Quicky
Brownlow Medallist
- May 27, 2008
- 25,933
- 32,080
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- Socceroos, Melbourne Victory
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 9 - Indigenous Round - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Brendan Fevola Trade Thread
- Thread starter daics35
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
Magpie Ink
All Australian
Veteran
Collingwood - Beau McCreery Player Sponsor 2023
Collingwood - Caleb Poulter Player Sponsor 2022
Collingwood - Josh Daicos Player Sponsor 2021
Collingwood - Tyler Brown Player Sponsor 2020
Collingwood Magpies - Brayden Sier 2019 Player Sponsor
Collingwood Magpies AFLW - Sarah Rowe Player Sponsor 2019
Collingwood - Jaidyn Stephenson Player Sponsor 2018
Re: Blues to trade Fevola
There's no way the Blues would allow a trade that saw Fev at the Pies, could you imagine the backlash from their members...
It will get built up in the media like every other big name that is going to be traded to Collingwood, happens every year..
Now if I was a betting man I'd have my money on Fev going to the Bulldogs for pick 15 and Everitt.
There's no way the Blues would allow a trade that saw Fev at the Pies, could you imagine the backlash from their members...
It will get built up in the media like every other big name that is going to be traded to Collingwood, happens every year..
Now if I was a betting man I'd have my money on Fev going to the Bulldogs for pick 15 and Everitt.
bombre-boy
Premium Gold
Veteran
Closest to the Pin
Essendon Upset Victory Tipping
Essendon Upset Victory Tipping
Essendon Player Sponsor 2020 - Orazio Fantasia, Anthony McDonald Tipungwuti, Shaun McKernan
Essendon Player Sponsor 2019 - Orazio Fantasia, Anthony McDonald Tipungwuti, Shaun McKernan
Essendon Player Sponsor 2018 - Colyer, Fantasia, McDonald-Tipungwuti and McKernan
Essendon Player Sponsor 2017
Re: Fev trade
Would love for you guys to snag Fev.....just seeing the carltank supporters bleeding would be worth it...
Would love for you guys to snag Fev.....just seeing the carltank supporters bleeding would be worth it...
Zahki
Norm Smith Medallist
- Aug 13, 2009
- 5,548
- 529
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Re: Fev trade
Bottom line, we are almost in position to win a flag, Fev would open the window well and truely for the next 2-3 years, if people are serious about wanting to win the premiership then it's time to stop holding on to players that we 'hope come good' and get a proven game winner.
Bottom line, we are almost in position to win a flag, Fev would open the window well and truely for the next 2-3 years, if people are serious about wanting to win the premiership then it's time to stop holding on to players that we 'hope come good' and get a proven game winner.
Re: Fev trade
WE MUST LAND THIS FISH.
yes he is a risk, but if anyone is capable of setting him straigh it's eddie, mick and now bucks. they will take whatever they can get for him, as they are not in a great bargaining position. i will happilly give them pick 14 and dawes. that will get the job done.
with fev in our team next year, dawes will have lmited opportunity, hence the trade. he has good currency and pick 14 is also good value for the blues. they can get to KPP (dawes + panos, talia, etc) to stregthen their stocks.
WE MUST LAND THIS FISH.
yes he is a risk, but if anyone is capable of setting him straigh it's eddie, mick and now bucks. they will take whatever they can get for him, as they are not in a great bargaining position. i will happilly give them pick 14 and dawes. that will get the job done.
with fev in our team next year, dawes will have lmited opportunity, hence the trade. he has good currency and pick 14 is also good value for the blues. they can get to KPP (dawes + panos, talia, etc) to stregthen their stocks.
- Nov 28, 2005
- 6,234
- 121
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- Australia
Re: Fev trade
There is no way that either of these two should be offered. Collingwood would lose the deal, and they won't get involved in that case. Clollingwood is aware that Cloke is 22 and a Copeland Trophy winner that went through a difficult pre-season following the New Years incident and the death that followed to his attacker, as well as the shots fired into the family house when he was home alone. His mind was not on footy when it should have been. The club is also aware that Medhurst badly injured his ankle early in the season. Both surely will be kept,
I think pick #14 and Dawes or Goldsack is what the club should be thinking.
There is no way that any team will offer a top-10 pick for Fevola. The lower teams are going to use those picks in the last un-compromised draft.
Magpie Ink
All Australian
Veteran
Collingwood - Beau McCreery Player Sponsor 2023
Collingwood - Caleb Poulter Player Sponsor 2022
Collingwood - Josh Daicos Player Sponsor 2021
Collingwood - Tyler Brown Player Sponsor 2020
Collingwood Magpies - Brayden Sier 2019 Player Sponsor
Collingwood Magpies AFLW - Sarah Rowe Player Sponsor 2019
Collingwood - Jaidyn Stephenson Player Sponsor 2018
Re: Blues to trade Fevola
One more point...
The Blues are in a win/win position..
They'll only trade Fev if they get a offer they can't refuse (Win)
If they don't trade him he'll get an almighty wake up call and they (the club) will look like they haven't turned a blind eye again (Win)
One more point...
The Blues are in a win/win position..
They'll only trade Fev if they get a offer they can't refuse (Win)
If they don't trade him he'll get an almighty wake up call and they (the club) will look like they haven't turned a blind eye again (Win)
Re: Fev trade
Lets be honest he would be a great great great fit for the Pies and get you very close to a flag but you are not getting him for Pick 14 and a player such as Dawes, Cox, Wellingham.
Pick 14 and Cloke would be tempting for the Blue seeing the will need a Forward replacement.
Lets be honest he would be a great great great fit for the Pies and get you very close to a flag but you are not getting him for Pick 14 and a player such as Dawes, Cox, Wellingham.
Pick 14 and Cloke would be tempting for the Blue seeing the will need a Forward replacement.
Re: Fev trade
Yep, a lot of people are suggesting pick 14 + Dawes but i doubt that would be enough. if their game is to offer fevola and see what deal comes up, and keep him if they're not happy, it will take more. if they're dead set on getting rid of him, and fevola wants us, and we can afford the cash, it might be enough.
Yep, a lot of people are suggesting pick 14 + Dawes but i doubt that would be enough. if their game is to offer fevola and see what deal comes up, and keep him if they're not happy, it will take more. if they're dead set on getting rid of him, and fevola wants us, and we can afford the cash, it might be enough.
Re: Fev trade
The Carlton midfield is a myth.
Carlton hold the cards, you have to satisfy them, or someone else will.
He will cost more than 14 and Dawes who by no means is a certainty to make the grade.
The Carlton midfield is a myth.
Carlton hold the cards, you have to satisfy them, or someone else will.
He will cost more than 14 and Dawes who by no means is a certainty to make the grade.
- Sep 25, 2006
- 18,362
- 14,618
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- FC Barcelona, Liverpool, FC Bayern
Re: Fev trade
That's what I was thinking.
I'd rather offer something like that on top of our first pick. Nothing more. We just aren't in a position to be able to trade Reid/Brown/Dawes/Davis etc.
That's what I was thinking.
I'd rather offer something like that on top of our first pick. Nothing more. We just aren't in a position to be able to trade Reid/Brown/Dawes/Davis etc.
Bloben
Premiership Player
Re: Blues to trade Fevola
I think IF Carlton decide not to trade Fev then it would scare the shit out of him but I think that he will be gone. He has lost his respect from captain and coach and today's statement is the the nail in his coffin.
The only thing that would save him would be no good offers however that is unlikely.
I actually see Carlton having quite a poor bargaining position here. The team has to either agree to pay $700k per year for him or they will need to pay part of his contract for the next few years. That instantly takes out a number of possible teams.
They also have a high performing player who is seen as risky for what he does off the footy field. Some clubs will turn away from him for this reason alone.
Plus if it is true that Fev has nominated his teams then it puts Carlton in exactly the same position that West Coast was in once Judd had nominated Carlton.
The Blues are far from being in a win:win situation... they are actually ******
I think IF Carlton decide not to trade Fev then it would scare the shit out of him but I think that he will be gone. He has lost his respect from captain and coach and today's statement is the the nail in his coffin.
The only thing that would save him would be no good offers however that is unlikely.
I actually see Carlton having quite a poor bargaining position here. The team has to either agree to pay $700k per year for him or they will need to pay part of his contract for the next few years. That instantly takes out a number of possible teams.
They also have a high performing player who is seen as risky for what he does off the footy field. Some clubs will turn away from him for this reason alone.
Plus if it is true that Fev has nominated his teams then it puts Carlton in exactly the same position that West Coast was in once Judd had nominated Carlton.
The Blues are far from being in a win:win situation... they are actually ******
Re: Fev trade
I'd love Fev at the Pies but one thing to consider is this. Fev has a maximum of 4 years to give us a chance at winning a flag. Would JA be experienced and strong enough to take over at FF once he is gone? hopefully.
Maybe we can do a deal and still keep pick 14 to get another Key Forward (eg Panos, Griffen or even Thalia or a good mid).
How about a combination of Dawes (will be getting limited opportunity with Fev in the forward line) Rusling, Fraser, Cox, L Brown, pick 30 and one of Goldsack/Toovey?
Could be a shot if we plan on paying the full contract for the 2 years.
Wouldn't let them touch Cloke, JA, N Brown or Reid.
I'd love Fev at the Pies but one thing to consider is this. Fev has a maximum of 4 years to give us a chance at winning a flag. Would JA be experienced and strong enough to take over at FF once he is gone? hopefully.
Maybe we can do a deal and still keep pick 14 to get another Key Forward (eg Panos, Griffen or even Thalia or a good mid).
How about a combination of Dawes (will be getting limited opportunity with Fev in the forward line) Rusling, Fraser, Cox, L Brown, pick 30 and one of Goldsack/Toovey?
Could be a shot if we plan on paying the full contract for the 2 years.
Wouldn't let them touch Cloke, JA, N Brown or Reid.
Re: Blues to trade Fevola
I was skeptical at first, but putting it all together, Fev stays away from the B&F, Fev stays away from the end of year trip, a statement is released.
He is in serious trouble.
I was skeptical at first, but putting it all together, Fev stays away from the B&F, Fev stays away from the end of year trip, a statement is released.
He is in serious trouble.
- Sep 25, 2006
- 18,362
- 14,618
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- FC Barcelona, Liverpool, FC Bayern
Re: Fev trade
Any deal for Fev would have to involve pick 14 IMO.
However, we will NOT be offering up players like Reid and Brown.
Malthouse and the club are on record saying they will not butcher the list and want to build and keep it together.
Dawes is an interesting one.
The maximum I would be offering is pick 14 + Dawes.
Even then, Dawes is rated highly by the club too.
Any deal for Fev would have to involve pick 14 IMO.
However, we will NOT be offering up players like Reid and Brown.
Malthouse and the club are on record saying they will not butcher the list and want to build and keep it together.
Dawes is an interesting one.
The maximum I would be offering is pick 14 + Dawes.
Even then, Dawes is rated highly by the club too.
Re: Fev trade
To get the deal done, give Carltank Pick 14 - Nathan Brown (who was a Carltank fan) - and the choice of either Jack Anthony or Chris Dawes. And if that didn't get Carltank's juices going, make it Pick 14-Browny-Cloke to get the deal done.
Ben Reid seems to be finding his feet at CHB in the VFL and could replace N. Brown.
Fev would out goal either of Jack,Chris or Trav in any given year.
To get the deal done, give Carltank Pick 14 - Nathan Brown (who was a Carltank fan) - and the choice of either Jack Anthony or Chris Dawes. And if that didn't get Carltank's juices going, make it Pick 14-Browny-Cloke to get the deal done.
Ben Reid seems to be finding his feet at CHB in the VFL and could replace N. Brown.
Fev would out goal either of Jack,Chris or Trav in any given year.
mattys123
Hall of Famer
- Mar 24, 2008
- 31,426
- 20,284
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- LAK, NUFC, SAS, SFGiants, 49ers,
Re: Fev trade
So, let me sum this up, to get Fev, we pay him 700,000 a year, give Carlton pick 14 (probably a gun KPP), Nathan Brown (a definite KPP for 8-10 years) and Jack Anthony (50 goals this year) or Chris Dawes (4 games).
Hmm, if that's what Carlton asks, the answer is NO.
So, let me sum this up, to get Fev, we pay him 700,000 a year, give Carlton pick 14 (probably a gun KPP), Nathan Brown (a definite KPP for 8-10 years) and Jack Anthony (50 goals this year) or Chris Dawes (4 games).
Hmm, if that's what Carlton asks, the answer is NO.
- Nov 28, 2005
- 6,234
- 121
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- Australia
Re: Fev trade
I disagree. I think Carlton have decided that his career there is over. I think that pick #14 and Dawes could get the trade done because they don't want him. If they wanted him, and if he was three years yonger, then Cloke could be possible, but neither is the case.
There is no way that Cloke, the 22 year old 2007 Copeland Trophy winner will be offered. Thanks for your input though!
I don't think so. Carlton don't want him. They have for all intents and purposes sacked him. I don't think two players will be involved, and I don't think they would be interested in Wellingham because they don't need a midfielder.
Maybe, but I don't think it's a priority for them. They want a forward or a defender.
I don't see it like that. I believe that Chris Judd has stated that it is Fev or him. There are no conspiracy theories as some have suggested about this being done just to scare him. His career there is over and Carlton want to make that happen. Because of his age, I'm sure that pick #14 and Dawes or Goldsack is a possibility.
It would under normal circumstances, but I believe that Carlton just want to move him on. He has been sacked, but they must try and trade for him first. I don't think he will be kept if a trade cannot be reached. Dawes and pick #14 could very well get the trade done.
goalpie
Premiership Player
Re: Fev trade
Not sure mm and em would take him, would come across as a hypocrites.:diamond:
Not sure mm and em would take him, would come across as a hypocrites.:diamond:
- Sep 25, 2006
- 18,362
- 14,618
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- FC Barcelona, Liverpool, FC Bayern
Re: Fev trade
Pick 14 is a pick without a face.
Could be anyone or anything.
I rate Dawes as much as anybody which is why I am sceptical about offering him up in any trade, particularly as we need a few more KPP.
However, pick 14 is a minimum of satisfying the requirements of Carlton to get the best FF in the competition, currently in his prime.
Pick 14 is a pick without a face.
Could be anyone or anything.
I rate Dawes as much as anybody which is why I am sceptical about offering him up in any trade, particularly as we need a few more KPP.
However, pick 14 is a minimum of satisfying the requirements of Carlton to get the best FF in the competition, currently in his prime.
Optimax
Brownlow Medallist
Re: Fev trade
Pick 14 + Harry for Fev + Carlton 2nd round pick
Pick 14 + Harry for Fev + Carlton 2nd round pick
Re: Fev trade
If Collingwood could hand pick any player in the game to play for them and get them as close to a flag a possible Fev would be in the top 3 or 4.
How do you feel when its the last day of trade week and your offers of Dawes and 14 have been rejected. Do you up your bid or just say forget about it he isnt that important anyway.
Carlton arent giving a guy who will kick 250 odd goals in the next 3 years away for cheap.
This is the Pies big chance to land a gun FF and really go for a flag.
So my question again is do you up your bid and what is it?
If Collingwood could hand pick any player in the game to play for them and get them as close to a flag a possible Fev would be in the top 3 or 4.
How do you feel when its the last day of trade week and your offers of Dawes and 14 have been rejected. Do you up your bid or just say forget about it he isnt that important anyway.
Carlton arent giving a guy who will kick 250 odd goals in the next 3 years away for cheap.
This is the Pies big chance to land a gun FF and really go for a flag.
So my question again is do you up your bid and what is it?
Optimax
Brownlow Medallist
Re: Fev trade
Simple
West coast have openly stated they want a gun small forward, we have these on in particular davis
Carlton will want a top 10 pick west coast has this
So
west coast get davis + our second rounder
Carlton get WC's first rounder+ pick 14+dawes
Colling get Fevola+carlton's second rounder
Carlton get a developing forward and 2 first round draft picks
West Coast get davis and another second rounder
Collingwood get Fevola and first pick Mid second round
We sell alot, we gain alot, carlton same, west coast same
Simple
West coast have openly stated they want a gun small forward, we have these on in particular davis
Carlton will want a top 10 pick west coast has this
So
west coast get davis + our second rounder
Carlton get WC's first rounder+ pick 14+dawes
Colling get Fevola+carlton's second rounder
Carlton get a developing forward and 2 first round draft picks
West Coast get davis and another second rounder
Collingwood get Fevola and first pick Mid second round
We sell alot, we gain alot, carlton same, west coast same
- Status
