Position 2024 Rookies

[gutsroy]

Those 3 aren't really his competition though are they? Didn't he come in for Elliot?

Yeah, Pendles and Mitchell not directly relevant to him, DeGoey to a point.
Mire just that week regain them, Mihocek etc. and there stress only 22 spots to go around.
Elliot out a while helps him a fair bit because on exposed form he's ahead of most of the other new players

 

[A Bit Dusty]

Yeah, Pendles and Mitchell not directly relevant to him, DeGoey to a point.
Mire just that week regain them, Mihocek etc. and there stress only 22 spots to go around.
Elliot out a while helps him a fair bit because on exposed form he's ahead of most of the other new players

Reef McInnes is back this week as well.

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Yeah, Pendles and Mitchell not directly relevant to him, DeGoey to a point.
Mire just that week regain them, Mihocek etc. and there stress only 22 spots to go around.
Elliot out a while helps him a fair bit because on exposed form he's ahead of most of the other new players

We'll see how it plays out I guess. He might be worth holding over other rookies though. As you say he played better than some of these other young players that have surfaced for Collingwood recently.

 

[A Bit Dusty]

We'll see how it plays out I guess. He might be worth holding over other rookies though. As you say he played better than some of these other young players that have surfaced for Collingwood recently.

There are a few arguments to hold and the same to trade him out. For me next week there should be at least one of the $102k rookies to trade him down to which makes $110k and allows me to get Gull Ryan. He might not even come back into the team this year and if you hold come Round 17-19 there is No playing rookies to trade down to. I think cash in while we can still make some money and get someone who is playing.

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

There are a few arguments to hold and the same to trade him out. For me next week there should be at least one of the $102k rookies to trade him down to which makes $110k and allows me to get Gull Ryan. He might not even come back into the team this year and if you hold come Round 17-19 there is No playing rookies to trade down to. I think cash in while we can still make some money and get someone who is playing.

Yeah that's definitely an option.

I'm looking at him and Jhye Clark as a way to a 23rd premo. Richards only needs 2 more games and he'll be close to $300k. Then trade him down to a $102k DPP donut if needed. Never hurts to have playing rookies late in the season, even if you can't use their money.

 

[Quazza]

Can someone talk me either in or out of McNeil ?

(Oh my gif)

 

[Wellsy35]

Can someone talk me either in or out of McNeil ?

(Oh my gif)

Non-existent JS, high sub risk, very low floor, only two price rises till bye.

 

[ubeaut]

How's McMullin from GWSs JS?

 

[Judd_Magic]

How's McMullin from GWSs JS?

I reckon he is in while Cogs is out which is around 6 weeks.

 

[MrChristo]

Brown will come straight back in, won't he?

 

[A Bit Dusty]

Brown will come straight back in, won't he?

Which Brown?

 

[MrChristo]

GWS. (Re: McMullin)

 

[JuddgementDay]

Brown will come straight back in, won't he?

Competing position though?

 

[MrChristo]

Competing position though?

Probably not.

(Sorry, I had it in my mind that because he's classified as a F that's where he played).

Cummings only a week away though.

Also, having just looked at the GWS injury list, I'm amazed to see Pruess is out indefinitely with a hamstring.
Crazy for such a durable guy.

 

[gutsroy]

We'll see how it plays out I guess. He might be worth holding over other rookies though. As you say he played better than some of these other young players that have surfaced for Collingwood recently.

Yeah, problem is always when you're out and someone playa in your spot and goes OK, do they bring you straight back in?
With the established blokes that's a lot easier to predict.
But talent- nd impact-wise, even of their roles are not identical, Joe has Reef, HH, Fin Macrae, Sullivan, Parker and Allan all covered.
Tricky one,if I owned him (Scoops going full OJ Simpson there lol(, inclination would be to hold if I didn't desperately need to access his moolah.
But as a proud Biggie Nyuon owner, it's tough for me to relate to you little people, I move in a different stratosphere.

 

[pincrusher]

 

[timtimtim]

Couldn’t they play Loch Rawlings again?

Need that DPP

 

[Axly]

Dowling?

 

[Ingy]

Dowling?

I'm in. Ticks a few boxes

 

[Axly]

I'm in. Ticks a few boxes

Go on....

 

[Northernsoul74]

Can someone talk me either in or out of McNeil ?

(Oh my gif)

Yes he’s crap and will be lucky to be on a list next year. He’s been sub due to lots of injuries but I don’t think he’s anywhere near best 22.

 

[Ingy]

Go on....

Box 1: mid/fwd dpp. This works for me. I needed this.

Box 2: Not a first year. Two preseasons under his belt.

Box 3: Stats up. Averaging 24 possies a game in the SANFL and more lately.

Box 4: Replacing a guy (Mrouch) with a lucrative fantasy role.

Box 5: His name's Billy. Not ****en Gryan or Sheridan or any of this flaky sh1t. The name of a kent you'd want next to you in the trenches, who'd pull the enemy off you with his bare hands in the afternoon and then tell a hilarious dirty joke around the camp-fire that night

 

[Ingy]

Box 1: mid/fwd dpp. This works for me. I needed this.

Box 2: Not a first year. Two preseasons under his belt.

Box 3: Stats up. Averaging 24 possies a game in the SANFL and more lately.

Box 4: Replacing a guy (Mrouch) with a lucrative fantasy role.

Box 5: His name's Billy. Not ****en Gryan or Sheridan or any of this flaky sh1t. The name of a kent you'd want next to you in the trenches, who'd pull the enemy off you with his bare hands in the afternoon and then tell a hilarious dirty joke around the camp-fire that night

Oh I forgot the important Box 6: will play in Round 14 when I'm cooked and need him desperately lol

 

[A Bit Dusty]

Why Eagles couldn’t look past talented Collingwood VFL product in mid-season draft

The high-flyer is now set for his AFL debut less than two weeks after being drafted.

www.sen.com.au

Interesting comment here in the article.

“We don’t see him coming here as a forward and that’s it, we acknowledge that those picks in the mid-season draft are later picks really because it’s on the back of people not getting drafted.

“We wanted to bring him in, and we think he could play a variety of roles in the midfield and even across half-back if we need.

 

[kaiserchief13]

Why Eagles couldn’t look past talented Collingwood VFL product in mid-season draft

The high-flyer is now set for his AFL debut less than two weeks after being drafted.

www.sen.com.au

Interesting comment here in the article.

“We don’t see him coming here as a forward and that’s it, we acknowledge that those picks in the mid-season draft are later picks really because it’s on the back of people not getting drafted.

“We wanted to bring him in, and we think he could play a variety of roles in the midfield and even across half-back if we need.

He kicked 5 goals in wafl last week so probably plays half forward i would guess