Teams 2024 Rate My Pre-Season Team

[TheArchitect]

I get the sneaky feeling that we are all over-reacting to the practice game today.

 

[gutsroy]

I get the sneaky feeling that we are all over-reacting to the practice game today.

Hard to resist the temptation a little, especially now that there are some real games to base things on.
But it is true.
The reality is that all of the changes are meaningless until after Rd 0, might as well watch it all unfold and assess then

 

[buttox]

Hard to resist the temptation a little, especially now that there are some real games to base things on.
But it is true.
The reality is that all of the changes are meaningless until after Rd 0, might as well watch it all unfold and assess then

I wonder how quickly we forget these early practice games.
I bet teams are skewed more to the most recent games

 

[gutsroy]

I wonder how quickly we forget these early practice games.
I bet teams are skewed more to the most recent games

Absolutely will be, mate.
Sheeze pre-, post- would be interesting, to name one example.
Xerri (certainly in AF) will have copped a bump etc.

 

[balmainforever]

gone for a 4th norf player with sheezel in for sinclair

 

[MacStradbroke]

I get the sneaky feeling that we are all over-reacting to the practice game today.

Am not!

 

[Dark Sharks]

Is it weird i've basically ****ed off every round 2-6 premo that has 2x byes off out of my team?



Gawn and Grundy stay due to price
Naicos because he's a disgusting chip scab and i really can't be ****ed not having him in my team at any point this year.
Flanders because Dimma was on his knees about it.

Aaaand that's about it really. Zilliams and Gibcus i'm ready to punt as well.

 

[DrSalt]

Hustwaite is speculatively but has been tracking well this pre-season. Trying to avoid mid-priced madness this year for once

 

[Username Unknown]

I didn’t watch all of the north intra club game but from what I saw. Player were also looking for Sheezel to distribute the ball out of the back line in that game.

 

[Better Loosen Up]

Sheezel makes it 5 ffs.

I'd be dropping Powell. Not because he's no good, I just think the others are better value picks.

Don't shoot me if I am wrong though!

 

[blueiris]

So Scheezel scored 142 fantasy points not bad

 

[blueiris]

My Current team was really impressed with Conway and Wehr today could be 2 really good rookie options

 

[Jetwa5h]

This is i think my 1316th ish version, welcome comments and criticism

 

[FAILTOSUCCEED]

View attachment 1910788

This is i think my 1316th ish version, welcome comments and criticism

Backline too risky, rookies ain’t that solid. Not sure even Curtin plays R1.

Need another premo Sheez/Young type.

Downgrade a mid or fwd.

 

[ubeaut]

Any advice ?
I hate the byes, so many players from round 0 I can't pick .. 4 is the least I can manage from round 0

 

[SC fish]

Have ended up with this

 

[LuvtheKangas]

Have ended up with this
View attachment 1911087

Lazzaro will outscore Duursma to a significant level and is slightly cheaper.

 

[FAILTOSUCCEED]

Have ended up with this
View attachment 1911087

Solid team mate!

A few things for me personally to consider:

Walsh missing Ps games due to back issues.

Macrae should be FWD but also hammy issues, big watch PS.

Duursma to Lazaro, cheaper, will play and score better either way.

Not sure Curtin will even play R1, watch that space.

 

[TennisPlayerAndy]

Up to five North players (Sheezel, LDU, Wardlaw, McKercher and Lazzaro).

It’s too many, but I can’t drop any of them.

 

[JuddgementDay]

Up to five North players (Sheezel, LDU, Wardlaw, McKercher and Lazzaro).

It’s too many, but I can’t drop any of them.

It's getting like that

You can also put up an argument for X and Powell

 

[SC fish]

Solid team mate!

A few things for me personally to consider:

Walsh missing Ps games due to back issues.

Macrae should be FWD but also hammy issues, big watch PS.

Duursma to Lazaro, cheaper, will play and score better either way.

Not sure Curtin will even play R1, watch that space.

Have turfed Macrae for Errol. Will keep an eye on Walsh

 

[TennisPlayerAndy]

It's getting like that

You can also put up an argument for X and Powell

You certainly can.

But there are better options at their prices.

The value of McKercher, Lazzaro, the potential of Wardlaw and the scoring prowess of LDU and Sheezel makes them locks.

 

[SSwans2011]

Seeing wayyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy too many North players in teams. campaigners are asking for trouble.






Myself included.



Heading to New Zealand for a couple of weeks next week, so this will probably be roughly what my team looks until after opening round.

Steele, Wardlaw and Adams are the players I feel are most likely to miss out from this line-up. Probably via downgrading Wardlaw and upgrading Adams to Flanders and Steele to someone like Merrett or Libba. I'm keen on the Warlord but I reckon you're playing with fire having 2 second-year players from the same team... hard to see the SC gods having a bar of that.

Feel like I'm getting close to what my starting side will look like though.

 

[ubeaut]

S

View attachment 1910788

This is i think my 1316th ish version, welcome comments and criticism

Something to keep in mind you have 6 round 0 players.
I'd also downgrade Martin or Crouch and get another back Sheez/ Sicily or Young

 

[Northernsoul74]

You certainly can.

But there are better options at their prices.

The value of McKercher, Lazzaro, the potential of Wardlaw and the scoring prowess of LDU and Sheezel makes them locks.

Interested in better options than Powell in the fwd line?