Review AFL Round 10 - Collingwood v GC Suns - Changes and Prematch Discussion

[Temploar]

Im hearing a trade between the 2 clubs come season's end, Caddy for Beams.

Pies gain a legit top 10 draft prospect in Caddy and free up cap space, Suns get a local gun home who will improve the team a lot.

Hmmm, i'd rather keep beams.

 

[Pie eyed]

Im hearing a trade between the 2 clubs come season's end, Caddy for Beams.

Pies gain a legit top 10 draft prospect in Caddy and free up cap space, Suns get a local gun home who will improve the team a lot.

Bucks will take Caddy outside the draft for the off season golf circuit.
Cheers and have a lovely day.

 

[Primetime Pricey]

shouldnt drop any big name players even if its the Suns. We really need to boost our percentage up.

I would give Jolly the week off however and freshen him up for Jamar next week.

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

Im hearing a trade between the 2 clubs come season's end, Caddy for Beams.

Pies gain a legit top 10 draft prospect in Caddy and free up cap space, Suns get a local gun home who will improve the team a lot.

Throw in Ablett and pay half his wages and you have a trade

 

[ksardog]

OUT- Keeffe
IN - Wood

Would place jolly as the sub, ruck wood most the game and if the game is under control just after half time maybe sub pendles giving him rest.
Would play goldsack at full back just for the next 2 games. i wouldnt bother playing either taz,brown,reid and even swan until the west coast game. give them all the time to completely recover.im sick of seeing, especially reid, coming back too early and reinjuring himself.

 

[Temploar]

OUT- Keeffe
IN - Wood

Would place jolly as the sub, ruck wood most the game and if the game is under control just after half time maybe sub pendles giving him rest.
Would play goldsack at full back just for the next 2 games. i wouldnt bother playing either taz,brown,reid and even swan until the west coast game. give them all the time to completely recover.im sick of seeing, especially reid, coming back too early and reinjuring himself.

A ruckman as a sub? LOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOL

 

[Pies_10]

Wouldnt bother tagging Ablett he'll still get 25+ touches.
I do like putting someone attacking on him to make him accountable, and no one else in there midfield worries me except maybe Swallow if he is back.

 

[Sunny_]

Wouldnt bother tagging Ablett he'll still get 25+ touches.
I do like putting someone attacking on him to make him accountable, and no one else in there midfield worries me except maybe Swallow if he is back.

Swallow, McKenzie, Matera, Bock, Harbrow and Dixon will all be unavailable for this game.

 

[Scodog10]

Im hearing a trade between the 2 clubs come season's end, Caddy for Beams.

Pies gain a legit top 10 draft prospect in Caddy and free up cap space, Suns get a local gun home who will improve the team a lot.

What a load of tripe!!!

http://www.adelaidenow.com.au/sport/afl/collingwood-midfielder-dayne-beams-wants-to-be-a-magpie-for-life/story-e6freck3-1226353392627

You'd be getting a player that would straight up be your second best player behind Ablett and we'd be getting a borderline best 22 player that only has the potential to get to Beams' level.

I mean seriously why would we be even slightly interested in that when Beams has said publicly he wants to stay.

 

[blaze036]

No way in hell collingwood will trade beams. Caddy has a small chance of becoming as a good a player as beams is already

 

[Cory]

I'm positive Beams will be at this club for a long time.

Caddy? donotwant

 

[mattys123]

I'll take Caddy, the kid could develop into a decent footballer if he was in the right system and was actually developed properly.

But to say we would trade Beams for him is hilarious, maybe Caddy and the Suns first round draft pick (almost certain to be pick one) and we may be talking.

If you want a straight trade, think more along the lines of Sinclair or Buckley, that's about what Caddy is worth IMO.

 

[TradeDraft]

I'll take Caddy, the kid could develop into a decent footballer if he was in the right system and was actually developed properly.

But to say we would trade Beams for him is hilarious, maybe Caddy and the Suns first round draft pick (almost certain to be pick one) and we may be talking.

If you want a straight trade, think more along the lines of Sinclair or Buckley, that's about what Caddy is worth IMO.

I agree I loved Caddy at Collingwood. Played well in the u-18 Champs.

Beams won't leave so if it does happen it would be 2nd Round + Player Trade

 

[Return of the Pies]

Wouldnt bother tagging Ablett he'll still get 25+ touches.
I do like putting someone attacking on him to make him accountable, and no one else in there midfield worries me except maybe Swallow if he is back.

Tag Bennell. He is their barometer, and attacking flair. Far more taggable than Ablett too.

 

[TheGreatGrundy]

I agree I loved Caddy at Collingwood. Played well in the u-18 Champs.

Beams won't leave so if it does happen it would be 2nd Round + Player Trade

When has Caddy ever been at Collingwood?

 

[Temploar]

When has Caddy ever been at Collingwood?

I think he just means "i'll love caddy at collingwood"

 

[SteeleBeams]

I think we shouldn't rush Tarrant back in. They don't really have a dominant forward that is going to tear us to bits and give them any real chance of winning! I say let Taz play another week in the VFL and bring him back along with Swan and possibly Reid on Queens Birthday.

 

[TheGreatGrundy]

I think he just means "i'll love caddy at collingwood"

Or even better 'I'd love Caddy at Collingwood'. TD already loves Ceglar, Witts and Ugle, and cannot really fit anymore into that category.

 

[TheGreatGrundy]

I think he just means "i'll love caddy at collingwood"

Or even better 'I'd love Caddy at Collingwood'. TD already loves Ceglar, Witts and Ugle, and cannot really fit anymore into that category.

 

[morgues]

I will echo the sentiments that we must seek some sort of percentage boost over this coming fortnight.

No resting anyone - the bye is so soon. Also GWS not too long after. Perfect.

The inspirational win on Saturday would surely take a bit of the pains away for our players?

All that said, I trust Bucks and the match committee

 

[Breakthelines]

I'm positive Beams will be at this club for a long time.

Caddy? donotwant

Exactly....if anything he would go and play with his brother at Brisbane.

I reckon we have more of a chance of getting his brother to collingwood than we do of Dayne leaving!

 

[Mame]

I think Wood needs game time so has to play either this week or the next. If it's not wet then two rucks against GC. If it is, Wood plays and rest Jolly.

Jolly can come back and ruck against Jamar then have another week off before the game against West Coast.

We need to develop the ruck depth and the next two rounds are a great time to do it. Unless there's a better time later in the year?

 

[TheClokes]

IN: Jackson Paine
OUT: L. Keeffe

 

[mattys123]

IN: Jackson Paine
OUT: L. Keeffe

Paine isn't even in contention, he had an ankle injury and is a chance to return to the VFL this week, but would need at least one full run before even being considered for senior selection.

Plus, aren't you replacing a defender with a forward, who plays down back?

 

[Breakthelines]

Paine isn't even in contention, he had an ankle injury and is a chance to return to the VFL this week, but would need at least one full run before even being considered for senior selection.

Plus, aren't you replacing a defender with a forward, who plays down back?

This ^

Brown and Reid are our best chance of playing this week.