Position 2024 Rucks

[King Max]

If only I could afford English …

I did see the NAB bank manager about purchasing him first.
Put me on a good monthly direct debit plan till 2034.

 

[Phoenix_9]

Lads, can someone make a case for Maley or Livingstone at R3. Who is the better loop?

 

[Nelso]

Lads, can someone make a case for Maley or Livingstone at R3. Who is the better loop?

Livingstone as West Coast play more late games in the round.

 

[Lindsay_Gilbee]

Can’t decide between Gawn, English and Marshall. Rucks seem to always define my season.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Can’t decide between Gawn, English and Marshall. Rucks seem to always define my season.

On a value POV ....Gawn

I'm assuming you already have Grundy

 

[Sphynx]

Thought Xerri gave Briggs an absolute hiding, even man handled him physically at times, which I haven’t seen anyone do to him since his breakout game last year.

Could be in for a massive year.

 

[blackshadow]

Thought Xerri gave Briggs an absolute hiding, even man handled him physically at times, which I haven’t seen anyone do to him since his breakout game last year.

Could be in for a massive year.

His best game to date. Had him in as my R2 until I flipped to Grundy after round 0. Kicking myself a little now.

 

[ArdentEagle]

Which genius decided to have ROB as a ruck POD.

This one

 

[Ken Tea]

Barnett super impressive in the WAFL hit out yesterday, one to watch.

 

[FAILTOSUCCEED]

Hands up if you dropped off Gawn after R0. I know there are a few that said they would. Be honest please.

 

[A Bit Dusty]

Hands up if you dropped off Gawn after R0. I know there are a few that said they would. Be honest please.

Never left my team

 

[FAILTOSUCCEED]

Never left my team

Never in doubt will be right at the top end this year

 

[kyri]

Hands up if you dropped off Gawn after R0. I know there are a few that said they would. Be honest please.

English was one of my first picked. 95% of preseason, Grundy was my R2. Only during the preseason match did Grundy become Max.

Could never really see myself getting rid of English, and the extra 100k from Grundy to Gawn made Brodie feel underpriced and Max priced about right.

Poor call but it is what it is.

 

[FAILTOSUCCEED]

English was one of my first picked. 95% of preseason, Grundy was my R2. Only during the preseason match did Grundy become Max.

Could never really see myself getting rid of English, and the extra 100k from Grundy to Gawn made Brodie feel underpriced and Max priced about right.

Poor call but it is what it is.

Yeah I do get it. I just think Gawn can average close to English for $150k less. But the ideal set up would have been taking both think. I have Grundy as well, a bit concerned but ride him out for a bit and see how he goes.

 

[Better Loosen Up]

Went with the value combo of Grundy and X in the end. Good start for X and I'm sure Grundy will bounce back. If they can both get to 550 - 600k, they've done their job by allowing me to start an extra premo.

 

[THE_GUN]

Im thinking its going to be hard for english to keep that Price and expect him to drop
Hopefully Grundy increses and i can go side ways and have a English/Gawn combo which is my ideal Ruck combo

 

[toxic]

 

[Makeshift Park]

Who was the only North player to win coaches votes last round?

LDU, you say?

Sheezel?

Larkey?

Nah.




I should try a year of SC where I don't pay any mind to ownership.

It was clear as day to me a month ago that Xerri was a better pick than Fisher.

And yet now, here I am.

 

[Sydney Kicker]

Who was the only North player to win coaches votes last round?

LDU, you say?

Sheezel?

Larkey?

Nah.


View attachment 1932207

I should try a year of SC where I don't pay any mind to ownership.

It was clear as day to me a month ago that Xerri was a better pick than Fisher.

And yet now, here I am.

Xerri looks good. Very happy I started with him. Though I wouldn't be dumping Grundy for him, not yet anyway.

 

[kyri]

Im thinking its going to be hard for english to keep that Price and expect him to drop
Hopefully Grundy increses and i can go side ways and have a English/Gawn combo which is my ideal Ruck combo

we didnt pay 700k to worry about his price. just forget hes there. he might drop to 600k but its besides the point. if he stays fit. youre getting a 120avg out of him.. thats what we paid for.

 

[SavDog23]

Only 139 of the top 1696 teams (Top 1%) own Timmy English

200 as Captain against Eagles this week would be delicious

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Only 139 of the top 1696 teams (Top 1%) own Timmy English

200 as Captain against Eagles this week would be delicious

What about 80 as captain when Crazy Bevo subs him in the third when they are miles ahead?

 

[iDon]

Only 139 of the top 1696 teams (Top 1%) own Timmy English

200 as Captain against Eagles this week would be delicious

Hi, I am one of those guys. Go KING English

 

[catstragic]

Can't see Darcy helping English's scoring. Happy to run Gawn all year, Grundy will be my last upgrade

 

[54Dogs]

Can't see Darcy helping English's scoring. Happy to run Gawn all year, Grundy will be my last upgrade

English was 75-80% ruck almost all of last yr, was 60% first game with Darcy in. Long term can't help his scoring.

2023


2024