TENACIOUS
Premiership Player
- Aug 16, 2008
- 3,874
- 14,714
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Thread starter
- #2
https://s.afl.com.au/staticfile/AFL Tenant/AFL/Files/Father-son-bidding-system.pdf
Last edited:
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 9 - Indigenous Round - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
2024 (Tenacious) Annual Carlton Board Phantom Draft
- Thread starter TENACIOUS
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Wickzki
Definitely Sam MacLure.
- Oct 1, 2010
- 26,043
- 62,562
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- Ophidians Old Boys, Blazers, MCFC
All good mate. Was going to prank someone whilst filling a need.
Pick 32 - pOWeR
Angus Clarke
Local boy. HB flanker who at 188cm has speed, endurance and is a natural rebounder. Untidy yet effective kicking technique. He'll develop nicely while they give Sinn the exposure he needs at HB.
Who needs Houston anyway?
WalshistheGOAT you're up next with the dokers.
Angus Clarke
Local boy. HB flanker who at 188cm has speed, endurance and is a natural rebounder. Untidy yet effective kicking technique. He'll develop nicely while they give Sinn the exposure he needs at HB.
Who needs Houston anyway?
WalshistheGOAT you're up next with the dokers.
- Mar 25, 2019
- 12,289
- 25,435
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Pick 33 - Fremantle
Zak Johnson
May be considered the first 'reach' of 'bolter' of the draft but I'm very happy to be picking him up here.
Another utility type selection for the Docker's who are sured up all over the ground but need a bit more x factor and creative ball use. Johnson's a player who's shown proficiency in all areas of the ground as a MID/HBF/HFF but is best suited to a high half back role similar to that of Dan Houston where he can intercept the ball and springboard attacks for his team with his deadly ball use. His ball use is his strong point, almost never wastes a possession when he's looking to retain the ball, but he's also got a great creative streak to his game and isn't afraid to take the game on when called upon. He tends to look a bit lackadaisical at times, but never flustered or rushed, he can hit targets on any angle short or long and has some of the best vision with ball in hand in the draft class. The question mark is on his body and whether a few years in a professional environment can see him play with a bit more intensity while also adding to his agility, explosiveness and repeat sprint endurance.
An underrated competitor too who loves flogging a bloke or two with a nice hard late bump when he can. Never takes a backwards step at the contest.
Ninja Worrier ur up next
Zak Johnson
May be considered the first 'reach' of 'bolter' of the draft but I'm very happy to be picking him up here.
Another utility type selection for the Docker's who are sured up all over the ground but need a bit more x factor and creative ball use. Johnson's a player who's shown proficiency in all areas of the ground as a MID/HBF/HFF but is best suited to a high half back role similar to that of Dan Houston where he can intercept the ball and springboard attacks for his team with his deadly ball use. His ball use is his strong point, almost never wastes a possession when he's looking to retain the ball, but he's also got a great creative streak to his game and isn't afraid to take the game on when called upon. He tends to look a bit lackadaisical at times, but never flustered or rushed, he can hit targets on any angle short or long and has some of the best vision with ball in hand in the draft class. The question mark is on his body and whether a few years in a professional environment can see him play with a bit more intensity while also adding to his agility, explosiveness and repeat sprint endurance.
An underrated competitor too who loves flogging a bloke or two with a nice hard late bump when he can. Never takes a backwards step at the contest.
Ninja Worrier ur up next
Last edited:
Bletch
Premium Platinum
- Dec 8, 2020
- 3,745
- 11,858
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Hi Ten,
It doesn't really matter for the purposes of this phantom, so keep doing it this way.
But... The leftover points don't get added to the next pick. A new pick is inserted based on the leftover value, AFTER the draft order has been updated by removing the other picks. See the Heeney example on the link you shared, note the last pick used (57) gets moved back to 64, which is the value of the leftover picks.
So in this example, a new pick 12 is inserted and given to Essendon, everyone else shuffles down one pick. Essendon's pick 28 is moved to the back of the draft, and everyone after that pick shuffles up one. Essendon's pick 31 is moved to 51. Everyone else between 32 and 51 move up one. Essendon then have picks 39, 45, 51, 53, 54, 65. Here, 40 and 46 have been moved up one. 51 is new, and the remaining picks stay the same. I think...!!
It must be a nightmare doing this on your phone! Kudos to you. And as I said, just keep doing it the way you have been, it's fine that way.
Thanks for running this!
- Jul 13, 2018
- 1,090
- 2,434
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Pick 34 - St.Kilda
Tom Gross
Write up to come later
Tom Gross
Write up to come later
- Jul 13, 2018
- 1,090
- 2,434
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Getting tough for doggies list needs here (without bidding on Ben Campo, which would annoy most with this exercise.)
Bid for West Coast NGA dynamic small forward Malakai Champion (nephew of Eddie Betts) TerryWallet what say you?
Bid for West Coast NGA dynamic small forward Malakai Champion (nephew of Eddie Betts) TerryWallet what say you?
Sorry Coona. Just got online, wasn't expecting a bid here. Yes for the sake of this exercise WC will match, even though they've got a lot of small forwards including now Owies and Berry.
Pick 37 - Western Bulldogs - JACK OUGH - 194cm (15/12/2006) - GWV Rebels
Hybrid wingman with the “curious name”, has an excellent championship series playing on a wing, before moving to a more inside role at the back end of the season and in the Coates League finals. Prolific in both roles, at first glance looks better suited to the outside role as a prototype KPP sized athletic wingman. His midfield highlights showed a somewhat ungainly looking player, but had the happy knack of getting hands to the ball and dishing off effectively by hand.
Late birthday and plenty of maturity to come. Has he finished growing? May look more the part inside as he grows in to his frame. Another each way bet. A POD outside runner of the Acres mould (only bigger) or a player who could become a genuine big bodied mid. Perhaps even be a consideration to becoming a key position/third tall type in a professional environment. Probably a slow burn type, but with a very balanced list the ‘dogs can afford the development time.
One of a host of players in this draft who are largely untapped. Pablito you are up.
Hybrid wingman with the “curious name”, has an excellent championship series playing on a wing, before moving to a more inside role at the back end of the season and in the Coates League finals. Prolific in both roles, at first glance looks better suited to the outside role as a prototype KPP sized athletic wingman. His midfield highlights showed a somewhat ungainly looking player, but had the happy knack of getting hands to the ball and dishing off effectively by hand.
Late birthday and plenty of maturity to come. Has he finished growing? May look more the part inside as he grows in to his frame. Another each way bet. A POD outside runner of the Acres mould (only bigger) or a player who could become a genuine big bodied mid. Perhaps even be a consideration to becoming a key position/third tall type in a professional environment. Probably a slow burn type, but with a very balanced list the ‘dogs can afford the development time.
One of a host of players in this draft who are largely untapped. Pablito you are up.
- Jul 13, 2018
- 1,090
- 2,434
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Man you just shot Bambi
bradfisher14
Not actually Brad Fisher
Oh, man. Twice I wanted to bid and twice refrained due to this being a Carlton Phantom Draft.
It does highlight where he actually sits in the draft and how much we will be relying on goodwill if we maintain pick 38 as it stands.
This draft is not as deep as many, me included, think. There are players around the mark who are quality, but most are big boys in this part of the draft, rather than a range of types.
Jimmae
Brownlow Medallist
Personally think there's enough happening here that it won't come until after 40, but I do hope we bundle 3 & 38 and try to trade with Richmond or the Saints.
- May 1, 2002
- 12,013
- 20,300
- AFL Club
- Carlton
IMO, if we bundle 38 it will be with next year's 3rd. If we want to try and get lower.
How much lower is anyone's guess and whether it's worth losing another pick next year is the question.
How much lower is anyone's guess and whether it's worth losing another pick next year is the question.
Wickzki
Definitely Sam MacLure.
- Oct 1, 2010
- 26,043
- 62,562
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- Ophidians Old Boys, Blazers, MCFC
I agree with you but also have heard some insiders (might have been Twomey) who think Campo goes 45+
Not sure what's going on to tank his value this much.
bradfisher14
Not actually Brad Fisher
I think recruiters get spooked by pure inside mids that aren't elite users by foot or overly quick. It's also an extremely mid heavy draft, so teams are likely to fill that need with earlier picks which pushes him even further down the order. Father sons that are off broadway tend to drift further down the order regardless - Calsher Dear as a recent example.
Wickzki
Definitely Sam MacLure.
- Oct 1, 2010
- 26,043
- 62,562
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- Ophidians Old Boys, Blazers, MCFC
Yeah I've been saying the latter for weeks but seeing no action on Ben Campo is a touch surprising given what Coona said about late drafters needing inside mids being true.
