Free Agency Ben McKay [Joins Essendon as RFA]

Does he stay or does he go?


  • Total voters
    236
  • Poll closed .

Remove this Banner Ad

Charlie Curnow has the day he plays the dogs written on his mirror every year. Reckon he averages at least 5 against us.
17 goals in 6 games, but 12 have been in the last two he's played you.
 
the only reason ben mckay would go is if north dont take steps forward this year. which we have shown to
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Yeah I think if North can continue to win games and/or remain competitive + address the Tarryn Thomas allegations seriously, there is a good chance Ben signs.
All bullshit aside. I think north are treating the TT situation appropriately. His contract adds a big layer of complexity rightly or wrongly. Paying out $1m is a big deal
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

My personal belief is that he wants/wanted to things:

1: to see a positive change in results/outlook for the future - obvious tick

2: confirmation that clarko will be his coach next year

Once the report is released and future coaching issues known, he’ll make his decision. Assuming clarko is still coaching, he’ll sign on.
 
Ben is 25, would need to believe that the club can have success in the next 5 years. No club is going to be able to pay Ben more than North can, if they are smart, they lock him away to a 5 year deal and front load it to make sure there is plenty of $ available to sign Sheezel, Wardlaw etc.
 
Not one bit concerned about Tarryn Thomas and the reputation he is giving your club? Yikes.

This has nothing to do with Ben McKay or his contract situation though. Most North fans seem to accept that TT has very likely played his final game for the club. I don't see the need to keep bringing it up on an issue or player that has nothing to do with him.
 
Ben is 25, would need to believe that the club can have success in the next 5 years. No club is going to be able to pay Ben more than North can, if they are smart, they lock him away to a 5 year deal and front load it to make sure there is plenty of $ available to sign Sheezel, Wardlaw etc.
I'd say with their young up and coming midfield and clarko at the helm, they have already surprised this year but its still a development year as next year will be. They need to go to the draft one more time and be selective with trade ins and keep McKay at all costs. In 2 years time i could see this side very much pushing for finals
 
Yeah nah.

This thread isn’t a proxy for North’s handling of Thomas or Clarkson’s involvement with the racism review.

If you want to discuss those topics there are plenty of threads on the main board for that.

Unless and until North, Ben McKay or his player manager issue some sort of public comment about a particular issue AND links it to how they handle a new contract, that crap will be regarded as trolling and will be off-limits for this thread. And that goes for all the other NM, Haw, Bris player threads too.
 
Yeah nah.

This thread isn’t a proxy for North’s handling of Thomas or Clarkson’s involvement with the racism review.

If you want to discuss those topics there are plenty of threads on the main board for that.

Unless and until North, Ben McKay or his player manager issue some sort of public comment about a particular issue AND links it to how they handle a new contract, that crap will be regarded as trolling and will be off-limits for this thread. And that goes for all the other NM, Haw, Bris player threads too.

Will head to the main board thread. It is a serious issue I think some are overlooking.
 
Ben is 25, would need to believe that the club can have success in the next 5 years. No club is going to be able to pay Ben more than North can, if they are smart, they lock him away to a 5 year deal and front load it to make sure there is plenty of $ available to sign Sheezel, Wardlaw etc.

Clarkson I strongly suspect wants to build up Norths midfield. Thats still miles off. That pick compensation Ben brings goes a long way towards doing that particularly in the likely event of a Tasmanian side leading to maybe 5 years of compromised drafts. This may be the last uncompromised draft we see for a fair while.

If North were going to blow everyone out of the water with an offer too good to refuse they perhaps could has done that by now?
 
Clarkson I strongly suspect wants to build up Norths midfield. Thats still miles off. That pick compensation Ben brings goes a long way towards doing that particularly in the likely event of a Tasmanian side leading to maybe 5 years of compromised drafts. This may be the last uncompromised draft we see for a fair while.

If North were going to blow everyone out of the water with an offer too good to refuse they perhaps could has done that by now?
Our midfield is complete
Jy, LDU, Phillips, Powell, Wardlaw all first rounders

Plus TT still around
Sheezel and sleevo other first rounders to rotate thro
 
This isn’t the North board.

Feel free to continue the delusion over there, or Bay 13.
They can also take it to the North club focus thread, where I shall quietly bring my popcorn

Big Brother Popcorn GIF by Pop TV
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Free Agency Ben McKay [Joins Essendon as RFA]

Back
Top