- Sep 26, 2012
- 35,962
- 54,627
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Siero going nowhere
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
LIVE: Sydney v Port Adelaide - 7:40 / 7:10 Fri
Squiggle tips Swans at 57% chance -- What's your tip? -- Teams on Thurs »
LIVE: Geelong v Brisbane Lions - 7:30PM Sat
Squiggle tips Cats at 54% chance -- What's your tip? -- Teams on Thurs »
Weekly Prize - Join Any Time - Tip Prelim Finals
The Golden Ticket - MCG and Marvel Medallion Club tickets and Corporate Box tickets at the Gabba, MCG and Marvel.
AFLW 2024 - Round 4 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
injuries and form fluctuation will happen but at this stage it would be:With Sier and Taylor Adams to come back into the side who do you see as the 2 to go out? James Aish? + ?
With Sier and Taylor Adams to come back into the side who do you see as the 2 to go out? James Aish? + ?
Hes played a dozen games from the 2015 draft as a second rounder and people have questioned his professionalism.
Hes also in the VFL right now. As I said a big year increased that value but at the moment it's very reasonable. A first rounder for that? Please. You're kidding yourselves as most clubs do about their own players. It would be a second rounder at best. Possibly some token pick swaps later. And if hes uncontacted and requests a trade that would get it done.
He would make up a good young trio along with Heeney and Mills that you could play off the flanksYep hope we throw the cheque book at him at seasons end
This.
I don't disagree with the Pies fans that on talent, he`d be worth a mid teens pick.
But uncontacted + assuming he doesn't cement a spot in the 22 (which is obviously what would have to happen for him to consider leaving) = value dips a lot.
Pies would hold no trump cards if he chose to leave for greater opportunity.
Unfortunately, that's the nature of trading, when players aren't playing AFL and his likely 'current' value.If he was to see limited game time in 2019 and not really find himself in the team he is worth a mid second round at absolute best.
Unfortunately, that's the nature of trading, when players aren't playing AFL and his likely 'current' value.
However, if he plays, 15+ AFL games at the standard he did last year, a mid to late teens pick would not be unreasonable.
15+ game is best 18 in the team , i doubt he want to walk out .Unfortunately, that's the nature of trading, when players aren't playing AFL and his likely 'current' value.
However, if he plays, 15+ AFL games at the standard he did last year, a mid to late teens pick would not be unreasonable.
Every club should have a look. He might not make it because there are rumours that he lacks commitment and his two big weaknesses are a bad combination - midfield only at this stage and lacks endurance. But if he knuckles down, he's got Patrick Cripps potential. Power, speed, agility, beautiful hands, awareness, peripheral vision, creativity. God I hope he stays and becomes motivated.He is not worth a first rounder as it stands. Seems he’s currently depth in a very deep Pies midfield. I’m sure he’ll find his way into the side at some point this year.
Essendon should be having a look.
Every club should have a look. He might not make it because there are rumours that he lacks commitment and his two big weaknesses are a bad combination - midfield only at this stage and lacks endurance. But if he knuckles down, he's got Patrick Cripps potential. Power, speed, agility, beautiful hands, awareness, peripheral vision, creativity. God I hope he stays and becomes motivated.
Commitment seems to be his issue at the moment. Someone on our board mentioned that he recently broke up with his long term girlfriend, which may have effected his headspace and form. Once he gets back in to the right frame of mind I’d expect that he’ll be back in the 22, because at his best he’s easily ahead of several players despite our midfield depth.He is not worth a first rounder as it stands. Seems he’s currently depth in a very deep Pies midfield. I’m sure he’ll find his way into the side at some point this year.
Essendon should be having a look.
On talent I think he is worth a late first imo but like with Witts the pies will have a hard time getting maximum value in a trade. I agree he would be a perfect fit for the Bombers and is ready to contribute right awayHe is not worth a first rounder as it stands. Seems he’s currently depth in a very deep Pies midfield. I’m sure he’ll find his way into the side at some point this year.
Essendon should be having a look.
If he plays some good footy at AFL level then he’ll possibly attract a late first. However if he can’t crack into the side he’s could get a Eitts type deal.On talent I think he is worth a late first imo but like with Witts the pies will have a hard time getting maximum value in a trade. I agree he would be a perfect fit for the Bombers and is ready to contribute right away
He is not worth a first rounder as it stands. Seems he’s currently depth in a very deep Pies midfield. I’m sure he’ll find his way into the side at some point this year.
Essendon should be having a look.
Lol.He's played just over 10 games heading into his fourth year - As it stands now he worth pick 40+.
He's played just over 10 games heading into his fourth year - As it stands now he worth pick 40+.
If he doesn't grab a regular spot in the seniors with the Pies this season you'd think a pick in the 30s would be the best the Pies could hope for.With the Hawks lack of inside midfield depth I hope they enquire about him. What’s his market value if he requested a trade. A pick in the 30s?