News Brad Crouch decision (ADL chickenshit, decline to match, receive 23)

Remove this Banner Ad

If you aren't aware of what transpired there you can't be taking any notice of the media or this board.

It was widely reported Fagan when negotiations were drawing out the 2nd year basically told Reid don't come home without the Gibbs deal in the bag.
A good leader knows when to leave it to their managers' expert knowledge. Doesn't he sound like the "big man", if that story is true.
 
It just means they weren't ever willing to match his contract under any circumstance, even in the PSD.

Makes it soooo much worse.
That part is fine, I don’t want us ending up in another situation where we may have to pay a player to leave in 2-3 years time during a rebuild as we are regretting the 5 years. Poor negotiation skills and messaging are the key issues here, absolute amateur hour.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

We also need points for Newchurch, Borlase and potentially Edwards, but absolutely should be targeting that Bulldogs pick 14 as a start.
I think it's unlikely we take all 3 even if available, certainly not if we/Luke nominates us. And most certainly not if the bids come in way earlier than we anticipate.
 
Everyone blaming the AFC have got it wrong.
You ALL know the Crows board are appointed by the VFL....they do as they are told BY the VFL.
This has turned out JUST as the VFL wanted it to. They were NEVER going to give Adelaide pick 2 ....under ANY circumstance.
The VFL have coached the club on whatt to say to its brainless supporters and i'm guessing those supporters will lap it up and turn their attention to who we get with pick 1...like good little ignorant customersn within a few days

The Stkilda contract was hyjacked and reworked by the VFL to ensure this outcone....when stuck on what to do next...our VFL appointed board follow the boses orders and bend over....as they OWN the Crows.
Your supporting a Victorian club...in a Victorian comp....for the benefit of Victorians...only the name has Adelaide in it.

Unfortunatly ive already cancelled my membership and foxtel....so all i have left is to stop watching or talking about the VFL at all.

As such....this is my final post.
Good bye and goodluck to you all.

AFL (Victoria) can EAD !!!!! ....what a shit state !!!...and a complete JOKE of a comp.

LCB out.
 
Everyone blaming the AFC have got it wrong.
You ALL know the Crows board are appointed by the VFL....they do as they are told BY the VFL.
This has turned out JUST as the VFL wanted it to. They were NEVER going to give Adelaide pick 2 ....under ANY circumstance.
The VFL have coached the club on whatt to say to its brainless supporters and i'm guessing those supporters will lap it up and turn their attention to who we get with pick 1...like good little ignorant customersn within a few days

The Stkilda contract was hyjacked and reworked by the VFL to ensure this outcone....when stuck on what to do next...our VFL appointed board follow the boses orders and bend over....as they OWN the Crows.
Your supporting a Victorian club...in a Victorian comp....for the benefit of Victorians...only the name has Adelaide in it.

Unfortunatly ive already cancelled my membership and foxtel....so all i have left is to stop watching or talking about the VFL at all.

As such....this is my final post.
Good bye and goodluck to you all.

AFL (Victoria) can EAD !!!!! ....what a sh*t state !!!...and a complete JOKE of a comp.

LCB out.

Its funny how WCE never get screwed by the AFL the same way despite being an interstate club.

The AFL organization is bias but THIS **** up is on us and us only.
 
I think it's unlikely we take all 3 even if available, certainly not if we/Luke nominates us. And most certainly not if the bids come in way earlier than we anticipate.
Well Borlase is a certainty and would be extremely surprised if we passed on Newchurch. Edwards is the one we may pass on, agree there.
 
So Kelly admitted we didn't know what the contract was until it was lodged by St. Kilda? That's gross negligence. He, and Reid, should be instantly dismissed.

To boot, St. Kilda obviously changed the contract from it's initial form as they didn't lodge it until Saturday. We let them **** us instead of getting maximum value from this situation, whish is why it's so galling to listen to Kelly tell us this was the best outcome - we can all see it's the worst and laziest result.

To mention it again (before any of the idiots who argued with me and Scorpus for the last few weeks that this wouldn't happen ask what we should have done better), Dodoro negotiated with Brisbane for weeks to ensure they got Band 1 and Brisbane didn't need to worry about Essendon matching to force a trade.

Ergo, Adrian Dodoro did better than our entire list management team.

Adrian. Dodoro.
 
That’s on the AFL for not allowing performance triggers into compo calculations, but making the club who match have to agree with them. Crouch will likely end up earning the same as Daniher and Williams next year.

Yep, it doesn't make a lot of sense.

What is to stop someone offering a really low base with a high and easily reachable trigger as the benefit is all to the club making the offer.

This FA needs some tweaking.
 
I think it's unlikely we take all 3 even if available, certainly not if we/Luke nominates us. And most certainly not if the bids come in way earlier than we anticipate.
TBH I'd be ok if we only took Borlase. The other 2 I'm not so fussed about

Really like the young Spicer? lad from south though
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Now that we are cashed up, why aren't we throwing cash at an uncontracted player. Oh sorry I forgot we are tightarses.
 
Surely we are trying to use it and other picks to get pick 9 up to 5 - they need to pull a rabbit out of the hat to salvage this debacle


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
Yes, they can restore a little faith if they play hardball with GWS & offer Atkins compo pick only. Then use the two 20ish picks to their advantage. I have faith that J Reid would achieve that as long as there's no interference from his boss(es).
 
Why look at last 8 years?

Why not last 2?

Last 3?

Last 4?

Last 5?

It is deliberately misleading to present the information the way we have.

He played 22 games last year.
Because your past injury history doesn’t just magically disappear, especially anything soft tissue related. His soft tissue injuries will follow him for his entire career, once your body has even one hammy it is way more susceptible to another. He did a hammy just this year if you’re looking for recent history.
 
I know we are all blaming Kelly here, but Reid is the list manager and this got board approval, he’s just the spokesperson for this shitshow. Kelly is not the one who would sign off on this.
I don't care. I want to see a head, on a stake. This $hit is a disgrace.

I have a rule I don't drink from Monday to Thursday. I only consume alcohol on Friday-Sunday.

Tonight is "wine and cheese night".

I actually wish I didn't care. If the Crows were a marriage I would have divorced them years ago. I am really questioning why I haven't severed this before now. You just hope for change, for things to come good. And every now and then there is the hope, just before the dagger in the heart.

The reality is the club is a rabble. Stone motherless last. And digging.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

News Brad Crouch decision (ADL chickenshit, decline to match, receive 23)

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top