2024 (Tenacious) Annual Carlton Board Phantom Draft

[TENACIOUS]

https://s.afl.com.au/staticfile/AFL Tenant/AFL/Files/Father-son-bidding-system.pdf

Pick	Club	Player (click on player below, will take you to post)	Poster
1	Richmond	Jagga Smith	Bletch
2	Brisbane *	Levi Ashcroft	Sheephead
3	Richmond	Sam Lalor	Bletch
4	Carlton	Harvey Langford	Soapy V
5	Adelaide	Sid Draper	GoBlues!
6	Melbourne	Finn O’Sullivan	Blugazi
7	North Melbourne	Alix Tauru	Blue and Silver
8	Gold Coast *	Leo Lombard
9	St Kilda	Josh Smillie	Ninja Worrier
10	St Kilda	Xavier Lyndsay	Ninja Worrier
11	Melbourne	Murphy Reid	Blugazi
12	Essendon *	Issac Kako	TENACIOUS
13	Richmond	Tobie Travaglia	Bletch
14	Richmond	Taj Hotton	Bletch
15	West Coast	Joe Berry	TerryWallet
16	Port Adelaide	Luke Trainor	Pablito
17	Fremantle	Bo Allan	WalshistheGOAT
18	Greater Western Sydney	Cooper Hynes	bradfisher14
19	Greater Western Sydney	Oli Hannaford	bradfisher14
20	Brisbane *	Sam Marshall
21	Western Bulldogs	Harrison Oliver	Coona Blues
22	North Melbourne	Jobe Shanahan	Blue and Silver
23	Sydney	Harry Armstong	Wickzki
24	Richmond	Jack Whitlock	Bletch
25	Greater Western Sydney	Alex Dodson	bradfisher14
26	Sydney	Jesse Dattoli	Wickzki
27	Richmond	Jonty Faull	Bletch
28	Richmond	Jasper Algar	Bletch
	Round 2
29	Western Bulldogs	James Barrat	Coona Blues
30	Essendon	Christian Moraes	TENACIOUS
31	West Coast	Hamish Davies	TerryWallet
32	Port Adelaide	Angus Clarke	Pablito
33	Fremantle	Zak Johnson	WalshistheGOAT
34	St Kilda	Tom Gross	Ninja Worrier
35	Hawthorn	Harry Charleston
36	West Coast *	Malaki Champion	TerryWallet
37	Western Bulldogs	Jack Ough	Coona Blues
38	Carlton *	Ben Camporeale	Soapy V
39	Port Adelaide	Jaxon Artemis	Pablito
40	Greater Western Sydney	Lochie Jaques	bradfisher14
41	Sydney	Matt Whitlock	Wickzki
42	Geelong	Clancy Dennis	ferrisb
43	Essendon	Harry O’Farrell	TENACIOUS
44	St Kilda *	Adrian Cole	Ninja Worrier
45	Western Bulldogs	Kayle Gerreyn	Coona Blues
46	Port Adelaide	Phoenix Hargrave	Pablito
	Round 3
47	Collingwood	Ned Bowman	Bamboo Harvester
48	Essendon	Thomas Sims	TENACIOUS
49	Essendon	Pass	TENACIOUS
50	Collingwood	Sam Davidson	Bamboo Harvester
51	Greater Western Sydney	Pass	bradfisher14
52	Carlton	Pass	Soapy V
53	Geelong	Xavier Ivisic	ferrisb
54	Collingwood	Noah Mraz	Bamboo Harvester
55	Sydney	Luke Urquhart	Wickzki
56	North Melbourne	Nathaniel Sulzberger	Blue and Silver
57	Adelaide *	Tyler Welsh	GoBlues!
58	Essendon	Pass	TENACIOUS
59	Fremantle	Benny Barrett	WalshistheGOAT
60	Carlton	Pass	Soapy V
61	Carlton	Pass	Soapy V
62	Hawthorn	Kade Herbert
63	Carlton	Boyd	Soapy V
64	Greater Western Sydney	Pass	bradfisher14
65	Geelong	Pass	ferrisb
66	Hawthorn	Pass
67	North Melbourne	Pass	Blue and Silver
68	Adelaide	Pass	GoBlues!
69	Melbourne	Archer Day-Wicks	Blugazi
70	Gold Coast	Pass
71	Gold Coast	Pass
72	Brisbane	Pass	Sheephead
73	West Coast	Keighton Matofai	TerryWallet

Pre Season Draft / DFA
(fill up you senior lists)

Pick	Club	Player	Poster
1	Collingwood	Tim Membrey
2	Carlton	Ethan Phillips	Soapy V
3	Greater Western Sydney	Ben Paton	bradfisher14
4	Geelong	Jack Martin	Coona Blues
5	Brisbane	Sam Day	Sheephead
6	Collingwood	Adam Tomlinson	Bamboo Harvester
7	Carlton	Coby Burgiel	Soapy V

Rookie Draft

Pick	Club	Player	Poster
1	Richmond	Josh Dolan	Bletch
2	North Melbourne	Nash King	Blue and Silver
3	West Coast	Pass	TerryWallet
4	Adelaide	Lucas Impey	GoBlues!
5	Melbourne	Rhys Unwin	Blugazi
6	Gold Coast	Sam Durdin
7	St Kilda	Brad Crouch	Ninja Worrier
8	Essendon	Gabriel Stumpf	TENACIOUS
9	Fremantle	Noah Cumberland	WalshistheGOAT
10	Collingwood	Will Hayes	Bamboo Harvester
11	Carlton	Liam McMahon	soapy
12	Western Bulldogs	Jacob Newton	Coona Blues
13	Hawthorn	Jack Gunston
14	Greater Western Sydney	Josh Fahey	bradfisher14
15	Geelong	Lachlan Blackiston	Coona Blues
16	Port Adelaide	Charlie West	Pablito
17	Sydney	Ollie Warburton	Wickzki
18	Brisbane	Darragh Joyce	Sheephead
19	Richmond	Pass	Bletch
20	North Melbourne	Riley Bice	Blue and Silver
21	Adelaide	Pass	GoBlues!
22	Melbourne	Sam Toner	Blugazi
23	Gold Coast	Pass
24	St Kilda *	Lennox Hoffman	Ninja Worrier
25	Essendon	Waylon Davies-Motlop	TENACIOUS
26	Fremantle	Pass	WalshistheGOAT
27	Collingwood	Oleg Markov	Bamboo Harvester
28	Carlton	Asher Eastham	Soapy V
29	Western Bulldogs	Max Knobel	Coona Blues
30	Hawthorn	Pass
31	Greater Western Sydney	Lachie Keeffe	bradfisher14
32	Geelong	Marcus Herbert	Coona Blues
33	Port Adelaide		Pablito
34	Sydney	Joel Hammling	Wickzki
35	Brisbane	Darcy Craven	Sheephead
36	North Melbourne	Toby Pink	Blue and Silver
37	Essendon		TENACIOUS
38	Collingwood	Ash Johnson	Bamboo Harvester
39	Carlton *	Lucas Camporeale	Soapy V
40	Greater Western Sydney	Jacob Wehr	bradfisher14
41	North Melbourne *	River Stevens	Blue and Silver
42	Greater Western Sydney *	Logan Smith	bradfisher14
43	Essendon		TENACIOUS
44	Sydney	Aaron Francis	Wickzki

 

[Blue and Silver]

I was gonna take him instead of Hynes but I thought he’d slide through to my next pick

Had him in mind at North's pick if my key prospects were gone

On Pixel 7a using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Sheephead]

Wowee. By the time I pick (72), I’ll be left with selecting Fev to replace Joe Daniher. There won’t be much meat left on the ole sheep carcus by then.

 

[Wickzki]

Sorry guys just got out of court (giving witness testimony). Give me 5 minutes and I'll have the pick covered

 

[Blue and Silver]

Sorry guys just got out of court (giving witness testimony). Give me 5 minutes and I'll have the pick covered

You ratted on me!

On Pixel 7a using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Coona Blues]

Plenty of KPP in this range.

Harry Armstrong the “big one” mooted to be long gone. Whitlock twins, Sims, Faull?

 

[Wickzki]

The strategy discussed with my Sydney compadre was that the Swans would go one tall and one small.

Was expecting one of the Whitlock's with our second pick but can't believe Harry Armstrong is still available.

Can't look past him.

Sydney select Harry Armstrong.

Sorry again peeps. Thought I'd be long gone today. Lawyers sure do know how to add billable hours.

Bletch is up

 

[HarryFlashman]

You ratted on me!

On Pixel 7a using BigFooty.com mobile app

Nah, Wick was the representative for all of us on BigFooty for the “Gross Negligence” charges laid on Voss for subbing off Kennedy.

Thanks for stepping up Wickzki

 

[Wickzki]

Nah, Wick was the representative for all of us on BigFooty for the “Gross Negligence” charges laid on Voss for subbing off Kennedy.

Thanks for stepping up Wickzki

I got kicked out of the court room for turning it into an umpiring debate

 

[Bletch]

That'll teach me to trade away that pick 18, was sitting there waiting on Shanahan and Armstrong with 2 picks to go before mine. Tigs will be looking for a tall forward as a future Lynch replacement. Back in a few after I've had a look at JWhit, Faull & Sims.

 

[Bletch]

Pick 24: RICHMOND - Jack Whitlock - Murray Bushrangers - 200cm - Key Forward
Highly touted since U/16s, Jack has slipped a little in his draft year (as has his twin Matt). But still provides a compelling option at this stage of the draft. A key forward who can spend time in the ruck is highly desirable in modern football, and the Tigers would be looking for a player of this type. Samson may be seen as the long-term replacement for Nank in the ruck, but a viable forward/ruck is something they're lacking. Liam Fawcett and a couple of Cat-B basketballers are the only other real options. Perhaps Koschitzke, but see him more as Lynch backup.

Other options at this pick: Kicking myself that I could have had Shanahan or Armstrong, who went the two picks before this one - had I not traded out pick 22 (original pick 18), could have had my choice. Anyways, looked at Gerreyn as another forward/ruck, or Sims/Faull as pure tall forwards.

Jack Whitlock Draft Profile

Murray Bushrangers prospect Jack Whitlock is a mobile key forward with terrific reach and dexterity at 200cm.

central.rookieme.com

Next up: Pick 25 (21) GWS bradfisher14

TENACIOUS

 

[Wickzki]

Pick 24: RICHMOND - Jack Whitlock - Murray Bushrangers - 200cm - Key Forward
Highly touted since U/16s, Jack has slipped a little in his draft year (as has his twin Matt). But still provides a compelling option at this stage of the draft. A key forward who can spend time in the ruck is highly desirable in modern football, and the Tigers would be looking for a player of this type. Samson may be seen as the long-term replacement for Nank in the ruck, but a viable forward/ruck is something they're lacking. Liam Fawcett and a couple of Cat-B basketballers are the only other real options. Perhaps Koschitzke, but see him more as Lynch backup.

Other options at this pick: Kicking myself that I could have had Shanahan or Armstrong, who went the two picks before this one - had I not traded out pick 22 (original pick 18), could have had my choice. Anyways, looked at Gerreyn as another forward/ruck, or Sims/Faull as pure tall forwards.

Jack Whitlock Draft Profile

Murray Bushrangers prospect Jack Whitlock is a mobile key forward with terrific reach and dexterity at 200cm.

central.rookieme.com

Next up: Pick 25 (21) GWS bradfisher14

TENACIOUS

Really like this pick. Had Harry not slid so far this would've been the one. Think he has a really productive KPF/Ruck career. More suited to ruck long-term than many successful combo players. Wouldn't be surprised if he has a better career than Armstrong. A bit of a can't lose position you put yourself in even if you didn't get your top choices.

 

[bradfisher14]

GWS will select Alex Dodson here. I’ll do a write up later.

Wickzki is up with the swans now

 

[TerryWallet]

GWS will select Alex Dodson here. I’ll do a write up later.

Wickzki is up with the swans now

Dodson is an excellent pick imo brad. I was in 2 minds for my upcoming pick as i really like Dodson but the Eagles, who i'm picking for, already have 4 rucks and 2 other young 200cm pinch hitters.

So you solved my dilemna for me lol.

 

[Wickzki]

With another pick not too far away I won't disclose who else I've considered here but Hannaford would've been the dream but he's gone to GWS.

With that said...

Sydney welcome Tom Papley's cheeky little apprentice who will learn a ton off of him and then take over the mantle.

Sydney selects Jesse Dattoli

Dattoli plays with some swagger and confidence and has the necessary tools to take those traits into the AFL: as a midfielder/forward he takes his chances, has a natural goal sense, reads the play well and dominated in some big games this year. The best of those might have been his late-season run for the Knights, when he had two three-goal games then followed it with a 35-disposal performance against Eastern. Injury kept him from testing at the Combine.

I believe we're back to Bletch with back to back selections.

 

[Bletch]

Pick 27: RICHMOND - Jonty Faull - GWV Rebels - 195cm - Key Forward
Although I picked up Jack Whitlock with my last pick, I think the Tiges still want another marking option up forward, especially with Lynch in the latter stages of his career. I see Faull as the best available option here, he's very good overhead, and kicks goals for fun. Think he'll pair well with Whitlock, and with Balta and Gibcus up back for the foreseeable future, sets up the spine for years to come.

Also considered: Sims, Barrat.

Jonty Faull Draft Profile

GWV Rebels' Jonty Faull made up for lost time upon returning from injury in his top-age year, stamping himself as one of the top key forwards.

central.rookieme.com

TENACIOUS

 

[Bletch]

Pick 28: RICHMOND - Jasper Alger - Oakleigh Chargers - 183cm - Small Forward
With the talls out of the way, Richmond's last pick of the draft will be a small forward to replace Bolton/Graham. I see Alger as the best of the second set of smalls, behind Lombard, Kako and Berry. Has plenty of smarts, good goal sense, and excellent overhead for his size.

Jasper Alger Draft Profile

Current Oakleigh and former Gippsland prospect Jasper Alger has found a home up forward where his marking and finishing abilities shine.

central.rookieme.com

Other options: In reality, this pick, as first of the second night, probably gets traded for a future 1st. But otherwise, there's a bit of dearth of small forward options around the 20-35 mark. Looked at Dolan, Bradley, Champion (WC NGA). For 'best available', maybe Gross, Davis or Matt Whitlock.

Next up: Pick 29 (25) - Western Bulldogs Coona Blues

TENACIOUS

 

[Bletch]

Tigers are now done. Good mix I think - Smith and Lalor inside. Travaglia and Hotton outside. A couple of tall forwards in Jack Whitlock and Faull, and a small forward, Alger. Be interested to see how this compares with what the Tiges end up doing.

Nominally, there's another pick available, which I'd use in the Rookie or PSD.

 

[Wickzki]

Pick 28: RICHMOND - Jasper Alger - Oakleigh Chargers - 183cm - Small Forward
With the talls out of the way, Richmond's last pick of the draft will be a small forward to replace Bolton/Graham. I see Alger as the best of the second set of smalls, behind Lombard, Kako and Berry. Has plenty of smarts, good goal sense, and excellent overhead for his size.

Second time in a row you picked the 1B to my 1A.

Will be interesting to see how it plays out on draft night.

 

[Coona Blues]

Pick 29 - Western Bulldogs - JAMES BARRAT - 194cm 23/11/2006 - Defender/Utility

Starting to think this draft is not as deep as we thought. A bit of a rider, I am picking for a club well balanced across the park. Almost overloaded with KPP, but light on for young defenders outside of unproven Busslinger.

Barrat has performed in all parts of the ground in recent weeks. Key forward, key back/rebounder and accountable big bodied mid. Has been successful at all, but rebounding back seems his forte.

A late birthday suggests still growing and definitely still developing as a player. A bit each way here, wanted a potential centre square big body and he has some chance of developing into that role while being a quality interceptor/KPD at the next level. Young player with plenty of time to find his true calling, if he has not done so alreeady.

TENACIOUS

 

[TENACIOUS]

Pick 30 - Essendon - Christian Moraes - 183cm Midfielder / Forward

Placed top 10 in the 2km time trial with a 6:25 minutes. Is one of those players with a high ceiling.

All he needs is time to develop his inside game to become a dangerous midfielder, has many elite traits to become a star. While playing mainly outside, has the ability to play forward and take the game away from you.

Next Up: TerryWallet

 

[GoBlues!]

Pick 30 - Essendon - Christian Moraes - 183cm Midfielder / Forward

Placed top 10 in the 2km time trial with a 6:25 minutes. Is one of those players with a high ceiling.

All he needs is time to develop his inside game to become a dangerous midfielder, has many elite traits to become a star. While playing mainly outside, has the ability to play forward and take the game away from you.

Next Up: TerryWallet

Hi Tenacious, not sure how it works but did Essendon have to use up its first two picks (#28, #31) to match the bid on Kako at #12? Apologies if it’s a dumb question.

 

[TerryWallet]

Pick 31: West Coast - Hamish Davis - 190cm - Forward/Utility

Very busy and ever improving forward/utility player. He looks a bit untidy, but as Jack Dyer used to say "he gets where the ball is, and not where it aint". He's all over the forward half of the field popping up in dangerous space all the time.

Has a great tank, natural reading of the play, sticky dukes and instinct for the sticks. Finished the year with a bang starring in the WAFL seniors including a BOG 4 goaler in a winning final. Then finished his year with BOG in the Colts Premiership.

Reminds me in parts of James Leake, Mich Owens, Harry Jones(with a tank), Will Hayward

9

Will Hayward

Age

26

Ht

186cm

Wt

83kg

Pos.

Fwd

Career

Season

Last 5

D

10.6

3star

K

6.6

3star

HB

4.0

3star

M

3.4

3star

T

2.8

4star

G

1.1

4star

D

9.0

2star

K

4.3

2star

HB

4.7

3star

M

2.7

3star

T

2.7

4star

G

0.7

4star

D

9.4

3star

K

6.2

3star

HB

3.2

3star

M

2.6

3star

T

3.4

5star

G

1.4

5star

, Sam Sturt

1

Sam Sturt

Age

24

Ht

190cm

Wt

81kg

Pos.

Fwd

Career

Season

Last 5

D

7.7

2star

K

4.0

2star

HB

3.7

3star

M

2.3

2star

T

1.0

3star

G

1.3

5star

D

7.7

2star

K

4.0

1star

HB

3.7

3star

M

2.3

2star

T

1.0

2star

G

1.3

5star

D

7.7

2star

K

4.0

2star

HB

3.7

3star

M

2.3

3star

T

1.0

3star

G

1.3

5star

.....even a young Nat Fyfe.

Pablito up next for Kenny's Kids.

 

[TENACIOUS]

Hi Tenacious, not sure how it works but did Essendon have to use up its first two picks (#28, #31) to match the bid on Kako at #12? Apologies if it’s a dumb question.

Doing all this on my phone, which is tough to do.

Yep, I’ve been using the same formula for all the bids.

https://s.afl.com.au/staticfile/AFL%20Tenant/AFL/Files/Father-son-bidding-system.pdf

Pick 12 = 1,268 points - 20% = 1,014 points

Pick 28 - 677 points + Pick 31 606 points = 1,283 points

1,283 paid - 1,014 cost = 269 points over

Essendon Next Pick:
Pick 40 - 429 points + 269 points = 698 points or Pick 28

 

[GoBlues!]

Doing all this on my phone, which is tough to do.

Yep, I’ve been using the same formula for all the bids.

https://s.afl.com.au/staticfile/AFL%20Tenant/AFL/Files/Father-son-bidding-system.pdf

Pick 12 = 1,268 points - 20% = 1,014 points

Pick 28 - 677 points + Pick 31 606 points = 1,283 points

1,283 paid - 1,014 cost = 269 points over

Essendon Next Pick:
Pick 40 - 429 points + 269 points = 698 points or Pick 28

 

[Wickzki]

Anyone willing to take a trade of an F2 and 40 for one of the next few picks?