 3 picks

 

[Purple Jesus]

Club already knows players want to be traded

Probably confirms atleast one of the Switta or Sturt calls :\

If it’s Sturt and it’s because we low balled him, I’m ****ing done.

 

[Joao]

Who would you rather play? Erasmus will probably already be playing, so who do you want to be our backup and rotation guy? If Fyfe can play an important role in our midfield set-up then so can Brodie. and probably do it better. Serong and Brayshaw need big body support and Erasmus can't help with that yet. Young can't carry that whole load himself. Johnson is still an unknown quantity and should probably be rested at times or at least be required to earn his spot. Unless we recruit some ready made quality mid, we don't have anyone else.

I don't want to do a rotation in the first place. That's your idea.

I'd put Ras in for Fyfe, draft/trade another inside mid and Brodie can play when there is an injury. Either that or NoD or someone else can fill in those games.

Also Bolton will absolutely spend time in the middle. As would Baker if we get him.

With Fyfe and Walters (especially Fyfe), I look at it as "is their best that they've shown this season at least somewhere in the top 30 of this list", and my answer is "hell yes". Playing them every game when they're fit doesn't work. But there are finals teams that have managed vets exceptionally. If I said to you this time last year "Jack Gunston can play an important role for a finals team next year", I think my account would've been banned for spreading misinformation.

It's the old "I ain't as good as I once was, But I'm as good once as I ever was".

The problem is, their best only appeared once all season. Walters v Crows and Fyfe v Dogs (1st time).

You can't carry them around for 10-15 games hoping to get a blinder when the average games are so poor.