Preview AFL Round 8 - Collingwood v Geelong - MCG - Friday 18/5 7.50 pm

[TradeDraft]

In: Jolly Dawes Williams Thomas

Out: Wood Brown(Injured) Buckley Yagmoor

The Game is 50-50 with both teams not in great shape and playing super well

 

[Shade]

Re: Changes and Chat for RD 9 vs Cats

I wouldnt play Dawes i thought the forward line was good without him

IN; Thomas Elliot Jolly

Out ; Yagmoor Brown Buckley

 

[TradeDraft]

Re: Changes and Chat for RD 9 vs Cats

I wouldnt play Dawes i thought the forward line was good without him

IN; Thomas Elliot Jolly

Out ; Seedsman Yagmoor Buckley

Would not bring Elliot in after a Very Quiet game in VFL Today

 

[TheGreatGrundy]

Re: Changes and Chat for RD 9 vs Cats

35 possessions and 8 clearances to Sidebottom!
34 to Swanny

 

[carnthepies19]

Re: Changes and Chat for RD 9 vs Cats

OUT: Yagmoor, Brown
IN: Thomas, Jolly

 

[Rusty22]

Re: Changes and Chat for RD 8 vs Cats

Fasolo in?

 

[Rustin Cohle]

Re: Changes and Chat for RD 8 vs Cats

I'd leave Jolly out to be honest. I want to see how Wood can go for a couple more weeks.

 

[TradeDraft]

Re: Changes and Chat for RD 8 vs Cats

Fasolo in?

I give him a Run in the VFL 1st

 

[Optimax]

Re: Changes and Chat for RD 9 vs Cats

OUT: Yagmoor, Brown
IN: Thomas, Jolly

They are my changes too, Plus wood for Dawes

Even after an ok game from wood today, jolly is still better.

Thomas for Yagmoor is a given

Dawes goes back to being cloke's foil and Leroys successor, keeffe back to the backline

 

[Temploar]

Re: Changes and Chat for RD 9 vs Cats

Did not see the game. What happen to brown. Is he ok?

Why was Dawes a late change?

 

[Pies_10]

Re: Changes and Chat for RD 9 vs Cats

Did not see the game. What happen to brown. Is he ok?

Why was Dawes a late change?

Fox Sports was saying that he may have strained his knee that he did his ACL in so he may be out for at least 6 weeks id say.

 

[Temploar]

Re: Changes and Chat for RD 9 vs Cats

Fox Sports was saying that he may have strained his knee that he did his ACL in so he may be out for at least 6 weeks id say.

No way... That's terrible. what a horror run for Nate.

 

[mattys123]

Re: Changes and Chat for RD 8 vs Cats

In: Jolly, Dawes, Thomas
Out: Wood, Brown, Seedsman/Yagmoor (not sure which one to drop)

Anyone saying Dawes won't play is kidding themselves, we may have got away with a true second forward tonight, but we won't against Scarlett, Lonergan and Taylor down back for the Cats.

Wood for Jolly will happen, which leaves who goes out for Daisy, I'd consider playing Yagmoor as the sub, he's clean by foot, and wasn't too bad tonight.

 

[Good_Old]

Re: Changes and Chat for RD 9 vs Cats

I'm in agreement with the man who doesn't believe in god.

 

[jefffff34]

Re: Changes and Chat for RD 9 vs Cats

Tonight gave me one of my favourite footballing memories when Didak ended his longest ever goalless streak (9 matches) by slotting the goal in the 3rd quarter and giving me the finger waggle.

In - Dawes, Thomas
Out - Brown, Yagmoor (did good though, just the logical call)

 

[Pie eyed]

Re: Changes and Chat for RD 9 vs Cats

No way... That's terrible. what a horror run for Nate.

Browny has tweeted thumbs up on his twitter.

 

[Adz]

Re: Changes and Chat for RD 9 vs Cats

Thomas to start the sub.

 

[JOELY]

Re: Changes and Chat for RD 8 vs Cats

Thought Buckley was pretty ordinary tonight, so I wouldn't mind squeezing him out. Not sure about taking both Yagmoor and Seedsman in either, so one of them might be in the gun over Buckley.

In - Thomas, Dawes, Jolly

Out - Wood, Yagmoor, Brown

Wouldn't mind seeing Ugle get another shot in for Seedsman but I dunno if you want to make too many changes to a winning lineup.

 

[The New Breid]

Re: Changes and Chat for RD 8 vs Cats

In - Dawes, Thomas, Fasolo
Out - Brown, Yagmoor, Seedsman

Like Yagmoor and Seedsman, but both are just so light. Not sure they'll be very effective against the big bodied cats.

Didn't mind Keeffe up forward and in the ruck. Dawes is fairly lucky Brown was injured IMO.

 

[SuperSub17]

Re: Changes and Chat for RD 8 vs Cats

I think Thomas and Jolly are just about certain ins, and Dawes probably is too. Outs are definitely Brown, and probably Yagmoor and Wood.

Didn't see the game, how was Buckley tonight? Few calls for him to be dropped but he was good last week.

 

[Good_Old]

Re: Changes and Chat for RD 8 vs Cats

In: Jolly, Thomas.

Out: Brown, Yagmoor

With Nathan out, throw Keefe back into the backline and have Wood/Jolly rotate through the ruck/forwardline.

 

[SwanBet]

Re: Changes and Chat for RD 8 vs Cats

IN: Thomas, Jolly, Dawes, Fasolo
OUT: Seedsman, Wood, Brown(inj), Yagmoor

Some really strong ins, who will all be ready. Would not be against leaving Wood in. Big game, will be sink or swim for Woody next week.

Dawes lucky to come back in for mine, but brown going down forces that change, obviously Keefe will go back to defense.

Thomas and Seedo, like for like swap, while Yagmoor was playing Half forward today should swap for Fasolo who despite being out of form, was rested this week.

Buckley keeps his place for mine, big body around contests, deserves a chance in a big game to show us what he is capable of.

A must win, players will be up for this, cannot wait to see Reid man up Hawkins, and shut him down.

 

[blaze036]

Re: Changes and Chat for RD 8 vs Cats

Out Yagmoor Seedsmen (too light) Brown Wood

In - Jolly Williams Thomas Dawes

Very tempted to play elliot, but needs some better VFL form.
Very tempted to play mooney, to scare the shit outa the old slow geelong boys
Very tempted to play faz, but best to rest his knee even if he pulls up pretty well

 

[migz]

IN: Thomas, Jolly, Dawes, Fasolo
OUT: Seedsman, Wood, Brown(inj), Yagmoor

Some really strong ins, who will all be ready. Would not be against leaving Wood in. Big game, will be sink or swim for Woody next week.

Dawes lucky to come back in for mine, but brown going down forces that change, obviously Keefe will go back to defense.

Thomas and Seedo, like for like swap, while Yagmoor was playing Half forward today should swap for Fasolo who despite being out of form, was rested this week.

Buckley keeps his place for mine, big body around contests, deserves a chance in a big game to show us what he is capable of.

A must win, players will be up for this, cannot wait to see Reid man up Hawkins, and shut him down.

Agree with these changes..

 

[smallfooty]

Re: Changes and Chat for RD 9 vs Cats

Did not see the game. What happen to brown. Is he ok?

Why was Dawes a late change?

hey TheNumber13, does this mean u wont be putting the brissy game up on the magpiecentrel site?

Just wanted to let you know as a overseas based pies fan, your site is basically my only means of watching games and that i appreciate your hard work and dedication in running the site..

cheers mate