Agree.
My point was the previous hawthorn supporter demanded suspension for grundy who whacked an opponent into the turf.
Thats fine but to be consistent cant drop off if own clubs players in coming weeks do same
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Brodie Grundy tackle on Ben Brown
- Thread starter BG32
- Start date
-
- Tags
- #tackle #armspinned
- Tagged users None
My point was the previous hawthorn supporter demanded suspension for grundy who whacked an opponent into the turf.
Thats fine but to be consistent cant drop off if own clubs players in coming weeks do same
Just saw the video on AFL.com.
Just like Koby Stevens earlier in the year.. Grundy tackled him the way every footballer has been taught from a young age. Take the player legally with their arms pinned, so they can't dispose of the ball, and take them down sideways.
I'm a St.Kilda supporter so I class myself as objective in this incident. Grundy did everything right.. everything. He also got the free kick from the umpire (like Stevens!). He dragged Brown to the left and unfortunately Brown flayed around and squirmed during the tackle in a position that resulted in him falling face/temple down instead of what would have been arm or shoulder first.
If Grundy releases the arms just before he hits the turf, Brown could feasibly dispose of the ball correctly.
So I ask you, what is he supposed to do?! The AFL can't keep suspending players who do the right thing, surely? Or are they just covering their tracks legally by admitting they have no other choice but to keep suspending players based on the outcome of the health of the player?
RMan
Just like Koby Stevens earlier in the year.. Grundy tackled him the way every footballer has been taught from a young age. Take the player legally with their arms pinned, so they can't dispose of the ball, and take them down sideways.
I'm a St.Kilda supporter so I class myself as objective in this incident. Grundy did everything right.. everything. He also got the free kick from the umpire (like Stevens!). He dragged Brown to the left and unfortunately Brown flayed around and squirmed during the tackle in a position that resulted in him falling face/temple down instead of what would have been arm or shoulder first.
If Grundy releases the arms just before he hits the turf, Brown could feasibly dispose of the ball correctly.
So I ask you, what is he supposed to do?! The AFL can't keep suspending players who do the right thing, surely? Or are they just covering their tracks legally by admitting they have no other choice but to keep suspending players based on the outcome of the health of the player?
RMan
Gone - have to protect the head according to AFL.
Sydney_hawk
Rookie
- Jul 25, 2017
- 45
- 64
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
- Banned
- #30
I'm sure you said this last weekend aye
Upgrayedd
A Vote for Clive is a Vote for Justice
Should get off. the issue was Dangerfield tackled and drove a players head to the ground without the ball, Grundy's tackle was great just unfortunate that Brown got smashed
- Banned
- #32
If he gets off it's because he plays for Collingwood and the AFL are scared of Eddie.
- Banned
- #34
Brown got suspended?
Pinning both arms is the perfect tackle when the head of the person being tackled doesn't hit the ground.
Players generally don't go headbutting the turf, so it's reasonable to assume it's the tackler gaining ascendancy in the tackle that causes the injury(or potential for injury). It's the tackler's responsibility to perform the tackle in a way that their head does not hit the deck. It happens many times a game. Learn the technique.
Players generally don't go headbutting the turf, so it's reasonable to assume it's the tackler gaining ascendancy in the tackle that causes the injury(or potential for injury). It's the tackler's responsibility to perform the tackle in a way that their head does not hit the deck. It happens many times a game. Learn the technique.
Art Vandelay_
TheBrownDog
- Oct 28, 2012
- 107,718
- 149,530
- AFL Club
- Geelong
- Other Teams
- Bushrangers - Tottenham
Fair comment. full of shit when a player from a certain club (ours *wink*) is up on a charge, Bartel will get him off is often muttered. Fair question imo.
go you pups summed it up. This shall be interesting, gets 1 week or less and Cook should be on the phone to Gillon demanding answers. This should be 2 minimum based on last weeks soft suspension where Kreuzer was near BOG today.
Not good for Brown seeing him off to hospital.
So Hawthorn supporters cant have an opinion now....even if others are of the same opinion.
All we ask for is consistency and the AFL to get their shite together
Upgrayedd
A Vote for Clive is a Vote for Justice
Should for that haircut
RanceyPantz
Team Captain
- May 26, 2017
- 350
- 886
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Banned
- #39
The grounds are too firm which results in more concussions from tackles. The drainage of these grounds removes the soft layer in the soil that behaves a bit like carpet underlay or that stuff at play grounds which prevents concussion.
Both have been slam tackles, not sling tackles.
Both rugby codes penalise the type of tackle that Dangerfield was suspended for. The problem is that in Aussie rules you are penalised for landing in the back, meaning it actually creates more danger for the head as you're trying to land in the side (more range of motion in whiplash, sides of the head are more vulnerable on impact than front and back)
Change the rules re the back - it's there to protect players on the ground contesting the ball, rather than fairly soft and incidental contact, and we will see the dangerous tackles subside
Just want consistency.
Brown's been taken to hospital. We know the MRP takes the impact to the tackled player into serious consideration.
Luv_our_club
Norm Smith Medallist
- Feb 14, 2017
- 6,883
- 12,959
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
This post. End of discussion.
Brown's been taken to hospital which can't be good for Grundy.
fpm84
Brownlow Medallist
Grundy wasn't as bad?
Do you even watch football? Kreuzer's shoulder made contact with the ground before his head did. Grundy slammed Brown head first into the ground.
Brown off to hospital means impact will be graded as severe = 3 weeks down to 2.
You think Danger's tackle was worse? He at least tried to roll him over. Grundy just plowed Brown straight into the turf.
Sheesh you Collingwood fans are something.
You see Danger tackle worse than Grundy
Chocoholic
Senior List
- Nov 24, 2016
- 261
- 190
- AFL Club
- Geelong
The ball was gone cause Kruzer threw it out.
Many great tackles occur without concussion. Obviously doing something wrong if you land a player head 1st into the ground, especially Ethiad.
