Rumour Bluemour Discussion thread - The sequel - I know what SOS did last Sumner

[SafeAsMilk]

He's not lazy, not by any means. But he's 'good' not 'great' and thus not worth the big dollars for. Rather draft and develop a top draft pick over time than seek a quick fix from Mitchell.

I don't understand how you could make that call unless you know what picks we will have and who will be available at those picks. Pick 5 is overs for Mitchell and we wouldn't be stupid enough to trade it to Sydney, but if SOS determines Mitchell is a better player than whoever might be available for our 2nd rounder or whatever we get for Tuohy, then it's a no brainer.

 

[Canyouhearthedrums]

Straight swap for Tuohy would be fair. Tuohy would dominate at the SCG. Both clubs address a need (Mills goes to the midfield). I don't want Tuohy to be kicked out though. Only if he wants to leave.

I worry about Mitchell's price which will be astronomical and attitude. He is a GOOD midfielder but he's a distant fifth to Parker, Hanneberry, Jack and Kennedy. You wouldn't break the back for him.

Straight swap for Zac.... Cmon

 

[Big Sim is Back]

Makes sense. Always thought Hawthorn would struggle to get both him and JOM.

Yep, I doubt they have the pick the Swans want. JOM will cost a future first and a player. Swans will want at least a mid first for Mitchell and given that Hawks pick is 15 and the earliest they have had in years, not only is it less than what the Swans want, the Hawks would want to keep it.

Also doubt we would give up anything more than a late first for him.

 

[ESKIE]

I reckon TM would be a good get for us at the right price I'm surprised at the negativity on here, only concern would be his speed maybe, a swap with Zac is obvious...

 

[Big Sim is Back]

If we could do a swap for Tuohy and our 3rd , that's a win , we need at least half a dozen mids

This is about right I reckon. He would also have to adjust his contract price significantly.

Richmond no show with Prestia already taking their first and Saints after Steele..maybe this may change though and Steele could become a possibility for us.

 

[bad setanta]

This is about right I reckon. He would also have to adjust his contract price significantly.

Richmond no show with Prestia already taking their first and Saints after Steele..maybe this may change though and Steele could become a possibility for us.

Anyone know what Mitchell is asking? 500k again is it?

 

[LanceRomance]

If Touhy goes to sydney I will seem like an oracle to my non forum friends...

came up months ago

 

[raymagoo]

Is Mitchell what we need? Is his disposal up to standard? Does he damage oppositions? I feel we'll have to give up a bit for this bloke. Is he worth it?

I think he does!

 

[KohPhi]

If Touhy goes to sydney I will seem like an oracle to my non forum friends...

came up months ago

Not only will you seem like an oracle, bit you will also come across as someone wise, insightful and prophetic!

 

[bluefan]

I had a dream, For a moment I believed it was true

I lol'd!

 

[Sam The Doc]

I'd actually prefer to get Harry Cunningham than Mitchell, from Sydney, would cost less trade and cap wise, but would greatly bolster our midfield.

Wouldn't knock back Tommy Boy though, just don't want to give up pick #5

why you being sydney for? you're a carlton supporter.

 

[The Flying Doormat]

If Touhy goes to sydney I will seem like an oracle to my non forum friends...

came up months ago

 

[Aphrodite]

why you being sydney for? you're a carlton supporter.

Turncoat!

 

[Tambourine]

Why would mitchell leave sydney? A primership contender vs us, i just dont see it happening...unless he is just chasing the mulla.

 

[passmark]

Why would mitchell leave sydney? A primership contender vs us, i just dont see it happening...unless he is just chasing the mulla.

Sydney are buggered for salary.

He's the mid they'll miss the least. They'll barely know he's gone.

 

[Jabba73]

If Touhy goes to sydney I will seem like an oracle to my non forum friends...

came up months ago

Better than being an orifice if he doesn't ...

 

[DaVillaBlues]

why you being sydney for? you're a carlton supporter.

Its a Bay/Anti Geelong thing. A few other posters have been doing it as well. Will change my profile back after the Prelim Final..

 

[SE_Blue]

68% disposal efficiency.
We have plenty of them. He'll Sam Kerridge goes at 73%, Simon White 78% and Sam Rowe 82%

Haven't looked it up myself, but if that's his DE then that's enough for me to say no. You can probably get away with that in a team as strong as Sydney's, but you'd be exposed 5 minutes into the 1st quarter in our side.

 

[Funk]

Only if they chuck in Marsh.
Harry x3!

Could you imagine Tommy Lahiff and Harry Beitzel calling that game.

"Are you there Harry..........??

 

[Weiterbot23]

Its a Bay/Anti Geelong thing. A few other posters have been doing it as well. Will change my profile back after the Prelim Final..

It's disgusting

 

[Jabba73]

Its a Bay/Anti Geelong thing. A few other posters have been doing it as well. Will change my profile back after the Prelim Final..

Don't get it.

Did you lose a bet?

 

[FlowersByIrene]

I'd to Touhy & our 3rd (#40?) for Tom Mitchell any day of the week. Lock it in.

Sent from my SM-N910G using Tapatalk

 

[ESKIE]

I would never NEVER Use another teams avatar..

Just me

 

[Jabba73]

I would never NEVER Use another teams avatar..

Just me

Loyal-esque?

 

[ESKIE]

Loyal-esque?

Yeh Jabba-esque I have ooonly one love