The best player i have ever seen is Wayne Carey is ability to win the tight big games of his own boot is unbelievable. The man was a freak. Just a cut above anyone else.
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 8 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Best player u've ever seen?
- Thread starter dees 4 life
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Banned
- #2
David Schwarz pre-knee op
his 1994 season was one for the ages
how many centre half forwards boot 9 goals in a game of footy? not many
also led the league in marks, polled well in the brownlow and had a mesmerising finals series
if he never did his knee.. well its scary to think what he would have become.
his 1994 season was one for the ages
how many centre half forwards boot 9 goals in a game of footy? not many
also led the league in marks, polled well in the brownlow and had a mesmerising finals series
if he never did his knee.. well its scary to think what he would have become.
The best Melbourne player I have seen (when performing at his best) is Travis Johnstone. I'll never forget that performance last year when he almost got us into a Preliminary Final on his own.
Overall: Wayne Carey. I have always loved him, still do. It looks like he is returning to his very best, which is great.
Overall: Wayne Carey. I have always loved him, still do. It looks like he is returning to his very best, which is great.
- Banned
- #4
John Greening
When i was a young lad and supported my Eagles as much as I do today, Geelong was our number 1 enemy. So it wasn't possible to like them at all, however, I took a big liking to Gary Ablett.
Best footballer - Gary Ablett
Best football game a person has played - Peter Matera 1992 grand final. You couldn't come closer to perfection.
Best footballer - Gary Ablett
Best football game a person has played - Peter Matera 1992 grand final. You couldn't come closer to perfection.
Brian Peake
- Jun 28, 2000
- 1,772
- 58
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Other Teams
- Dallas Cowboys, Tottenham
Gary Ablett without question. Wayne Carey, Robert Harvey and Leigh Matthews also head up my list.
cjwalkley
Premiership Player
Was: Wayne Carey
IS: Michael Voss
IS: Michael Voss
Gary Ablett. Hands down.
- Mar 19, 2002
- 7,867
- 275
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- The West Coast Eagles
Gay Ablett and Peter Matera for sure!
Garry Ablett without a doubt
Wayne Carey of course!!!
marcuz
Norm Smith Medallist
YYYYYYYYaaaaaaaaaaaaabbbbbbllllllettttttt!!!!!!
- Banned
- #15
Was: Daryl Baldock
Is: Robert Harvey
Is: Robert Harvey
Monster Joe
Team Captain
Gary Ablett. He was an absolute freak (still is, but for different reasons nowadays).
Dingster
TheBrownDog
North: Carey
Others: Ablett & D Jarman
Others: Ablett & D Jarman
- Aug 10, 2000
- 1,146
- 169
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- LFC, MVFC, Besiktas, SA Spurs
Nathan Buckley 
IMO and in my time, I would have to say that Peter Matera was possibly the best footballer I have ever seen play. The guy was an excitement machine. Exceptionally quick with extreme skills and posie personified. One of the best wingman to ever play the game.
Also have to mention Darren Jarman. What a beautiful kick!
IMO and in my time, I would have to say that Peter Matera was possibly the best footballer I have ever seen play. The guy was an excitement machine. Exceptionally quick with extreme skills and posie personified. One of the best wingman to ever play the game.
Also have to mention Darren Jarman. What a beautiful kick!
Daicos.
F
Fall Out Boy
Guest
Ablett, by a long way.
Next in line, Carey and Brereton.
Next in line, Carey and Brereton.
- Feb 14, 2002
- 17,797
- 6,860
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
- Other Teams
- Lexton, Northcote Park
As is evident by my nick, Bob Skilton. Not because there is some objective measure of 'best', but because of how much better he was than anyone else, during the extended period in which he played.
Three Brownlows in a team which usually lost is some measure.
Three Brownlows in a team which usually lost is some measure.
