Brownlow Medal 2009 (Part 1)

[Athomas]

Re: Brownlow Medal

My Brownlow Medal - After Round 12


1.Leigh Montagna (19)
2.Gary Ablett (18)
3.Chris Judd (15)
4.Adam Goodes (12)
5.Brendan Goddard, Adam Simpson, Sam Mitchell (11)
6.Jobe Watson, Dane Swan, Scott Pendlebury, Steve Johnson, Joel Selwood, Nick Riewoldt, (10)
7.Bernie Vince, Travis Boak, Nick Dal Santo, Lenny Hayes, Lindsay Gilbee, Jimmy Bartel, (9)
8.Scott Thompson, Adam Cooney, (8)
9.Tyson Edwards, Kade Simpson, Jason Winderlich, Brent Stanton, Andrew Swallow, Paul Chapman, Paul Duffield, Jonathan Brown, Matthew Boyd, (7)
10.Brendan Fevola, Shaun Higgins, Jude Bolton, Warren Tredrea, Brad Sewell, Leon Davis, Alan Didak, Luke Power, (6)

I was going to say excellent! But there is one major problem being there is no way Adam Simpson has 11 votes.

 

[Effes]

Re: Brownlow Medal

I've been criticising and haven't yet offered my votes so here are mine to round 11 (9 votes or more)

Hayes 15
S Johnson 14
Ablett 14
Mitchell 12
Judd 11
Selwood 11
Montagna 11
Davis 10
Edwards 9
Murphy 9
Chapman 9
Dal Santo 9
Goddard 9
Goodes 9
Tredrea 9

 

[eaglespremiers]

Re: Brownlow Medal

Here's my take on Judd v Ablett.
After Round 12:
Judd - 18 votes
Ablett - 12 votes (blame Joel Selwood primarily for this)
Smoky - Ryan Griffen - 10 votes.

 

[Little Jerry]

Re: Brownlow Medal

I was going to say excellent! But there is one major problem being there is no way Adam Simpson has 11 votes.

Some games i've had to rely on stats because i've missed them so i will be giving some players a lot of votes when they really shouldn't. Such as i'm not sure if Boak has played well enough to have 9 votes already because i have missed his games. Same for Simpson.

 

[Little Jerry]

Re: Brownlow Medal

Update for Round 13

Vince, Swan, Goddard, Ablett and Mitchell all big movers this week in the tally.
1.[FONT=&quot] [/FONT]Gary Ablett (21)
2.[FONT=&quot] [/FONT]Leigh Montagna (19)
3.[FONT=&quot] [/FONT]Chris Judd (15)
4.[FONT=&quot] [/FONT]Sam Mitchell, Brendan Goddard, (14)
5.[FONT=&quot] [/FONT]Dane Swan (13)
6.[FONT=&quot] [/FONT]Adam Goodes, Bernie Vince (12)
7.[FONT=&quot] [/FONT]Adam Simpson, (11)
8.[FONT=&quot] [/FONT]Jobe Watson, Scott Pendlebury, Steve Johnson, Joel Selwood, Nick Riewoldt,Lenny Hayes
(10)
9.[FONT=&quot] [/FONT]Travis Boak, Nick Dal Santo, , Lindsay Gilbee, Jimmy Bartel, Paul Chapman (9)
10.[FONT=&quot] [/FONT]Scott Thompson, Adam Cooney, Alan Didak, Simon Black,Luke Power,Jonathan Brown,Brad Sewell, Andrew Swallow (8)

 

[TubbsFarquhar]

Re: Brownlow Medal

20. Ablett

16. Dal Santo

15. Hayes

14. J. Selwood, Montagna

12. Judd, J. Brown

11. Pendlebury, Didak (interesting one but this is for three B.O.G's in a row plus 2 against the Dees in round 2)

10. Watson, Goddard

9. Tredrea, M. Murphy, Chapman, Black, Swan

8: Haselby, Higgins, Goodes, N. Riewoldt, Cooney, Gilbee, Pavlich, Power, Mitchell, Vince

7. R. Shaw, S. Johnson, Sewell, Thompson, Bartel, Boyd

6. Kerr, Ar. Davey, Winderlich, J. Mcveigh, Deledio, Fevola, Doughty

5. Gibbs, Akermanis, Koschitzke, Knights, T. Edwards

4. Lockyer, Roughead, Johnstone, A. Selwood, Jackson, Ray, Stanton, Lloyd, Brogan, Waite, Kirk, Sylvia, Simpson, D. Cox, Davis, Ryder, B. Johnson, LeCras, Porplyzia, Monfries

3. Wiggins, Harding, P. Burgoyne, C. Bolton, Griffen, Adcock, Dangerfield, Harvey, J. Riewoldt, Goodwin, Salopek, Sandilands, C. Morton, Bradshaw, Sherman, Hale, Rich, Giansiricusa, Duffield, Cassisi, K. Cornes, Dick, Cross, M. Morton, Tambling, Byrnes, Prismall, Corey, A. Welsh, Lovett

2. McLeod, Green, Lake, Patfull, Guerra, O’Brien, Chaplin, Richardson, Ziebell, Mundy, Mooney, S. Hill, Wells, Bateman, Kelly, S. Tuck, Boak, Pearce, Lewis, J. Hill, Tippett, Varcoe, O'Keefe, Priddis

1. Gilbert, McIntosh, Fisher, Fraser, Jolly, D. Fletcher, Hurn, Reilly, L. Hansen, Gram, McPhee, Moss, Bruce, McKay, J. Bolton, Morris, Swallow, Franklin, Clint Jones, Petrie, Van Berlo, O'Bree

 

[Athomas]

Re: Brownlow Medal

G Ablett 20
L Montagna 19
D Swan 15
N Dal Santo 14
L Hayes 14
C Judd 13
B Goddard 13
A Goodes 12
S Johnson 12
S Mitchell 12
J Selwood 12
J Brown 11


Ablett regains with a 2 imo this week. Swan coming hard!

 

[Big Nasty]

Re: Brownlow Medal

G Ablett 20
L Montagna 19
D Swan 15
N Dal Santo 14
L Hayes 14
C Judd 13
B Goddard 13
A Goodes 12
S Johnson 12
S Mitchell 12
J Selwood 12
J Brown 11


Ablett regains with a 2 imo this week. Swan coming hard!

Who get's the 3 votes then?

 

[Effes]

Re: Brownlow Medal

Has to get 3

Played a genuine game this week, no pissy handballs. Nearly every disposal was damaging as well.

 

[AG]

Re: Brownlow Medal

Dane Swan will be the worst winner of the Brownlow in ages.

 

[fridge21]

Re: Brownlow Medal

can't believe lenny hayes is still $31. simon black into $17, such a good vote getter and has had a really good few weeks now.

judd terrible value.

 

[Athomas]

Re: Brownlow Medal

Who get's the 3 votes then?

Has to get 3

Played a genuine game this week, no pissy handballs. Nearly every disposal was damaging as well.

Rewatched it and awarded him the 3. However, I'm still reluctant as the umps have no love him for the award. Chappy had HEAPS of marks which I think would stick in the umps minds, but Ablett deserves the 3 so yeh.

 

[Athomas]

Re: Brownlow Medal

can't believe lenny hayes is still $31. simon black into $17, such a good vote getter and has had a really good few weeks now.

judd terrible value.

Yeh Hayes is great value! Black has had a worst year then last but will still poll well.

Coleman odds are very interesting.

 

[tarky]

Re: Brownlow Medal

Yeh Hayes is great value! Black has had a worst year then last but will still poll well.

Coleman odds are very interesting.

lecras at 60/1....might be worth a $5 investment

 

[banta]

Re: Brownlow Medal

what votes did people get for the hawks vs eagles game. will big nick naitanui's last quarter get him a vote..
also didn't see any of the kangaroos vs bulldogs game. who played well in that game?
cheers

 

[Jimmy Two Hands]

Re: Brownlow Medal

Sam Mitchell was probably BOG in a losing side. Not sure if Natanui will get votes, maybe 1. He certainly would have got their attention.

As for Dogs/Roos - I didnt see enough of it to give a confident answer. Harding/Petrie were the best for the Roos, Gia and Matty Boyd for the Dogs for me.

 

[Big Nasty]

Re: Brownlow Medal

Once again Swan underrated by a knucklehead, so whats new?

More like Overrated by Collingwood supporters.

 

[AG]

Re: Brownlow Medal

Once again Swan underrated by a knucklehead, so whats new?

Knucklehead? I tore apart VCE and Uni. I just don't like him as a player. If he plays well next week I will probably put him in my AA side so it's not like I'm ignoring him. Just a personal preference that I wouldn't want him to win the Brownlow. I'd like Ablett or Hayes personally.

 

[AG]

Re: Brownlow Medal

nice sig, im sure it still digs inside of you that u lost u thought u had it in the bag hahahaahha SUCK

You are the ultimate pest. A newbie and an unlisted club.

 

[AG]

Re: Brownlow Medal

Hey I'm just saying, if big nasty didn't have the most laughable votes I wouldn't have even said anything...but this is bigfooty so what can you expect

Why are they laughable?

 

[Big Nasty]

Re: Brownlow Medal

Hey I'm just saying, if big nasty didn't have the most laughable votes I wouldn't have even said anything...but this is bigfooty so what can you expect

Where's your Brownlow votes?

It's easy to criticise.

 

[Racing To Win]

Re: Brownlow Medal

Swan is a better player than Goodes and at this stage he has had a much better year than Goodes did either year he won the Brownlow.

The fact that Goodes has won two brownlow votes shows what a joke the system is.

If you doubt me check out this thread:

http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/showthread.php?t=595049

 

[AG]

Re: Brownlow Medal

Swan is a better player than Goodes and at this stage he has had a much better year than Goodes did either year he won the Brownlow.

The fact that Goodes has won two brownlow votes shows what a joke the system is.

If you doubt me check out this thread:

http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/showthread.php?t=595049

Statistics mean stuff all. It's who you remember dominating the game as you leave the stadium. Goodes stands out because he is tall and quick and normally receiving and running towards the 50. He deserved 2006 100%, you could argue he got lucky in 2003 but it wasn't a shock that he won.
To say Swan is a better player than Goodes is a bit of a joke and to say Swan is having a better season compared to Goodes in 2006 is a joke. Goodes and Hall pretty much delivered us a GF appearance that year.

 

[Jonny27]

Re: Brownlow Medal

G Ablett 20
L Montagna 19
D Swan 15
N Dal Santo 14
L Hayes 14
C Judd 13
B Goddard 13
A Goodes 12
S Johnson 12
S Mitchell 12
J Selwood 12
J Brown 11


Ablett regains with a 2 imo this week. Swan coming hard!

Ablett was BOG mate.

 

[Athomas]

Re: Brownlow Medal

Ablett was BOG mate.

As I posted further on, I changed my votes to Ablett 3.