Opinion Adelaide Crows New Logo Discussion

[Samcro24]

Remember, the day it was leaked the club supplied Channel 9 with a higher quality version. This is really what we should be expecting..

View attachment 2153549

Has it ever been established that the club supplied this version?

It’s far more likely the c9 work experience kid knocked it up to use in the bulletin, based on the grainy image we first saw.

 

[Peter Doherty]

Has it ever been established that the club supplied this version?

It’s far more likely the c9 work experience kid knocked it up to use in the bulletin, based on the grainy image we first saw.

The tweet from Braden Ingram and his story both imply inside knowledge. Makes sense the club have given him something to use on the 6pm news, the day it was leaked.

Get a better quality version out there instead of that photo of a pc screen.

 

[Samcro24]

The tweet from Braden Ingram and his story both imply inside knowledge. Makes sense the club have given him something to use on the 6pm news, the day it was leaked.

Get a better quality version out there instead of that photo of a pc screen.

I don’t believe there will be kinks in the red and blue lines, rather it’s like a ripple from whatever fabric it’s on.

Therefore assume someone at 9 has redrawn it, kinks and all, for the purposes you describe.

It’s just too shoddily drawn to present even as a work in progress for it to be a pro job.

 

[Peter Doherty]

I don’t believe there will be kinks in the red and blue lines, rather it’s like a ripple from whatever fabric it’s on.

Therefore assume someone at 9 has redrawn it, kinks and all, for the purposes you describe.

It’s just too shoddily drawn to present even as a work in progress for it to be a pro job.

That's definitely another possibility.

 

[GreyCrow]

Remember, the day it was leaked the club supplied Channel 9 with a higher quality version. This is really what we should be expecting..

View attachment 2153549

I said early I dont mind this ie I dont hate it

Yes I get the ''straighten the Adelaide '' idea but overall I'm not not buying merch because of it

 

[AFC3000]

I don’t believe there will be kinks in the red and blue lines, rather it’s like a ripple from whatever fabric it’s on.

Therefore assume someone at 9 has redrawn it, kinks and all, for the purposes you describe.

It’s just too shoddily drawn to present even as a work in progress for it to be a pro job.

Yeah I think 9 probably did that one, would have only taken a short amount of time for someone with a little experience, certainly plenty here could have done similar.

Someone over on the graphics board did a retrace of it and probably spent a little more time on it and I thought it was better again.

I wasn't sold after the first leak and still have my concerns but perhaps if the first time we saw it was on actual merchandise and in final form, the reaction would have been better.

I can believe it may not have been the final version that leaked, but I don't at all buy that it was to get feedback or anything like that. I really think it would have been way too late to make changes with lead times for merchandise and things like that.

 

[GameofSloanes]

I swear if that abomination that was leaked ends up being it I'll be so pissed. You're telling me not one person at the club saw that and said hey fellas that looks trash? We're gonna go in a different direction

These are the same people that looked at nicks and thought let's sign him for another few years.......

 

[GameofSloanes]

It's not great and 90% of us could come up with something better in a couple of hours
Yet it's still better than the current one.....

 

[Chezzel]

I can’t remember who made this, but surely this has made its way to the club and they’ve given it some of their time, it will be embarrassing if they stick with the robo crom when there is a perfect logo replacement out there for them to use.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[GameofSloanes]

I can’t remember who made this, but surely this has made its way to the club and they’ve given it some of their time, it will be embarrassing if they stick with the robo crom when there is a perfect logo replacement out there for them to use.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

Definitely better than the leaked version

 

[SA_Great]

FWIW I did send my design in and eventually got a reply - just a vague and generic email from “the Adelaide Football Club”.

Whatever the plan is, the club is sticking to it.




Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[JPetro83]

FWIW I did send my design in and eventually got a reply - just a vague and generic email from “the Adelaide Football Club”.

Whatever the plan is, the club is sticking to it.

View attachment 2154301


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

The club always fails to listen to us, the fans

 

[StickerMan]

The club always fails to listen to us, the fans

"Customers"

 

[JPetro83]

"Customers"

I hate Nigel Smart for saying that

 

[jenny61_99]

The club always fails to listen to us, the fans

That's not true. They did consultations with the cheersquad and other supporters. Are they not fans?

 

[NTRabbit]

The people who don't like this one are in much more of a minority than the last logo, club will probably take that as enough of a win.

I don't like the last logo, I'm more or less ambivalent to the new one as pictured so far. It is at least a clean, non-derivative or evolutionary break that lets us attach the bad old logo to a decade and a half of abject failure from the club, and consign the entire period to a memory hole.

 

[George Kramer]

The people who don't like this one are in much more of a minority than the last logo, club will probably take that as enough of a win.

I don't like the last logo, I'm more or less ambivalent to the new one as pictured so far. It is at least a clean break that lets us attach the bad old logo to a decade and a half of abject failure from the club, and consign them both to a memory hole.

I don’t know, the logo was ridiculed when it was leaked, that wouldn’t have gone unnoticed and why Shutts rang into 5aa

 

[NTRabbit]

I don’t know, the logo was ridiculed when it was leaked, that wouldn’t have gone unnoticed and why Shutts rang into 5aa

Ridiculed by some, but the ridicule was neither the majority nor widespread, certainly nowhere near as widespread as the previous logo.

 

[DJ75]

FWIW I did send my design in and eventually got a reply - just a vague and generic email from “the Adelaide Football Club”.

Whatever the plan is, the club is sticking to it.

View attachment 2154301


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

This is so far ahead of the leaked version that accepting it would be such an embarrassment, the clowns running the club will never admit their failings.

 

[George Kramer]

FWIW I did send my design in and eventually got a reply - just a vague and generic email from “the Adelaide Football Club”.

Whatever the plan is, the club is sticking to it.

View attachment 2154301


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

That’s so ****ing good, ****wits.

How do I get that on a cap?

 

[1970crow]

That's not true. They did consultations with the cheersquad and other supporters. Are they not fans?

Cheersquad people are the last people you’d engage with, they’re seriously loopy.

 

[Geoffa32]

I don’t know, the logo was ridiculed when it was leaked, that wouldn’t have gone unnoticed and why Shutts rang into 5aa

Not just ridiculed, no one seemed to like it.

I can't recall any support for it at all.

 

[Chezzel]

Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[Mr MysteryGuest]

FWIW I did send my design in and eventually got a reply - just a vague and generic email from “the Adelaide Football Club”.

Whatever the plan is, the club is sticking to it.

View attachment 2154301


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

While this is improvement on the leaked image it’s still missing something imo.

The feathers need a bit more texture or something, to make it less plain looking

 

[Mostyn]

While this is improvement on the leaked image it’s still missing something imo.

The feathers need a bit more texture or something, to make it less plain looking

I reckon that might just look messy.