- Apr 1, 2018
- 6,483
- 8,013
- AFL Club
- Tasmania
Player Watch #5: Christian Petracca – Norm Smith Medallist, 4x All-Australian and 2x Best and Fairest (re-commits to Melbourne)
- Thread starter RandB
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Topkent
Confirmed ITK Drafting King
Stopped reading here cause it was obviously a post full of lies
melbun
Your Grace
- Jan 15, 2023
- 824
- 704
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
- Other Teams
- Giants.
Whatever happens here, it seems that Petracca has poisoned the well by his public airing of his issues.
Others will follow. Melbourne becomes a less attractive destination. Other clubs will be cautious in taking on a disruptive influence.
Others will follow. Melbourne becomes a less attractive destination. Other clubs will be cautious in taking on a disruptive influence.
Topkent
Confirmed ITK Drafting King
Lol Tracs not a disruptive influence, you'd be insane not to take him as another club. It's the opportunity of a lifetime
- Apr 18, 2005
- 31,506
- 27,462
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
Which was always going to happen
Topkent
Confirmed ITK Drafting King
Never been anything but the perfect pro until this season.
You strangely love Trac as much as Goodwin loves Oliver.
Both sides are causing issues now.
He could maybe be a bit more quiet about it, but obviously he and his family take serious issue with MFC managing his injury vs Collingwood.
Am in the medical profession myself and was a specialist in abdominal & thoracic surgery - spleens are no joke, they are extremely vascular and bleed profusely. Usually a rupture requires complete surgical removal and some degree of permanent immune system support, at a minimal a group of vaccinations post-operatively. Preserving the spleen after a laceration is a great outcome but the procedure sounds very traumatic. It's confusing to me as to why he wasn't under a general anaesthetic.
The ribs and punctured lung are also dangerous but generally heal with time and some supportive care (intercostal drainage catheter etc).
I'm shocked that MFC sent him back onto the ground in severe discomfort and it was interesting to hear a Pie player (name escapes me) say that they were concerned about him on the field and felt that they shouldn't tackle or bump him too hard out of duty of care.
Regardless it sounds like there's a lot of water to go under the bridge for Christian and his family and he just wants to leave the club. I think the public opinion of him might be different if he was quiet about it but I guess it's his style to share and talk openly which should be celebrated IMO. Just a shame that the media are making a big show of it - this is why Dusty stopped speaking to them altogether.
Just wish him the best in his recovery, physical and mental. Would be a shame not to see him return to his peak powers.
Am in the medical profession myself and was a specialist in abdominal & thoracic surgery - spleens are no joke, they are extremely vascular and bleed profusely. Usually a rupture requires complete surgical removal and some degree of permanent immune system support, at a minimal a group of vaccinations post-operatively. Preserving the spleen after a laceration is a great outcome but the procedure sounds very traumatic. It's confusing to me as to why he wasn't under a general anaesthetic.
The ribs and punctured lung are also dangerous but generally heal with time and some supportive care (intercostal drainage catheter etc).
I'm shocked that MFC sent him back onto the ground in severe discomfort and it was interesting to hear a Pie player (name escapes me) say that they were concerned about him on the field and felt that they shouldn't tackle or bump him too hard out of duty of care.
Regardless it sounds like there's a lot of water to go under the bridge for Christian and his family and he just wants to leave the club. I think the public opinion of him might be different if he was quiet about it but I guess it's his style to share and talk openly which should be celebrated IMO. Just a shame that the media are making a big show of it - this is why Dusty stopped speaking to them altogether.
Just wish him the best in his recovery, physical and mental. Would be a shame not to see him return to his peak powers.
LarryDavidNeitz
Club Legend
- Sep 9, 2020
- 2,460
- 6,248
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
At first I was sceptical about keeping Simon Goodwin but now I really feel that he deserves to be given the opportunity to show what he can do without the disruptive influences of Petracca, Kosi, ANB.
All those guys wanting to leave definitely shows we need to double down on our commitment to contest and defence, play footy the Melbourne way etc.
All those guys wanting to leave definitely shows we need to double down on our commitment to contest and defence, play footy the Melbourne way etc.
- Feb 23, 2012
- 1,168
- 2,446
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
Please rephrase incorporating the words 'DNA' and 'working incredibly hard.'
LarryDavidNeitz
Club Legend
- Sep 9, 2020
- 2,460
- 6,248
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
DNA DNA DNA DNA #demonspirit DNA Simon Goodwin working incredibly hard DNA DNA CONTEST AND DEFENCE DNA DNA working incredibly hard to trade Petracca, Kosi, ANB.
DNA DNA DNA CONTEST AND DEFENCE GOT IT LOOKING LIKE A MELBOURNE GAME contest and defence, play footy the Melbourne way etc.
A11dAtP0w3R
Dumpster Fire Diver
- Oct 18, 2013
- 95,120
- 139,678
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
- Other Teams
- Carolina Panthers
All trading and no contest and defense makes Simon a dull boy.
Goody is still digging in to the why
Bluelegs
Digging into the why
DNA on my face.
You’re following the media narrative. Nibbler bleeds red and blue and was the whipping boy at this club for many years but worked through it to be a very good player and clubman. The club letting him go home after his services shows massive maturity and respect. Kosi’s home sick but he hasn’t gone yet and Im sure, petty style he won’t. Petty ended up staying and signing by the way.
trade him to norf for pick 2 for instance? That trade would make sense. Maybe some other swap of picks as well. But would he go to norf?
While i think a lot of this is media beat up, no doubt there are some issues, but i still think it's never as bad as what the media portrays it to be, I'd be shocked if a team like North weren't getting in his ear. Yeah, not big crowds or the social media presence he's after, but Clarkson and a ton of early draft picks running around could be tempting. I mean if Butters all of a sudden was in the media headlines like this, every club regardless of size or ladder position would be on the phone to him putting in a sales pitch. Who knows, if he actually is that pissed off, then maybe one club like North might get a bite. Big cash and draft capital to get it done.
The injury scenario could have happened at any club.
Port and dogs continuously knowingly send knocked out players back on to play. That’s negligence. Tracs injury may be an afl issue? Should there be the right machinery on every afl site to assess internal injury? I don’t think the club doctors went, hey Tracs facing death get him back out there. Trac and his family could push for better injury assessment technology on site but haven’t. Save lives etc. That makes sense to me
LarryDavidNeitz
Club Legend
- Sep 9, 2020
- 2,460
- 6,248
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
Hi Kate
It could have, but it happened at MFC and they have a duty of care to him. He won't be upset with what another club may theoretically have done to him, will he?
And yes, it's absolutely negligence. Clubs should be sanctioned for this IMO.
It's probably not viable to have CT or MRI on-site at the MCG, it requires significant infrastructure adjustments due to radiation and magnetic field generation - the machines themselves cost a few million but the works required to make them safe would be just as significant. There's very little point when most major AFL grounds are within a stone's throw of very capable tertiary hospitals. Additionally these machines are designed to provide diagnostic services to society and are usually booked flat-out in emergency departments with some outpatient work also (for medicare funding/income) so I think the idea of having a machine + staffing specifically for 46 blokes, 2-3 hours a couple of times on a weekend would be horrendously out of touch with the current healthcare situation.
Ultimately the decision to send a player to hospital for assessment needs to be looked at - perhaps the AFL should have independent medical staff doing assessments with club staff?
Topkent
Confirmed ITK Drafting King
At the end of the day, commentators, fans and even opposition players were saying how ****ed he looked but because we were losing a meaningless game we rolled the dice and sent him back out despite constantly talking about how we have so much love and care for the player.
jhong
Old man yelling at clouds
Remember when they sent a clearly injured Joel Smith back on the ground in a pre season match . It isn’t just a one off with Trac , the club has form .
Think it’s been established he had no issue going back on and it is more around the lack of communication during recovery. He physically chose to go back on himself and AFL has signed off on the protocols the Dees took.
Dees then paid for all his care and gave him 10-12 weeks away from the club to recover, not sure what more they could have done. People are just fishing for issues a bit here.
If you have issues with protocols take it up with the AFL as it would apply to all clubs.
Our club ****s up a lot and does a lot of idiotic shit but you can’t blame the club on his injury.
