Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
AFLW 2024 - Round 9 - Indigenous Round - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Exactly my thoughts also Esk!Holy **** not either of those two
Lyon ... no no
I love the CFC as much as the next person and have handed over alot of money to support the club for over 30 years. But like you,if the club bought in Hird to coach i'd be having a real hard think about what i'd be doing with my money in the future aswell.
I dispise Essendon and anything to do with that club and always have.
I really hope we dont go down that track.
Hird wont be coaching Carlton next year.
Not untouchable, certainly a long way from your description of turnover king and slow as a snail.No problem I won’t say anything about him again.He obviously is untouchable.
No more selective than only ever highlighting errors, regardless of circumstances they are created in. Don’t see the same criticism of Cripps and he makes more errors and has a worse DE than Plowman.What an extraordinarily selective take.
He actually can't play anywhere else on the ground and is shithouse in the position he plays. The occasional solid defensive game is interspersed with 120 minutes of clanger-riddled brain fades.
Looking at his overall body of work it is unfathomable that he could have been selected at #3.
Yes, because Cripps and Plowman's overall positive contributions to the team are so similar.No more selective than only ever highlighting errors, regardless of circumstances they are created in. Don’t see the same criticism of Cripps and he makes more errors and has a worse DE than Plowman.
Plowman also has a better DE this season than any of Jones, Weitering, Simpson and Marchbank.Yes, because Cripps and Plowman's overall positive contributions to the team are so similar.
True that, no-one mentioned his howler while bouncing it. It wasnt the only mistake of Crippas either.No more selective than only ever highlighting errors, regardless of circumstances they are created in. Don’t see the same criticism of Cripps and he makes more errors and has a worse DE than Plowman.
Hird wont be coaching Carlton next year.
What, you never got the invite ? I'll speak to somebody and get that sorted out for you.Can’t believe you, or anyone, is talking about that happening.
I have a better chance of being the only male invited to a Miranda Kerr/Megan Fox/Eugenie Bouchard triple love in than that happening
Crikies
#nevergoingtohappeninamillionmilleniums
That mistake came about because there was nothing to kick to up the ground. If that excuse is good enough for Cripps it should be good enough for Plowman.True that, no-one mentioned his howler while bouncing it. It wasnt the only mistake of his Crippas either.
But thats what happens in games of footy. Loads of miatakes from all players.
Okay so you actually think Plowman is a good kick "because DE"? He kicks the ball sideways to an unmarked player more than anyone in the team.Plowman also has a better DE this season than any of Jones, Weitering, Simpson and Marchbank.
At over 80% it is in the elite category.
I'd be dropping every piece of memorabilia, clothing, badges, and my and my kids membership cards at the front door of the club.I love the CFC as much as the next person and have handed over alot of money to support the club for over 30 years. But like you,if the club bought in Hird to coach i'd be having a real hard think about what i'd be doing with my money in the future aswell.
I dispise Essendon and anything to do with that club and always have.
I really hope we dont go down that track.
Yes but he’s elite ...Okay so you actually think Plowman is a good kick "because DE"? He kicks the ball sideways to an unmarked player more than anyone in the team.
He's slow, gets towelled up by smalls, towelled up by talls, is a horrendous decision maker and not a damaging kick exiting the back half. So much to work with, so glad he's an automatic selection.
Disgusting if trueHird to coach Blues next year. Lloyd connections. Bookmark it.
Not a fan of Marchbank either. Think SOS has erred badly with these two.Marchbank is a worse footballer than Plowman.
I long for the day Marchbank moves the ball quickly and then actually hits a target.
I'm a big fan of Levi's.The same people that get stuck into Casboult then go all quiet when he does alright.
Its like target shooting. We got to knock that thing out of the sky just because its there.
Actually think Marchbank can play ... but he looks like he just doesn’t give a shite ... hopefully someone in the coaching department can get the best out of him ...Not a fan of Marchbank either. Think SOS has erred badly with these two.
No, merely pointing that he is not the shit kick you are making him out to be. Seems the poor guy can’t win, it is a shit kick when it hits an unmarked target and a shit kick when it gets intercepted trying to hit a target. What are his other options?Okay so you actually think Plowman is a good kick "because DE"? He kicks the ball sideways to an unmarked player more than anyone in the team.
He's slow, gets towelled up by smalls, towelled up by talls, is a horrendous decision maker and not a damaging kick exiting the back half. So much to work with, so glad he's an automatic selection.
Needs to stop flopping around and going to ground so easily. Agree that his intensity is very much lacking at the moment, needs to start playing with urgency. His disposal is also pretty unreliable.Actually think Marchbank can play ... but he looks like he just doesn’t give a shite ... hopefully someone in the coaching department can get the best out of him ...